We’re Wasting Billions on a Wall That Will Never Exist

A president with 40% approval is shutting down the government for a project with 40% approval

Sometimes, fault doesn’t matter. Sometimes, a problem just needs to be fixed. But other times, we need to know what went wrong and where the blame lies so we can stop it from happening again.

The current case is of the final instance.

Fortunately, in the Federal Government Shutdown of 2019, the longest federal government shutdown in history, the culprit was proud to take the blame.

President Trump’s shutdown persists because of one contested issue: a border wall between Mexico and the United States — an idea with 58% disapproval, according to Pew Research Center.

Now, I won’t get into why it’s a bad idea; if you want information on that, check out this great piece by Vicky Alvear Shecter.

But for the purposes of the case I’m making here, you should know that if the government shutdown lasts until January 25th, which appears likely considering the slow negotiations, America will have wasted as much money paying for the shutdown as it would have spent funding the border wall to the extent that Trump has requested (source). As of writing this on January 18th, Standard & Poor estimates that the shutdown has cost the American economy $3.6 billion (source).

All of this money spent — and nothing in return.

Now, considering that Democratic leadership likely knows that this loss to our economy is predictable, why don’t they just give in and take a loss for the greater good? Because, for one, building a border wall makes serious insinuations about what our country is supposed to be. And two, giving in to stubbornness sets a horrific precedent, and only encourages more future stubbornness.

Giving in now, though maybe making fiscal sense initially, would lead to a far greater cost in the future.

But what is my larger point here?

My point is that when it comes to the president, character, interpersonal competence, and the actual ability to make deals aren’t just nice skills to have. They are essential pieces of building a workable legislative agenda. Without a functional plan of leadership, people get hurt. Real people get really hurt.

The federal government isn’t a place for games.

I’m not here to point out why the border wall is bad policy, but I am here to point out that even as just proposed policy, it is vastly harmful. Without a single stake being stuck or a shovel being shoved, the sheer idea of a border wall and its use in negotiations is hurting our country in measurable, objective ways.

When 2020 rolls around, we must keep this in mind and try our damndest to not elect an unqualified, immature, petulant, disunifying, stubborn, arrogant, cowardly, and dishonest person to serve in the highest office of the land. We need reasonability in government.

But for now, we will suffer under the leadership we so poorly chose, all the while remembering that every cent wasted in this struggle is 100% preventable.

-Ben Chapman

Ben Chapman is a reporter and commentator in Illinois. He is a student in Food Science and Human Nutrition and ran for his local County Board in 2018. You can stay updated on his commentaries at his Facebook Page and his Twitter.

I write about politics, food, and the environment. My goal is to improve the world through policy. Email me at hi@benchapman.us (https://www.benchapman.us)

Sign up for Zooming Out

By The Bigger Picture

A bird's-eye view of what's happening at The Bigger Picture Take a look.

By signing up, you will create a Medium account if you don’t already have one. Review our Privacy Policy for more information about our privacy practices.

Check your inbox
Medium sent you an email at to complete your subscription.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store