What Happens on Uber Should Stay on Uber — Kenyan Driver Perspectives on the Possibility of Portable Ratings

Are Reputational Ratings Favorable for Drivers?

Julie Zollmann
Feb 13, 2019 · 4 min read
Credit: Matheus Bertelli

As platform-mediated livelihoods grow around the world, many are contemplating how to ensure that gig work can be good work. Among the ideas circulating are those looking for ways to create long-term benefits, like pensions, to support gig workers, across platforms. Another idea is to allow gig workers to move their reputations across platforms, as a mechanism to enable competition and labor mobility. But when we asked about 20 Uber, Taxify, and Little Ride drivers in Nairobi in November 2018 whether they
would want to be able to port their ratings across platforms, the answer was a unanimous and resounding, “No!”

“Each platform is different in so many ways that moving ratings across them would be unfair to drivers,” — one driver explained, echoing many of the others.

Incentive-driven Environments

At the moment, Taxify has lower fares than Uber. Many drivers take issue with this.

“Taxis should be a luxury service,” — one driver explained to me. “Now they are attracting even students and matatu [bus] people, who don’t know how to behave.”

Other drivers complained with disgust that Taxify attracts criminals, drunkards, students, and “Nigerians.”

“They don’t pay, and they are arrogant,” — another driver said of the typical Taxify client.

The problem is not just that lower prices attract lower-income people, but also that the incentives within the application environment do not encourage good behavior from customers. Indeed, many drivers who drove at least part time for Taxify had unsettling experiences where customers never paid them, and Taxify took months to address complaints. They might never compensate for this lost income.

Ride Hailing Etiquette

It’s unclear whether these rider offenders are penalized sufficiently on the Taxify system, particularly given long delays in addressing problems reported on the platform. Some drivers have begun to feel they should take things into their own hands, carrying clubs in their cars to threaten non-payers, and association leaders warning the public that drivers are on edge and liable to lose their tempers with unruly customers.

Uber stands in stark contrast. The average rider on Uber has “good manners” according to drivers. And, Uber as a company is more professional. Key to that is the fact that they quickly intervene whenever something has gone wrong. When one driver got an unusual low rating, they called him to find out what
happened. He explained that passengers were “romancing” in his car, and refused to stop at his request. He returned them to the pickup point. Given that the riders had broken an Uber policy, Uber overturned the low rating on the driver’s behalf.

“In case there is a problem, and you write an email to Uber, they will consider the driver’s opinion,” — one driver explained.

Drivers work hard to cultivate a high rating, but only when the platform environment allows and rewards good behavior. Until that is true for all players in the market, drivers strongly prefer that their digital reputations be confined to the specific incentive environments that shaped them.

FIBR stands for Financial Inclusion on Business Runways and aims to learn how to transform emerging business data about low-income individuals and link them to inclusive financial services to deepen financial inclusion and its impact.FIBR is a project of BFA in partnership with Mastercard Foundation.

Stay connected by signing up for the FIBR mailing list and joining theInclusive Fintech Group on LinkedIn.

Finance for Life

Building more sustainable and inclusive economies through data, finance and technology innovation

Finance for Life

BFA Global is a research, advisory, data analytics and product innovation firm focused on the intersection of finance, data and technology. We aim to improve the lives of vulnerable and underserved communities around the world.

Julie Zollmann

Written by

I’m a Kenya-based researcher doing work independently & with BFA (www.bfaglobal.com). I study the economic lives of ordinary people and small businesses.

Finance for Life

BFA Global is a research, advisory, data analytics and product innovation firm focused on the intersection of finance, data and technology. We aim to improve the lives of vulnerable and underserved communities around the world.

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store