by Alfred Ng

The physical key has prevailed over the smart lock for a group of tenants with privacy concerns.

In a settlement released Tuesday, a judge ordered landlords of an apartment building in New York to provide physical keys to any tenants who don’t want to use the Latch smart locks installed on the building last September.

The settlement is a first, as there’s no legal precedent or legislation deciding how landlords can use smart home technology. Since the technology is relatively new, lawmakers haven’t had time to catch up with smart home devices, and this case in New York is one of the few legal challenges to appear in court. It won’t set a legal precedent because it’s a settlement, but it represents a win for tenants who had issues with smart locks and landlords installing them against their will.

“This is a huge victory for these tenants and tenants throughout New York City. These types of systems, which landlords have used to surveil, track and intimidate tenants, have been used frequently in New York City,” Michael Kozek, the attorney representing the tenants in Manhattan, said in a statement. “These tenants refused to accept the system, and the negative impact it had on their lives. Hopefully they will be an inspiration for other tenants to fight back.”

Mary Beth McKenzie, her husband, Tony Mysak, and a group of tenants sued their landlords after the landlords installed the smart locks last year, arguing that there were privacy concerns with the Latch smart lock and the app required to get into their own building.

Read more on: Tenants win as settlement orders landlords give physical keys over smart locks

Related Article: Are smart door locks secure enough?