Walking the Line Between Customer Love and Business Growth
The DCX Newsletter is a reader-supported publication. Please consider joining the community as a paid subscriber to support the continued creation of posts like this.
It’s 5:17 PM on a Friday. The office is nearly empty, but you’re still at your desk, staring at an email that just landed in your inbox.
Subject line: “URGENT: Executive Escalation — Disappointed VIP Customer.”
As you open the email, your phone pings with a Slack message from your CFO: “Great job on Q3 numbers. Remember our 15% growth target this quarter.”
Your heart sinks. You’ve been here before, poised on the precipice between customer satisfaction and business realities.
Welcome to the high-wire act of Customer Experience.
Customer Experience has evolved from a simple service function to a core business strategy. Yet, as CX professionals, we often find ourselves caught between two seemingly opposing forces:
- The drive to create genuine value for customers
- The pressure to meet ever-increasing financial targets
This tension raises a crucial question: How do you balance customer satisfaction with business objectives?
You start to consider the practices that have become the norm:
Your mind wanders to the idealism that first drew you to CX. The dreams of making a difference, of being the customer’s champion in a world of faceless corporations. But now, those dreams seem to flicker in the harsh fluorescent light of your office.
I see this a lot-customer needs and profit motives colliding. So, I developed the BALANCE framework, which I hope will emerge as a steadying force. Born from years of grappling with the same dilemmas you face, this framework offers a new perspective-a way to align customer satisfaction with business success rather than viewing them as opposing forces.
At its core, BALANCE represents seven crucial aspects of customer-centric business practices:
B — Business Transparency
A — Authentic Value Creation
L — Long-term Relationship Focus
A — Actionable Feedback Loop
N — Needs-Based Innovation
C — Customer Empowerment
Each component of this framework offers a lens through which you can examine and refine your CX strategies. By applying these principles, you’ll find new ways to serve your customers and your business with integrity and purpose.
Let’s explore each element and see how they address the real-world challenges you face daily:
B — Business Transparency
Customers see through corporate smokescreens. They demand honesty. Remember that angry email about your AI-driven recommendations? Imagine if you’d proactively explained how your system works and why it makes certain suggestions. Transparency isn’t just ethical — it’s a powerful trust-builder.
Take Everlane, the clothing retailer. They’ve built their brand on “radical transparency,” breaking down the cost of each item they sell. This approach has built trust and justified their pricing, leading to a loyal customer base that understands the value they’re getting.
Action step: Next time you implement a new feature or policy, explain the ‘why’ behind it to your customers. You might be surprised at how understanding they can be when they see the full picture.
A — Authentic Value Creation
Creating genuine value transcends the simple exchange of goods or services for money. It’s about tangibly improving your customers’ lives. Remember that VIP customer’s escalation email? They likely felt shortchanged on value, not just unsatisfied with a product.
Zoom’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic exemplifies authentic value creation. As remote work surged, Zoom didn’t just sell video conferencing — they provided free accounts to K-12 schools globally. This move supported education, built goodwill, and ultimately led to massive growth as users experienced the platform’s value firsthand.
Action step: Review your recent customer escalations. Identify patterns where customers feel they’re not getting enough value. Then, brainstorm ways to enhance your offering that go beyond your core product. Could you provide educational resources, community forums, or complementary services that genuinely improve your customers’ lives or work?
L — Long-term Relationship Focus
Under pressure to meet quarterly targets, it’s easy to lose sight of the long game. However, building lasting customer relationships sustains a business over time.
Costco exemplifies this principle. Their customer-friendly policies, like their generous return policy, might seem costly in the short term. But they’ve resulted in a 90+% membership renewal rate, creating a stable revenue base that’s the envy of the retail world.
Action step: When faced with a customer issue, like the VIP escalation in your inbox, ask yourself: “What action will build a stronger relationship five years from now?” Sometimes, sacrificing short-term profit for long-term loyalty is the wisest business decision.
A — Actionable Feedback Loop
Listening to customers is good, but acting on their feedback truly moves the needle. Remember that chatbot that’s frustrating your elderly customers? That’s what happens when we implement solutions without continuously incorporating user feedback.
Starbucks’ “My Starbucks Idea” platform is a prime example of closing the feedback loop. The platform encouraged customers to share their ideas for improving Starbucks’ offerings, resulting in over 150,000 suggestions within its first five years. This improved their offerings and made customers feel heard and valued.
Action step: Implement a system for reviewing and acting on customer feedback regularly. Make it a KPI for your team to implement a certain number of customer suggestions each quarter.
N — Needs-Based Innovation
True innovation springs from a deep understanding of customer needs, not from chasing competitors or implementing technology for its own sake. Remember that frustrated elderly customer struggling with your chatbot? That’s what happens when we innovate without truly understanding user needs.
