[Cisco] RIP、EIGRP、OSPF 路由協定比較

Kuro Huang
資安工作者的學習之路
2 min readOct 5, 2019

當初考CCNA Routing Switching(200–125) 時候很在意這三大路由協定的差別

上課時的一個RIP 、EIGRP、OSPF 比較:

三大協定簡易比較

我的所有文章目錄: https:kuronetwork.me

EIGRP VS OSPF

EIGRP

  1. Hybrid protocol –Distance vector (first time) Link state (updates)

2. Summarization possible on all the routers.

3. Easy to configure (No area configs) & can separate routes wrt to AS numbers

4. Not much processor oriented as the metric from the neighbor is believed and also feasible successor in place

5. No dependency… like underlying area 0

6. Add as many routers u want, with proper planning and summarization.

7. Easy to design and redesign

8. Only 2 route types (Internal & external)

9. Convergence is faster as the hello:dead = 5:15 & also because of the successor & feasible successor.

10. Supports only md5 authentication

11. Hello/Dead shud not match, helps while making changes

12. Stuck in Active scenario (can be addressed with summarization / stub / disabling active-timers)

13. In modern DMVPN designs, EIGRP has managed tomove past 3500 peers

14. Equal cost load-balancing is possible ! (variance)

15. traffic-share balanced: traffic load balancing according to the cost of the available links.

OSPF

1. Purely a Link state protocol.

2. Summarization possible on ABR & ASBR only.

3. A bit complex to design wrt to areas, as all the OSPF routes gets traverse across OSPF domain.

4. Consumes more resources of the device to run SPF every time a change happens in network.

5. Must have to rely on area 0 to communicate interarea.

6. Adding routers in an area may increase the size of LSBD

7. May be easy to desing, but for redesigning and adding areas, virtual link is required.

8. 11 types of routes (LSAs)

9. Conversion time is higher than EIGRP, hello:dead=10:40

10. Supports clear text & md5 authentication

11. Hello/dead timers shud be the same, bit difficult to make the changes

12. No Stuck in active.

13. Equal cost load-balancing is not possible !

若您喜歡我的文章,歡迎按下「拍手」與Liker按讚給我支持並轉發給你的朋友們(可以多拍幾下手喔),或是「Follow」我,讓我提供更多優質文章給您。

也歡迎繼續閱讀:

讀書心得系列
https://medium.com/blacksecurity/tagged/reading
網路管理系列
https://medium.com/blacksecurity/tagged/network
財務金融系列
https://medium.com/blacksecurity/tagged/finance

--

--

Kuro Huang
資安工作者的學習之路

對教育充滿期待的資安從業者,現任ISC2台北分會理監事成員,喜歡用專業興趣交朋友建立友誼。希望對資安社群盡一點心力,並期望自己與身旁的人能有所進步,歡迎喝咖啡聊資安。希望保持著定期參與資安社群活動。個人介紹 https://portaly.cc/kurohuang