Davis Family: How to Winn the Dixie
Boldness and tenacity took Winn-Dixie from a single store in Miami to a multi-billion dollar grocery empire.
William Milton Davis didn’t always win at business; but, he wasn’t scared of failure either. The founding father of the Winn-Dixie grocery empire was intense and opportunistic. And he instilled these same business principles in his four sons: James Elsworth (“J. E.”), Milton Austin, Tine Wayne, and Artemus Darius (“A. D.”).
The senior Davis was decades ahead of his time. In ways that would make today’s Lean Startup practitioners proud, the Davis family learned as much or more from mistakes as their successes. But when a hypothesis proved out, they weren’t afraid to (literally) bet the house on it. They employed these methods (and an insatiable tenacity) to propel them from a single store to a multi-billion dollar supermarket behemoth.
Origin of an Empire
William Milton Davis was born in 1880 in Texas, before moving to the Ozark Mountains of Arkansas at a very young age. There he was raised on the family farm. As a young man he helped his dad manage the family’s general store in Gamaliel. In 1904 he cut his teeth with his own store in Henderson, the neighboring tiny town just across the Norfolk River.
Hearing there were fortunes to be made in Idaho, he moved with his brother Newton Carlisle Davis (“Carl”) to Burley in 1912. The next year the brothers began work at Clark Mercantile General Store. Before long the ambitious duo bought the place and renamed it Davis Mercantile.
And business was good! Three years later they expanded to a 8,250 square foot retail space called Davis Department Store. They sold everything from food to clothing. In a few short years William and Carl grew the business ten fold from $30,000 to $300,000 in annual sales.
As was standard for the time, they offered customers sales on credit — and even home delivery to boot. This practice and keen attention to service was lauded by their patrons. The brothers were well-respected pillars of the southern Idaho community.
However, in 1920 competition steam-rolled into town. An upstart chain called Skaggs Cash Store (predecessor of Safeway) shunned credit and required cash only purchases. This less risky model allowed them to lower prices on food stuffs while offering a larger selection.
Then a 1921 recession hit Idaho’s largely agriculture-based economy hard. Farmers suddenly could not pay off their grocery debt. The Davis store had extended tens of thousands of dollars in merchandise on credit, with no foreseeable return. Combined with the competition from Skaggs, they soon were forced to hand over assets to creditors and close up shop.
Undeterred, Carl encouraged William to check out the feverish Florida market, which was in the midst of the great boom years. Perhaps he was equally motivated to put as much distance between himself and Skaggs as humanly possible! Regardless, he took his brother’s advice and moved from the west coast to Miami in 1925.
“No” is just a temporary setback
With a $10,000 loan from his father, William surveyed the exploding market around Miami. He finally focused his attention on the emerging community of Lemon City — which today is Little Haiti — that was starting to blossom as a commercial and residential district, just north of downtown.
Proud and determined, Davis walked into Rockmoor Grocery at the corner of Dixie Highway (now NE 2nd Avenue) and 59th Street on November 15, 1925. He confidently approached store owner C. A. Rhodes with an unsolicited offer to buy the store on the spot.
Rhodes scoffed at first. He had no interest in selling the shop. Miami was bursting with growth, and the business had netted Rhodes $6,000 that past year. This was in the era when $1,400 was a solid annual salary!
Legend has it Davis got a gleam in his unwavering brown eyes. He opened up his briefcase and spread out $10,000 in cold-hard cash across the cashier’s counter. He repeated his offer. Rhodes looked down at the cash, looked up at the balding veteran grocer, extended his hand, and exclaimed: “SOLD!”
The store proved even more successful under the leadership of Davis. The following year his sons James and Artemus dropped out of the University of Idaho to help their father run Rockmoor Grocery.
Learning lessons from Idaho, William vowed to never sell merchandise on credit. He promised that he would fire anyone who did — “even if their last name is D-A-V-I-S!” Thus they entered the trend du jour among groceries: the self-service, low-margin, high-volume game.
At store number one, they sold homemade pies baked by Ethel Davis herself (wife of William). By maintaining his relationship with previous vendors, Davis was the first to introduce Idaho potatoes to Florida tables. They focused on fresh produce, dairy and meat from local farms; except for beef, which Davis insisted on importing from high quality western stock.
