Published in


The Self-Justifiathan Vs. The Fugue

“I swear my justification is based on SOMETHING!”

My main interest right now is to use the core of cognition to talk about the broad range of social shapes that are available to us as a species, or as a part of a broader ecosystem. The shapes of society should help us accomplish what makes a mind worth having, or what makes life worth living. The shapes of society are inherently loopy, as they rest on the beliefs of what we all think about ourselves.

A common theme for me is the concept of “rules,” and social shapes as “games.” So here I am musing on fugues, and how the rules in a fugue make it beautiful: make the artistry better. When it comes to rules of society, or rules in a game, or rules of nature, or any kind of rules, these musical rules are justified in terms of their ability to bring about greater musical value. These rules make life and mind more brilliant. They contribute to the peaks of the mind, of expression…and I could imagine a small-scale “ruler” such as a music teacher justified in their musical authority to teach me how to compose a fugue. But it wouldn’t be coercive authority. It would be just a higher level of awareness about why the rules exist and how to use them and what the value of them are. This is way different than the justification of large scale “self-justifiathans” as I like to call them. Large coercive rulers are self-justifying. Large territories with coercive rulers (a Leviathan, as Hobbes calls it) bend society to the ruler’s maladaptions, and by doing so, create the behavior and the beliefs that justifies their rule-making.

The rules of the fugue lead to what makes life worth living, whereas the rules of the self-justifiathan are just unexamined maladaptations playing out as rules that create more monsters.

Fugue that!

We envision a voluntary world and are committed to helping you get there.

Recommended from Medium

The Fact-Opinion Dichotomy

Socialist Fantasies and the Escape from Nature’s Prison


A Philosophy Against I: Mistaken Identity and True Selves

My Definition of Anarchism

The Plague and Our Plague

The Red Herring of Michael Oakeshott’s “Conservative Character”

We Need To Finally Break Free Of The Engineering Mindset

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Vanessa Molano

Vanessa Molano

Vanessa Molano is a philosophical entertainer, putting on shows about strange loops, social structures, and what makes life worth living. Empathematics.com

More from Medium

Beyond the Imagination: Zoos in Conservation

People, Policy, and Power: A Love Letter to Civics Educators…and Folks Who Oppose Fascism

The 24th (and The Changes Brought About via Some Mushrooms.)

Are social networks connecting or dividing us?