Selected Articles from the Major Economic History Journals
By choosing 6 articles from some of the journals given in this blog post, If you had to follow only one of those journals, which one would you like choose? Why?” and for each of the 6 articles “research question/s, methodology, main results, why did you particularly choose this article? Explanation the reason behind it” were answered.
Article 1 — Regional inequalities and the West-East divide in Turkey since
1913
1)Research Question/s
The research question of the article titled “Regional inequalities and the West-East divide in Turkey since 1913” is: How has the regional economic inequality in Turkey evolved over time and what are the factors that have contributed to the West-East divide in the country since 1913?
2) Methodology
The article analyzes regional inequalities and the West-East divide in Turkey since 1913 by examining changes in economic indicators across different regions, such as income and education levels. The methodology involves collecting and analyzing data from various sources, including national statistics and surveys, to identify trends and patterns in regional disparities over time. The article also provides historical context and explores the political and social factors that contribute to regional inequalities in Turkey.
3) Main Result
The article examines the economic and social disparities between the western and eastern regions of Turkey. The authors utilize a comprehensive dataset to track various indicators of development such as income, education, and health outcomes over the past century.
The main result of the study is that the gap between the two regions has significantly narrowed over time, but still remains substantial. The authors argue that the primary drivers of this trend have been government policies focused on industrialization and modernization, as well as improvements in transportation infrastructure and communication technologies.
However, the authors also note that the persistence of regional inequalities has important political and social implications, as it has contributed to a sense of marginalization and resentment among certain groups in the eastern region. They argue that addressing these disparities should be a key priority for policymakers in Turkey, in order to ensure that all citizens have access to the opportunities and benefits of a rapidly developing economy.
4) The reason why I chose the article.
I did not choose this article specifically for any personal reasons. I thought the title of the article might be useful to me. I got very bored while reading the content of the article.
Link for article :https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ehr.13245
Article 2-War, pandemics, and modern economic growth in Europe
1)Research Question/s
How have wars and pandemics impacted modern economic growth in Europe, and to what extent have these events contributed to the development of modern economies in the region?
2) Methodology
The article uses a quantitative approach to examine the impact of wars and pandemics on economic growth in Europe from 1300 to 2016. The authors analyze a large dataset of historical events and economic indicators, using statistical methods to investigate the causal relationship between shocks and economic development.
3) Main Result
The article explores the impact of war and pandemics on economic growth in Europe between the 14th and 19th centuries. The authors find that these events had short-term negative effects on economic growth but also led to long-term benefits. War contributed to technological innovation and modernization, while pandemics led to improvements in public health and sanitation, which fostered economic growth. The study highlights the complex relationship between these events and economic growth, underscoring the importance of understanding historical contexts to inform economic policy.
4) The reason why I chose the article
Analysis of the historical relationship between pandemics, war, and economic growth, which has become particularly relevant in light of the COVID-19 pandemic and its economic impact. Additionally, the article offers insights into how seemingly negative events can lead to positive outcomes over the long term.
Link for article: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0014498322000456
Article 3- Why we shouldn’t measure women’s labour force participation in pre-industrial countries
1)Research Question/s
Should labor force participation rates of women in pre-industrial societies be measured using modern definitions and methodologies? / Should modern definitions of labor force participation be applied to analyze historical data on women’s work in pre-industrial societies?
2) Methodology
The article uses a qualitative approach, drawing on historical data, literature, and feminist theory to examine the limitations of applying modern labor force participation definitions and methodologies to analyze women’s work in pre-industrial societies. The authors propose alternative approaches that consider the social, cultural, and economic contexts of women’s work.
3) Main Result
The article argues that measuring women’s labor force participation in pre-industrial countries using modern definitions and methods can lead to incorrect conclusions. The study suggests that pre-industrial societies had different economic systems and gender roles, making it difficult to measure women’s economic activities using modern concepts. The main result of the article is that modern methods of measuring labor force participation are not suitable for pre-industrial societies and that using such methods can lead to inaccurate and misleading conclusions about women’s economic activities in these societies. The article suggests that alternative methods and frameworks should be used to understand the economic activities of women in pre-industrial societies.
