Floridian Governor Signs Bill Restricting Youth from Social Media
Authored by: Euri Kim, Editorial Writer, Fidutam
Edited by: Leher Gulati, Editorial Director, Fidutam
Floridian Governor Signs Bill Restricting Youth from Social Media
In a groundbreaking move, Florida has become the pioneer state to implement stringent regulations on social media access for minors. Governor Ron DeSantis signed into law a bill that effectively prohibits children under the age of 14 from having their own social media accounts, marking a significant step in addressing the concerns surrounding the impact of digital platforms on young minds.
The legislation, known as HB3, not only bars individuals under 14 from creating social media accounts but also mandates parental consent for 14- and 15-year-olds. This move underscores the state’s commitment to empowering parents in guiding their children’s online interactions and safeguarding their well-being in the digital realm.
Previously, Mr. DeSantis had vetoed a bill that moved to ban social media accounts for 14- and 15-year-olds, parental consent or not. In regard to this bill, the governor stated that it would infringe on parents’ rights to make their own decisions about their children’s actions.
Social Media’s Effect on Kids
Governor DeSantis emphasized the necessity of this measure in a press conference, highlighting the detrimental effects of unrestricted social media usage on children’s mental health and overall development. He articulated that excessive screen time and exposure to potentially harmful content pose significant risks to young individuals, necessitating proactive steps to mitigate these dangers. He added that “being buried” in devices all day long was not a good way to grow up. “Social media harms children in a variety of ways,” Mr. DeSantis said in a statement. The new bill “gives parents a greater ability to protect their children.”
However, this legislative initiative is not without its share of controversies and anticipated legal challenges. Critics argue that such restrictions infringe upon the First Amendment rights of minors and hinder their access to valuable information online. Moreover, concerns have been raised regarding the constitutionality of imposing limitations on digital platforms, particularly in the absence of clear delineation between permissible and impermissible content.
A Divided Legal System
Before this move, several other states vetoed more lenient online safety laws on grounds of free speech. For example, judges in Ohio and Arkansas have blocked laws that would require specific social networks to verify the ages of users and acquire parental permission before allowing children under the age of 16 to make social media accounts. A Californian judge stopped a law that would require some social networks and video game apps to turn on the most severe privacy settings by default for minors and turn off default certain features, like auto-playing videos, for minors.
Old News?
To some social networks, this is nothing new. Apps like Facebook, Snapchat and Instagram already have policies prohibiting children under the age of 13. This is a result of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act: which requires certain online services to receive parental permission before collecting personal information from children under the age of 13. These include things like full names, facial photos, and location.
However, sometimes these measures are not effective. In 2023, The New York Times reported on an unsealed complaint, which claimed that Meta failed to disable many underage users’ accounts after they were found and continued to use those users’ data.
“Within the company, Meta’s actual knowledge that millions of Instagram users are under the age of 13 is an open secret that is routinely documented, rigorously analyzed and confirmed, and zealously protected from disclosure to the public” the complaint read, according to the Times. The complaint also alleged that when Meta “received over 1.1 million reports of under-13 users on Instagram” from 2019–2023, it “disabled only a fraction of those accounts and routinely continued to collect children’s data without parental consent.”
Balancing Acts
The legal landscape surrounding social media regulation is fraught with complexities, as evidenced by ongoing disputes in various states across the nation. While the intention behind these measures is to promote online safety and protect vulnerable users, reconciling these objectives with constitutional rights remains a formidable task.
Furthermore, the Florida legislation extends beyond social media platforms to encompass age verification requirements for accessing pornographic websites. This approach shows the state’s comprehensive efforts to address the challenges posed by digital technology, spanning from protecting minors against explicit content to curbing the addictive features inherent in social media platforms.
Unconstitutional… or Revolutionary?
The enactment of HB3 heralds a new era in digital governance, setting a precedent for other states grappling with similar concerns. As technology continues to evolve at a rapid pace, policymakers face the daunting task of striking a delicate balance between innovation and regulation, ensuring that the benefits of digital connectivity are not overshadowed by its pitfalls.
In the midst of these debates and legal battles, one thing remains clear: the need for concerted efforts to foster responsible technology usage and empower individuals to navigate the digital landscape safely and ethically. Florida’s social media legislation serves as a pivotal milestone in this ongoing journey towards a more secure and equitable digital future.
Sources
- DeSantis Signs Social Media Bill Barring Accounts for Children Under 14 — New York Times
- Florida governor signs law restricting social media access for children — CNN
- Ron DeSantis signs Florida social media ban for children into law — Guardian
- Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis signs bill that bans children under 14 from having social media accounts — NBC
- Complaint alleges that Meta ‘pursued’ children to use its platforms — Mashable
Follow Fidutam for more insights on responsible technology!
