Featured Image

Closing Credit Cards: Smart Move or Credit Hazard?

Thinking about closing credit cards is beneficial and when it’s not.

Marcus Whitmore
Credit Sense: Managing Loans and Debts
3 min readDec 17, 2023

--

Pondering over whether to shut down your credit cards? This choice isn’t black and white. In this piece, we’ll explore the impact of closing credit cards on your credit score and overall financial health. Credit cards are a paradox — they bring ease and perks, yet can also usher in debt and monetary worry. Hence, when faced with the significant decision of closing them, it’s vital to judiciously consider the advantages and drawbacks.

Understanding the Consequences of Shutting Down Credit Cards

Choosing to terminate your credit cards is more than just discarding the plastic; it’s a matter of grasping the fiscal outcomes. Let’s dissect the potential risks and rewards:

  • Risk to Credit Score: Eliminating a card could raise your credit use ratio, potentially diminishing your score. This effect is often short-lived and can be lessened by decreasing balances on other cards.
  • Debt Management: For some individuals, closing cards may lessen the urge to spend excessively, thus aiding in better debt management.
  • Importance of Account Longevity: Older accounts positively impact your credit history. Closing age-old cards might reduce your average credit age, possibly influencing your score.
  • Security Advantages: Fewer cards equate to a diminished risk of fraud. Consider the Target data breaches — reducing your active cards can protect against such security risks.
  • Annual Fees: If the benefits don’t justify the high annual fees of certain cards, they might not be worth retaining.
  • Reward Churning: A strategy involving closing cards post-earning sign-up rewards. This needs careful thought as it can impact your credit score.

Every decision to close a credit card should be customized to your specific financial context. Weigh these factors in their entirety, considering both immediate and long-term effects for a comprehensive decision-making process.

Practical Considerations

Delving further into the nuanced practicalities of closing credit cards:

  • Spending Pattern Analysis: Reflect on your expenditure habits. If possessing multiple cards encourages extravagant spending, it might be wise to close some.
  • Emergency Funds Consideration: Retaining a couple of cards for emergency situations can offer a financial buffer, particularly if your savings aren’t substantial.
  • Future Financial Objectives: Planning significant fiscal ventures like home purchases necessitates a solid credit score. Contemplate the potential effects of card closures on such plans.
  • Alternatives to Full Closure: Rather than completely shutting down accounts, you might think about locking away the cards or physically cutting them up, while keeping the accounts active for the sake of your credit history.
  • Diverse Credit Portfolio and Utilization: It’s advantageous to maintain a mix of different credit forms (like loans, mortgages, etc.) and ensure a low credit utilization rate.

Keep in mind, a universal solution doesn’t exist. Your individual financial circumstances and objectives should steer your decision regarding the closure of credit cards.

Remarks

In the end, choosing to shut down a credit card is an individual decision, shaped by your fiscal behaviors and aims. It’s critical to ponder over the repercussions on your credit rating, the possibility of extravagant spending, and the significance of maintaining an emergency reserve. Wise financial stewardship involves making educated decisions that are in harmony with your personal and enduring financial well-being.

FAQs

  • Will closing a credit card affect my credit score? Yes, it can impact your score, but the effect is often temporary.
  • Should I close a credit card with a high annual fee? If you’re not using the benefits, closing such a card could save you money.
  • What should I consider before closing a credit card? Consider your spending habits, credit score, account age, and future financial goals.
  • Is it better to close a credit card or keep it open? It depends on your personal financial situation and goals.
  • How can closing credit cards impact my debt management? For some, it can help reduce the temptation to overspend, aiding in better debt control.

Originally published on SmartFinance.life.

--

--

Marcus Whitmore
Credit Sense: Managing Loans and Debts

Finance expert certified in personal coaching, shares practical tips on achieving financial freedom, smart investing, and growing online income.