4) The reason why I chose the article
The article provides a more nuanced understanding of women’s contributions in preindustrial societies, which is an important area of research. Although this subject is important for our country, I chose it because I had no knowledge.
Link for article:
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/epdf/10.1080/20780389.2021.1929602?needAccess=true&r ole=button
Article 4-Economics of the crisis and the crisis of economics
1)Research Question/s
The research questions of this article are:
1-What are the causes and consequences of the recent economic crisis?
2-How has mainstream economics contributed to or failed to address the crisis?
3-What are the limitations of mainstream economics in understanding and dealing with the crisis?
4-What alternative theoretical and policy approaches can help address the crisis and promote sustainable and equitable economic development?
2) Methodology
The methodology of the article involves a critical review of the existing literature and empirical evidence on the recent economic crisis and mainstream economics. The authors analyze academic articles, reports, and books to identify the limitations of mainstream economics in understanding and addressing the crisis. The article also explores alternative theoretical and policy frameworks for promoting sustainable and equitable economic development.
3) Main Result
This article critiques mainstream economic theories and policies in the context of the recent economic crisis. It argues that the crisis exposed the limitations of neoclassical economics and proposes alternative frameworks, such as post-Keynesian, institutional, and ecological economics. The article concludes that addressing the crisis requires a fundamental rethinking of economics as a discipline, and a more pluralistic and interdisciplinary approach to economic research and policymaking.
4) The reason why I chose the article
Only the title of the article caught my attention.
Link for the article :
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09672567.2014.927519?scroll=top&needAcce ss=true&role=tab
Article 5- Optimism or pessimism? A composite view on English living standards during the Industrial Revolution
1)Research Question/s
What was the impact of the Industrial Revolution on the living standards of the English population, and can a composite view of different indicators provide a more accurate assessment of this impact?
2) Methodology
The article uses a quantitative approach to construct a composite view of English living standards during the Industrial Revolution. The authors analyze a range of historical data, including real wages, height, and mortality rates, using statistical methods to assess changes in living standards over time.
3) Main Result
The article finds that living standards in England during the Industrial Revolution improved in many areas, including food availability, nutrition, and urbanization. However, the authors also identify areas where living standards did not improve, such as child mortality and inequality. The authors propose a composite index of well-being as a way of capturing the complex changes in living standards during this period, and conclude that the overall impact of the Industrial Revolution on living standards was positive, but with important caveats.
4) The reason why I chose the article
This article seemed to explore issue of living standards during the Industrial
Revolution in England. That’s why I chose .
Article Link : https://academic.oup.com/ereh/article/25/1/1/5827898
Article 6-Fifty years of African economic history
1)Research Question/s
What are the major trends, debates, and challenges in African economic history over the past 50 years, and what are the future research directions and policy implications?
2) Methodology
The article uses a literature review methodology to analyze the major themes, debates, and contributions of African economic history scholarship over the past 50 years. The authors draw on a wide range of sources to identify gaps, challenges, and future research directions.
3) Main Result
The article “Fifty years of African economic history” provides a comprehensive review of the major trends, debates, and challenges in African economic history scholarship over the past 50 years. The authors highlight the significant contributions that have been made to understanding the economic development of the continent, but also identify several important research gaps and challenges that remain. These include the need for more interdisciplinary approaches, engagement with debates in global economic history, and addressing issues of data availability and quality. The authors also suggest future directions for the field, including greater attention to the role of institutions, the impact of colonialism, and the influence of natural resources on economic development.
4) The reason why I chose the article
This article provides a comprehensive review of African economic history, and I was curious because of the increasing African refugee situation in our country in recent years.
Link fort he article :
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/20780389.2019.1575589?scroll=top&needAcc ess=true&role=tab
If you had to follow only one of those journals, which one would you like choose? Why?
I am not sure about this question. But I would probably choose the article “Why we shouldn’t measure women’s labor force participation in pre-industrial countries”. Because as a woman, I was always curious about the place of women in the workforce.