Slack exemplifies needs-based innovation. Originally an internal tool for a gaming company, It was born from the team’s need for better communication. By focusing on user pain points in workplace collaboration, Slack created a platform that transformed how teams work. Their continuous improvements, like threaded conversations and app integrations, all stem from observing and responding to how people actually use the tool, increasing stickiness and customer productivity.
Action step: Before your next product update or feature release, shadow your customers. Spend a day in their shoes, using your product as they do. Identify friction points and unspoken needs. Let these real-world insights, not just internal ideas or market trends, drive your innovation. Could this approach have prevented your chatbot from frustrating elderly users?
C — Customer Empowerment
Empowering customers means giving them control over their experience with your brand. It’s about creating options, not limitations.
Netflix’s “Skip Intro” feature is a simple yet powerful example of customer empowerment. It gives viewers control over content consumption, enhancing their experience without compromising Netflix’s core offering.
Action step: Identify areas where you can give customers more control. Could you offer more flexible subscription options, more customization in your product, or more self-service features that solve problems?
E — Ethical Data Usage
In an age of data breaches and privacy concerns, using customer data responsibly is crucial. It’s not just about compliance — it’s about building trust.
Beyond its famous “Don’t Buy This Jacket” campaign, Patagonia provides detailed information about its supply chain. This transparency extends to how it uses customer data, builds trust, and aligns with its environmentally conscious customer base.
Action step: Review your data practices. Are you collecting only what’s necessary? Are you using it in ways that genuinely benefit the customer, not just your bottom line? Communicate your data practices clearly to your customers.
By applying these BALANCE principles, you’re building a bridge between customer needs and business objectives-You’re creating a business model where serving your customers’ best interests naturally leads to sustainable growth and profitability.
As you turn back to that urgent email in your inbox, you have a new lens through which to view the situation. How can you address this VIP’s concerns in a transparent way, create authentic value, build a long-term relationship, incorporate feedback, address real needs, empower the customer, and use data ethically?
The path forward may not be easy, but with BALANCE as your guide, you can confidently navigate these choppy waters, knowing you’re building a customer experience that’s both genuinely helpful and sustainably profitable.
Start Implementing the BALANCE framework by conducting a BALANCE audit of your current CX initiatives. Be honest in your assessment. Where are you excelling? Where do you see room for improvement?
Next, engage your team in open discussions about the tension between customer needs and business demands. Create a safe space for sharing doubts and aspirations.
Finally, concrete goals for each element of the BALANCE framework should be set. These could be as simple as increasing transparency in one area of your business or implementing a new system for acting on customer feedback.
As CX professionals, we can transform customer experience from a business function into a force for good. By applying the BALANCE framework, we can create experiences that are not only profitable but also genuinely beneficial to our customers.
The future of CX lies in finding harmony between business objectives and human needs. It’s about creating value that resonates on both a financial and a personal level.
So, as you return to that urgent email in your inbox, remember that you’re not just resolving a customer issue. You’re taking another step towards a more balanced, authentic, and human-centric approach to customer experience.
The journey will not be easy, but the impact could be profound. Are you ready to lead the charge toward a more balanced future for CX?
Applying BALANCE: The Moment of Truth
Picture this: You’re in the boardroom. Suits surround you. The air is thick with expectations. You’re about to propose your next big CX initiative. But this time, it’s different.
You feel confident because in developing your initiative, you used the BALANCE framework as a litmus test, asking yourself these critical questions:
By systematically addressing these questions, you know that you’ve crafted an initiative that promises business results and aligns with your commitment to customer-centric practices.
To illustrate how this might work in practice, let’s consider a hypothetical scenario:
You’re proposing a new AI-powered personalization engine for your e-commerce platform. Here’s how you’ve applied the BALANCE framework:
By framing your initiative through the lens of BALANCE, you’re not just pitching a new feature — you’re proposing a strategic shift towards more ethical, customer-centric practices that drive business results.
This approach transforms the conversation from a simple ROI discussion to a deeper dialogue about building sustainable, mutually beneficial customer relationships. It positions you as a CX professional and a strategic leader driving long-term business success through customer-centric innovation.
👉 If you enjoyed this newsletter and value this work, please consider forwarding it to your friends and colleagues or sharing on social media.
I want to share some of the exciting content and programs that I have created for your personal and professional growth:
30 Days to Greater Influence — a email course crafted specifically for customer-obsessed leaders like us.
DCX Executive Coaching — 1:1 coaching for customer-obsessed leaders (Mention DCX for 50% off the first three months)
The Daily Challenge SMS Service — Daily text messages designed to uplift your spirit, remind you of your worth, and inspire you to keep going, no matter what. — 7-Day FREE Trial
365 Days of Accountability — Accountability Books, Journals, and Exercises
I hope you find these programs useful. Let me know if you have any questions or need any further assistance.
-Mark
Originally published at https://digitalcx.substack.com.
