ProgPoW, Sha-3, Dag, Oh My! — Changing the Ethereum Classic PoW Algorithm

Stevan Lohja
Nov 26 · 3 min read

Ethereum Classic core developers and stakeholders participated in a public call Thursday, November 21, 2019, at 1 pm UTC [1] to discuss proposals to change the Proof of Work (PoW) algorithm.

Miners in a PoW system use GPUs or ASICs running computational cycles to solve a math problem with the goal of reaching a set number previously provided to them. This set number is called a “target”, which is an Ethash hash and the “difficulty” of this “target”. Ethereum Classic and Ethereum are born from the same Ethash PoW mining algorithm and there are many more PoW algorithms used throughout the cryptocurrency space.

Ethash is the current status quo PoW algorithm for Ethereum Classic. However, the below have been proposed and being debated:

  • ECIP-1070 — ProgPoW: Programmable Proof of Work [2]
  • ECIP-1049 — Keccak-256: A variant of the Sha3–256 algorithm. [3]
  • ECIP-1043 — Restrict the Dag: Restrict the size of the Dag in Ethash. [4]
  • ECIP-1047 — Reduce Gas Limit: Reduce the gas limit by 8x [5]
  • No change, keep Ethash.

In short summary, there was progress. ProgPoW was officially rejected and Keccak-256 is inconclusive.

ECIP-1070 — ProgPoW 👎

ProgPoW is a proof-of-work algorithm designed to close the efficiency gap available to specialized ASICs.

ECIP-1049 — Keccak-256 🤔

Keccak-256 is designed to be more secure than Sha-256 and more performant.

In fact, Ethash’s underlining algorithm is based on Keccak-256.

Ethash —📌

Ethash remains the current status quo as there was no concrete decision to accept an alternative algorithm.

As mentioned above, Ethash = (Keccak-256 + Dag). The Dag contributed memory intensity to the PoW algorithm which was said to be an ASIC resistant feature. However, Ethash ASICs exist and the Dag failed to prevent them. The Dag, as well as Ethereum Ice Age, are arguably bias designs to influence the network to move to Proof of Stake.

In May of 2018, the Ethereum Classic network defused the difficulty bomb.

The following did not have enough time to discuss:

  • ECIP-1043 — Restrict the Dag: Restrict the size of the Dag in Ethash.
  • ECIP-1047 — Reduce Gas Limit: Reduce the gas limit by 8x

Conclusion

ProgPoW is officially rejected and the Ethereum Classic community and core developers continue to discuss features and upgrades, but not limited to algorithm changes.


Listen to the full meeting 🎬

#3 Ethereum Classic Core Devs Meeting — Changing the mining algorithm [2019–11–21]

etc-core

A leading Ethereum Classic core development team.

Stevan Lohja

Written by

Technology Coordinator at ETC Core. Previously Tech Writer at ETCDEV.

etc-core

etc-core

A leading Ethereum Classic core development team.

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade