10 Criteria for Choosing the Right Software Development Company

Hayk Petrosyan
ETEAM
Published in
9 min readAug 22, 2023
A company choosing the right software development company.

As a tech decision-maker, you likely face considerable stress. This pressure intensifies when dealing with tailor-made software, which must perfectly align with your business. With over 28,000 custom software development firms listed on Clutch, picking the right fit becomes a challenge, as you want to avoid lengthy research.

Countless software development horror tales circulate online. These range from unprofessional vendors burdening clients with hidden charges to projects spoiled by frequent team changes or severe budget overruns.

Employing specific criteria to vet companies can quicken your search and ensure a favorable outsourcing experience. This article compiles essential factors that distinguish top-performing custom development firms from the rest, offering a guide for your selection process.

How can custom software development give your business that extra edge?

Custom software development entails a lasting partnership. Crafting a solution tailored to your unique needs, objectives, and user base assumes avoiding frequent provider shifts. View the process of selecting and finalizing a software development company as a fundamental aspect of your business strategy, on par with crucial KPIs and metrics.

Although off-the-shelf solutions might offer apparent quick fixes, they rarely deliver the required processing power, storage, or scalability essential for your business’s expansion. Even if they do, the cost tends to grow exponentially. What initially seems inexpensive transforms into a substantial cost with the addition of users, high-volume transactions, or services.

Despite the appeal of ready-made solutions, custom software development retains its status as a primary competitive edge for companies navigating a saturated marketplace.

Access to third-party resources, expertise, and support

Collaborating with a custom software development company grants you access to a broader array of resources and assistance than what many in-house teams can manage.

Furthermore, you can harness the knowledge of professionals who have engaged in various projects and technologies, leveraging their insights for your benefit. Often, the most promising ideas emerge from the synergy of diverse minds pooling their varied experiences.

Tailored software products

Custom application development empowers businesses to gain an edge over competitors by crafting software products that cater to previously unaddressed user requirements.

In the United States, the custom software development sector anticipates a yearly growth rate of 19.4% by 2030, with enterprise software spearheading the expansion.

The appeal of custom software stems from its capacity to grant a competitive advantage. Through tailor-made solutions, companies can introduce fresh and unexpected features or seamlessly integrate with existing systems more effectively than other available products.

Bar chart predicting the US custom software development market evolution between 2020–2030.

Better scalability, security, and compliance

Custom software is designed with growth and scalability in mind right from the beginning. It also grants businesses the ability to enforce additional security measures that off-the-shelf solutions often overlook. These measures can span from highly specialized access control to strengthened network security.

Given its alignment with industry-specific demands, custom software simplifies compliance with regulatory standards and minimizes the risk of substantial penalties.

Finding custom software development services providers

Before embarking on your search, it’s helpful to have a general outline of your requirements and project goals. You don’t need to have all the details ironed out at this stage; many custom development companies offer product discovery services to refine specifications later.

Still, having a basic list of objectives helps in evaluating whether the companies you come across match your expertise needs.

Key aspects to consider might include:

  • Roles and responsibilities needed in your team (e.g., Project Manager)
  • Intended tech stack and application complexity
  • Project timeline, milestones, and budget
  • Preferred communication method and frequency of updates

Once your requirements are outlined, the initial step involves collecting a list of potential software development companies. Numerous routes can be explored for online research in this regard.

Ratings & reviews directories

Websites such as Clutch, GoodFirms, and DesignRush offer valuable insights into the activities of development companies. These platforms allow you to assess a company’s profile, including its services and past projects, along with client reviews and testimonials.

Additionally, some of these platforms provide curated selections of software development companies, categorized by factors like location, technologies, or services offered. By utilizing filters such as project scope or average hourly rate, you can refine your search effectively.

Clutch widget featuring criteria to choose a software development company.

Google research

To identify suitable software development companies, you can use relevant keywords that match your business needs.

For instance, utilizing phrases like “fintech development companies” or “fintech development companies with expertise in machine learning” can yield both organic and paid search results tailored to your criteria.

Alternatively, if your requirements are still evolving, opting for more broad search terms such as “software development company” can help you explore various options.

Technology publications, blogs, and social media

A reputable software development company excels in its field by effectively speaking about development topics in a clear and engaging manner. They actively contribute to the community through articles, guides, and valuable content.

By staying informed through technology publications and blogs, you can come across insightful content that resonates with you. This content could very well be created by a potential development partner for your next project.

Choosing the right software development company

With the collected information and a substantial list of prospective companies at your disposal, it’s time to refine your choices. While an impressive portfolio, favorable client feedback, and valuable content are certainly important, they alone may not suffice to create impactful custom software.

Consider the following 10 crucial elements as you narrow down your selection of the top custom development companies for your software endeavor.

1. Look for these 3 types of expertise

Expertise stands as a key factor in assessing software vendors, yet their capabilities must be tailored to align with your business and application needs. A potential vendor should possess three distinct forms of expertise:

  • Technical Expertise: For instance, if your aim is Android app development, focus on companies specializing in Android. The quality surpasses quantity in importance. Be cautious of vendors that offer services across numerous tech stacks. Opt for vendors certified in your chosen technology or with a successful history of projects built using it (you might even test some applications from their portfolio that are publicly available).
  • Industry Expertise: Custom software’s importance lies in gaining a competitive edge. Achieving this is challenging if the development company lacks familiarity with your industry. Collaborating with domain experts assures compliance with industry regulations. Beyond that, it facilitates quicker feature delivery and harnesses domain knowledge to craft innovative solutions.
  • Custom Application Development Expertise: Building intricate applications differs from website creation or plugin coding. Software providers must have transparent processes and a comprehensive software product development approach. This encompasses pre-launch assessments, post-launch maintenance, and ongoing support. Their development methodology should cater to the unique nuances and challenges that come with custom software.
Venn diagram showing the three types of expertise a custom software development company has to have.

2. Understand their workflows & tools

Processes and tools form the foundation of software development, shaping the core of your application. Familiarize yourself with the vendor’s working style and chosen approach, whether it’s Scrum, Rapid Application Development, or any other Agile methodology.

Gain insight into their frequency of code deployment.

Do they integrate automation or other tools to optimize their development process?

The rise of AI-powered tools and coding assistants has enhanced development productivity and effectiveness. The chosen company should demonstrate a keen interest in staying up-to-date with the latest technologies, both externally and internally, encompassing tools and methodologies.

3. Assess their project management style

The custom software development journey includes multiple stages and collaborative efforts, spanning from requirement validation to launch preparation. Seamless communication with your development partner throughout this entire process is vital for achieving success.

Prioritize a software development company that places priority on transparency, offering consistent status updates and involving you in decision-making.

Look for a project management approach that’s proactive and emphasizes keeping communication channels accessible at all times. This includes the possibility of regular demos and frequent exchanges of feedback.

Examine the team’s approach to managing their development workflow, surrounding daily stand-ups, sprint retrospectives, and the tools they utilize for project management.

4. Check security practices

When collaborating with a software development company, the sharing of sensitive data is inevitable. Before entrusting them with such information, it’s critical to assess their security practices on multiple fronts: their strategies for safeguarding software against cyber threats and how they manage confidential data and concepts.

  • Cybersecurity Measures — Verify the company’s compliance with data protection regulations and ask about their cybersecurity services, such as Managed Threat Response, Compliance & vCISO, and Penetration Testing. As data breaches and ransomware attacks can inflict severe damage on a business’s reputation and finances, ensure that the chosen vendor has a comprehensive security approach that covers threat scenarios and risk prioritization.
  • Confidentiality Measures — Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs) and Non-Compete Agreements (NCAs) serve to shield your proprietary information, product concepts, and sensitive materials from unauthorized access. Prior to finalizing a contract with a software development company, inquire about these safeguards to guarantee the proper handling of confidential data.

5. Ask about IP rights

Protecting your intellectual property (IP) rights is essential in ensuring the security of your concepts and ideas. When entering into a partnership with a development company, it’s important that they transfer the complete rights to your product over to you.

This goes beyond mere legal compliance; it’s a strategic and financial move. Without full ownership, you won’t have the ability to capitalize on your product through licensing arrangements or royalties.

6. Follow the “size match” rule

It’s important to ensure a proper fit between the software development company’s size and your needs.

The “size match” principle suggests that companies and teams of similar sizes tend to have comparable working styles and capabilities. This minimizes the chances of frustration due to mismatches in resources and objectives.

However, exercise caution and avoid strictly committing to this principle. Larger companies or teams aren’t necessarily superior, and smaller ones may not prioritize your project all the time. Consider not only the size but also the company’s maturity and the complexity of its past projects in your evaluation.

7. Prioritize testing and iteration

Experiencing software glitches or freezes during a demo can be frustrating for clients. Testing and iteration are crucial for building reliable custom applications.

Before finalizing your choice of a development company, it’s important to grasp their approach to testing, acceptance, and feedback phases.

What kinds of testing do they employ?

What methodologies are part of their process?

Testing is a prerequisite for improvement. The extent of their testing reflects their willingness to learn and enhance their work.

8. Consider post-development support

The development process doesn’t end upon launching your application. To avoid being overwhelmed by tickets and complaints, address support and maintenance considerations first.

When evaluating potential partners, inquire about the inclusion and duration of support and maintenance services after launch.

Post-development support isn’t solely about reducing code-related problems. It also ensures technical currency and integration of user feedback to keep your application light and up-to-date.

9. Discuss engagement terms

The nature of your engagement will greatly shape the terms of your collaboration, making it important to identify the best match.

In a managed services model, the software vendor handles the entire lifecycle of the application, from development to maintenance and support. This is suitable for those seeking a comprehensive solution without the need to manage internal resources.

A co-sourcing model involves enrolling external assistance to enhance the in-house development team, often due to a shortage of specialized developers.

10. Look for a partner mindset

Technical proficiency is merely the first prerequisite for creating effective software solutions. Search for a development company with a collaborative approach, capable of strategic thinking and offering solutions that tackle your unique business challenges.

Your chosen partner shouldn’t just provide technical guidance, but should also show a commitment to your expansion.

For instance, does the development firm extend consulting services?

Do they incorporate Business Analysts within their team?

Do they possess a track record of developing their own software products?

List of 10 essential criteria to choose a software development company.

Conclusion

Tech industry leaders wrestle with ongoing hurdles, and the most stressful is the element of uncertainty, both within and beyond their organization. Collaborating with a software development agency introduces a measure of unpredictability and risk.

Nevertheless, this shouldn’t necessarily be a gamble or an extended process of due diligence. Employing a set of standards like those outlined in this article can quicken your exploration while mitigating stress.

Ready to dive deeper into the world of software development and stay up-to-date with the latest tech news? Visit our blog and unlock valuable insights, expert tips, and industry trends. Click here to explore our blog now!

--

--