Member-only story
Neural Nostalgia: Why AI Keeps Remixing the Past — and What That Means for Culture
Instead of being a launchpad to entirely new worlds, a lot of what AI produces feels strangely… familiar. You’ve probably noticed: AI art often mimics the brushstrokes of Van Gogh, the glitchy vibes of early internet aesthetics, or the synth-heavy soundscapes of the 1980s. Even AI-written stories tend to lean into tired tropes or nostalgic fanfic vibes.
So here’s the big question: Is AI inherently backward-looking? And in doing so, are we training our tools to make us sentimental but stagnant?
Let’s unpack that through a cultural, technological, and theoretical lens.
Media as Memory: Why the Past Has Such a Strong Grip
Media theorist Marshall McLuhan famously said, “We look at the present through a rear-view mirror. We march backward into the future.” In other words, when we encounter new technologies, we often use them to replicate or reinterpret what we already know.
This is especially true for AI. Whether it’s DALL·E generating a “cyberpunk Mona Lisa” or ChatGPT writing poetry in Shakespearean English, our tools are leaning heavily on patterns from the past.
Why? Because that’s exactly what they’re trained to do.