Following the Skaggs model, melded with his intense focus on customer service, they found great success at their Lemon City location. However, Davis never wanted to own just one store. His goal was to create a large retail chain; so less than a year later he started adding new locations.
They had a few false starts with store number two. Several attempts opened and closed quickly. Davis saw little reason to hesitate on pulling the plug if an idea or location wasn’t working out.
Their first big break came when opening store number three in Hialeah. It was located on Lindsey Court just north of the old post office near 54th Street (now known as Hialeah Drive). This location became a cash cow and greatly helped to finance early expansion.
In 1927 the Davis’ grocery rebranded as Table Supply Stores and began a phase of measured growth. They steadily scaled out, opening moderately performing stores around Miami-Dade before entering the Fort Lauderdale market in 1929.
Standards and efficiency were the name of the game. Table Supply opened a 15,000 square-foot warehouse in the Wynwood district of Miami. The central hub was located near the train tracks. The facility supplied all of their stores with daily truck shipments and allowed them cheap “by the carload” prices.
They focused on creating uniform best practices in all of their stores. Each location featured a nearly identical layout with three departments: meats, groceries, and produce. They boasted novelties like electric refrigerated display cases, wider aisles, low shelves to keep everything in easy reach, and distinctive can pyramid displays.
Finding Opportunity in Dark Times
Despite the nation entering the early stage Great Depression, business was booming for Table Supply in 1930. With reported year-over-year earnings up over 100% they decided to double down on expansion.
During the fall of that year, they opened three stores in Palm Beach County. There they met their greatest success yet. In its first week in business the West Palm Beach location produced $7,600 in gross sales. For context, at that time a typical take was about $1,000 for a local grocer.
Their biggest driver of demand was selling quality cuts of Western beef at greatly discounted prices. While most meat markets were selling steaks from 60 to 85 cents per pound, Davis offered it for just 19 cents! This created a bit of a frenzy (and often long lines). Here they started earning their future mantra “The Beef People” in the very early days of the store!
The business community in the Palm Beach area, however, was not very happy to see Table Supply enter their territory. While they did not appreciate the chain’s competition, they had a down right fit when area manager Artemus Davis launched a November 1930 advertising campaign.
Newspaper ads throughout South Florida purported that Table Supply offered “the same steaks” that other grocers offered for less than a third of the price. The enraged rivals fired off a series of false advertising lawsuits against them, claiming that the Davis beef was not “the same” as theirs.
Table Supply eventually won all of the legal challenges and ultimately benefited from the suits. The charges were widely reported in newspapers, magnifying the advertising campaign and ensuring locals knew where to get the cheapest meat products! Eventually the other grocers and butchers were forced to lower their prices as well.
Flush with cash from their rabidly successful foray into Palm Beach County, the Davis family made a bet to expand while the nation’s economy declined. In 1931 they bought another Florida chain called Lively Stores, giving them a total footprint of 33 locations and introducing them to the massive Tampa Bay market. The next year they added 10 Orlando area locations in the acquisition of B&B Stores.
No Time to Mourn
In November 1934 founder William Milton Davis fell sick during church service. He went into emergency abdominal surgery the next day, but succumbed to complications from the operation and heart disease a week later. He was just 54 years old.
Following their father’s death, the four brothers took over the business. James became chairman.
The twenty-six year old CEO had little time to mourn his father’s death. With a fast-expanding business in the height of the Great Depression, independent shop owners and politicians alike began to look at chain stores with ire. These fat cats, they were sure, were responsible for all of their economic woes.
In April 1935 senator Henry C. Tillman of Hillsborough County introduced the “Florida Recovery Act.” Its goal was nothing short of completely banning all chain stores from the state. The proposal was met with surprising support, and its debate occupied the majority of the floor time during the spring session of both houses of state government. The controversy erupted into heated newspaper and radio editorials, political grandstanding, and large advertising campaigns by both sides.
Needless to say its passage would have quite literally put Table Supply out of business. They hired lawyers and vehemently argued against it. The bill actually passed in the House, but ultimately it was amended and de-clawed to a large extent by the Senate. The weakened version then stalled when it was returned to the House for re-passage.
