The Truth About Your Writing Competition

Greetings, aspiring authors! Today, I will discuss the realities of your writing competition. People often wonder about their odds of getting published, but the truth is, these odds are hard to quantify. Let’s dive into who you’re actually up against in the pool of writers aiming to get published, focusing on traditional publishing.

Understanding Your Competition

First, let’s define who you are as a writer. If you’re serious about writing novels, completing projects, and pursuing traditional publishing, this discussion is for you. You’re committed to querying, seeking literary representation, and getting published by a traditional publisher. With that in mind, let’s explore your actual competition.

The Pool of Writers

  1. Aspiring Novelists: This includes everyone who wants to write a novel, has an idea for one, or dreams of becoming an author. This pool is massive, but most of these individuals will never start writing.
  2. Those Who Start: Of those who want to write, only a fraction will begin their novel. Let’s assume 50% actually start writing.
  3. Those Who Finish: Among those who start, only about half will complete their novel. So now we have a smaller group of writers who have finished at least one novel.

Quality and Commitment

Completing a novel is an accomplishment, but it doesn’t guarantee quality. Writing is a skill that improves with practice. Many first drafts are not ready for publication and require significant editing. Here’s where we whittle down the competition further:

  • Editing and Revising: Not everyone who finishes a novel will revise it to a publishable standard. Let’s say half of these writers either don’t want to or can’t edit effectively.
  • Serious Writers: Now we have a pool of writers who can finish and revise a novel to a readable quality. These are your peers — writers serious about improving their craft and pursuing traditional publishing.

Traditional vs. Self-Publishing

Next, consider that not all serious writers will pursue traditional publishing. Some will choose self-publishing, which means they are not your direct competition if you aim for traditional routes.

Querying and Representation

Your real competition consists of writers who:

  • Can finish and revise a novel.
  • Aim for traditional publishing.
  • Are actively querying agents.

Even among these writers, many won’t do the necessary research on agents, write effective queries, or have marketable premises. This further narrows your competition to those who have the skill, perseverance, and market awareness to catch an agent’s attention.

The Final Pool

At any given time, the number of serious, skilled writers querying agents is relatively small. If an agent receives 100 queries, perhaps 20–30 are from writers who stand a real chance. This number might be even smaller if some submissions don’t match the agent’s taste or needs.

Conclusion

While the initial pool of aspiring writers is vast, your actual competition is much smaller. Focus on improving your writing, crafting compelling queries, and understanding the market. Persistence is key. The longer you stay in the game, the better your chances of success. Keep writing, keep learning, and don’t give up. Your dedication will set you apart from the crowd.

This overview aims to provide a realistic perspective on your writing competition and inspire you to continue honing your craft. Remember, the road to publication is challenging, but your perseverance will pay off. Good luck on your writing journey!

--

--

J.D. Myall
Craft Chat: Resources and Writing Advice from Drexel MFA Alumni.

Author, Writer’s Digest & Huffington Post Contributor, Literary Lunatic, Pop Culture Fan-girl. Lover of all things chocolate or sparkly. jdmyall@gmail.com