Defamation Law
Published in

Defamation Law

Q: Can I Sue Someone For Posting A Review About My Business?

Yelp/ Youtube reviews have become ubiquitous. Almost every business gets reviewed, some positive and some negative. While positive reviews are always welcomed, negative reviews scorn some business owners to the extent that they contact us for legal advice.

Photo by Eaters Collective on Unsplash

Here’s a hypothetical situation.

Prospective client: “I want to sue them!”

Why?

Prospective client: “They wrote a negative review about my business. This is defamation!

Well, only reviews which have false assertion of facts are defamatory, other statements are mere opinions.

Prospective client: “So they can write whatever they want to about me and my business, I am losing money!

If the statement of facts are not false and the only offending statement is that they do not like your product, goods, services, etc. then such speech is an opinion and is protected under the First Amendment.

Prospective client: “What if I still sue them? That will force them to remove the review, right?

Wrong. In most states, including California, anti-SLAPP statutes protect the free speech rights of the speaker. If the lawsuit is frivolous, you will have to pay the legal fees of the opposing counsel when the case gets dismissed.

Prospective client: “So I do not have any recourse?

While we empathize with you and understand how negative reviews affect your business, only false assertions of facts (and conclusions drawn from them) are defamatory. So the first thing one may want to do is to ensure whether any statement of fact is false. If no false assertion is made, and the only offending statements are those that are the subjective opinion of the speaker, then such statements are not defamatory.

As an example, if the speaker states, “I went to xyz restaurant, and the restaurant is dirty. Do not go here,” these statements are a subjective opinion and not defamatory. However, if the statements included additional facts justifying why the speaker perceived the restaurant to be dirty, if those additional statements are factually false (e.g., the server threw garbage on the floor causing a health hazard) then the review can be defamatory.

--

--

--

Weekly publication. Ask a defamation related question. Your question will be anonymized and generalized. Public answer provided for educational and informational purposes only. No attorney-client relationship formed by using this service. Not a substitute for legal advice.

Recommended from Medium

HOW TO make a successful challenge???

PR 2021: Top 4 Basic Tips for Start-Ups to Pitch and Get Published

Overhead view on a desk, with a laptop wzh pink screen, an e-ink writer from boox, a pen, an orange and a smartphone on it. Someones typing on the laptop.

How to Hire and Evaluate an All-Star Startup Marketer: 7 Questions to Consider

How Slack Created An “Enemy” to Promote Their Product: A Lesson in Copywriting

4 Website Design Choices that Help Inbound Marketing

Done For You Services System By Ariella Review

Pricing Strategies-Yikes!

AdSigner in Google analytics

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Rohit Chhabra

Rohit Chhabra

Patent & Defamation Attorney https://www.clfip.com

More from Medium

The Broken Window Fallacy, Planned Obsolescence, and a New Way for Consumer Technology.

The Butterfly Effect and Its Relatives Help Us Understand Our World

Lack of Transparency in Higher Education

Legacy Goes to SXSW to Talk About Sperm…