However, to appease their base, they passed in its place a new graduated licensing fees and gross receipts taxes that severely penalized chain stores. Table Supply, with its 34 stores, was in the highest bracket. They had to pay a $400 license fee per store (it was just $10 if you had one location) plus a 5% tax on gross sales (versus half a percent for single-store owners).
In response the Davis brothers founded the Florida Retail Federation (then called Florida Chain Store Association). Through this organization, retail chains collaborated to lobby against this and other similarly oppressive anti-business laws.
The Florida Recovery Act become a hot item on the political agenda once again in the 1937 gubernatorial race. In round two it stood about a 50–50 chance at becoming law. Understand the severity of its proposed impact…
In what some likened to building a business firewall around the state, it promised not only to expel every single retail chain but forbid any non-resident ownership of businesses operating in Florida. This included mere shareholders! The largely democrat-backed initiative sought to remove yankee influence and profit-siphoning from Florida, but by extension it would also eliminate northern investment in the state!
Lucky for the Davis brothers, it once again failed after a series of alterations in the Senate. Gradually, as the Depression began to subside, the various anti-chain regulations and taxes were repealed one-by-one. The gross receipts tax was thrown out in 1941, but others remained in place until as late as 1953.
Davis Brothers Know How to Winn
By 1939 the brothers had amassed 43 Table Supply stores throughout southeast Florida, the Heartland and the Tampa Bay area. Perhaps through their work in the chain store association, they became acquainted with fellow grocery magnate William R. Lovett.
Lovett was the president of Jacksonville-based Winn & Lovett. The company operated 73 stores in north Florida and south Georgia under the Lovett’s name, as well as some Piggly Wiggly franchises.
Winn & Lovett began in 1920 with founders Lovett and E. L. Winn. By 1930 they began to consolidate from numerous small neighborhood stores to fewer “super-markets” closer to the modern self-service vein. It was about that time that Lovett bought Winn out and rebranded the chain Lovett’s Groceteria. The term groceteria being used in the era as a contraction of grocery and cafeteria, noting the parallels in the self-service nature of the up-and-coming concepts.
Lovett convinced the Davis brothers to purchase a controlling interest in his larger retail chain. In 1939 they mortgaged nearly everything they owned and bought a 51% stake in the much larger Winn & Lovett. A. D. moved to Jacksonville to take over as president of the company.
For the next five years Lovett stayed on the board, and the two companies continued to operate as separate entities. Then in November 1944 the Davis family bought out the remainder of the Lovett’s chain and immediately merged the two companies. Taking on Winn & Lovett as their combined corporate monicker, they relocated their headquarters to Jacksonville.
Interestingly, after they parted ways William R. Lovett was not done with the grocery business. He later bought a controlling interest in the troubled Piggly Wiggly Corporation. Among his investments in other industries like shipping, Lovett revitalized Piggly Wiggly and grew it to 1,000 franchises throughout the southeast — 200 of which he owned personally.
Keep Investing in What Works
Over the next two decades, the Davis family had an unquenchable lust for growth. Other than a few Lovett locations in south Georgia, the company had no presence outside of Florida. That changed in 1945 with the purchase of Kentucky-based Steiden Stores and its 31 locations. The Steiden stores, mostly around the Louisville area, continued to operate under its well-known local brand for the next decade.
The acquisition brought Winn-Lovett’s total store count to 149 stores. They operated variably as Table Supply, Lovett’s, Steiden, Piggly Wiggly, and a handful as Economy Wholesale Grocery.
By 1949 another grocery powerhouse with Miami roots had emerged. In just ten years Margaret Ann New Era Markets had grown exponentially, opening 47 stores in the southern half of the state on both coasts.
Margaret Ann was founded by Robert Pentland, a Miami accountant and air force officer. Though it was named for his young daughter, their marketing instead suggested a fictional store founder: a housewife that truly understood their needs. In contrast to trendy new supermarkets that touted frills and fancy finishes, they boasted their unadorned simplicity and smaller staff that supposedly allowed them to offer lower prices.
As the Margaret Ann marketshare grew, Winn-Lovett seethed to see this ascension in their own backyard. So when a bit of weakness and disgruntled shareholders began to plague the newcomer, the Davis brothers did not waste any time taking advantage. They bought out the competitor for $5,000,000 and secured its spot behind A&P at the top of the Florida grocery market.
Through the forties the two primary Winn-Lovett brands (Lovett’s and Table Supply) had worked hard to embrace the perks that Margaret Ann had shunned. They introduced coffee bars, handsome displays, and decorative flair into their buildings. Their mundane features like air conditioning, shopping carts, and well-staffed meat departments were all novel at the time.
For a while they continued to expand all three core brands (plus Steiden in Kentucky), often in the same region. For a short time to create differentiation, Margaret Ann became the designator for its smaller stores. Some of the older Table Supply locations were also remodeled under that name.
Across all of the labels Winn & Lovett had reached 178 stores by 1952. To fund their continued growth, they applied for an initial public offering on the New York Stock Exchange. That February they became the first Florida corporation to be publicly traded.
The IPO was received enthusiastically by investors. As one of the fastest growing chains in the nation and with the ticker symbol WIN, there was a whole lot to like!
Their luck improved even more in 1953, when the state of Florida repealed the gross receipts tax. This tore down the last remnant of the Great Depression era anti big business laws.
Flush with cash from stock sales and tax savings, they began to expand rapidly into both new and existing markets. And because apparently they needed yet another brand in their portfolio: they launched Kwik Chek. Most of their new and modern locations began to take on this newly-minted name.
Older readers will surely still remember these stores; however, even those my age will recall its iconic imprint that is still evident today. The check in the modern Winn-Dixie logo and its line of Chek colas owe their lineage to it.
Throughout the next decade the Kwik Chek brand gradually became the more prominent of the bunch. Over time all of their stores gravitated toward Kwik Chek, first with co-branding and then phasing out the older name. On a large scale this happened across virtually all remaining Table Supply and Margaret Ann stores in 1955 and with the Louisville, KY area Steiden locations in 1956.
The Winn-Lovett buying spree really got kick started from 1954 through 1957. They added these to chains to their lineup in quick succession:
- Wylie & Company, operating 8 Jitney Jungle stores in Alabama
- Eden’s Food Stores in South Carolina, 33 stores
- Ballentine Grocery Stores in South Carolina, 16 stores
- Penny Stores in Mississippi, 8 stores
- Ketner-Milner of North Carolina, 24 stores
- Kings Outlet Stores of Georgia
- H. G. Hill’s of Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama, 42 stores
- Dossett’s in Mississippi
In addition to gobbling up other chains, by 1957 they were buying 5–7 independent grocers per year. Meanwhile, they were opening 40–60 new stores and closing 20–30 under-performing locations annually.
By the mid fifties Dixie-Home Super Markets were the dominant grocery brand of South Carolina, North Carolina, and parts of Georgia. Its roots date back to 1927 when J. P. Williamson founded Dixie Stores; Robert E. Ebert and H. H. Harris started Home Stores in 1930. The two merged in 1937.
Winn & Lovett wanted desperately to break open the Carolina market and become the king of the Southeast. So in 1955 they negotiated a blockbuster deal to merge with Dixie-Home in a stock swap.
The deal combined Winn-Lovett with its 271 stores and $260,000,000 in revenue with Dixie-Home’s 117 locations and $80,000,000 in sales. The combined corporation was renamed Winn-Dixie.
The Davis brothers were obviously thrilled out of their minds. They had far exceeded their father’s wildest dreams. The poetry of the merged name was the icing on the cake. They had long aspired to dominate the southern market or “win the Dixie.” Now it was built right into their corporate identity!
About a year and a half after the Dixie-Home merger, they renamed the stores in the Carolina market Winn-Dixie. Gradually they phased in the new name across all of their stores; some were a hard cut over and others transitioned with evolving logos and co-branded stores for a while. However, in many markets the Kwik Chek name survived into the late 1970s.
(Not) All in the Family
In 1965 the company promoted longtime VP Bert Thomas to the role of president, the first time someone not named Davis was at the helm. The brothers continued as the corporation’s largest stockholders and held the top positions on the board of directors — J. E. Davis remained the chairman.
By then of course millionaires many times over, the Davis brothers had become active in the Florida political scene. Since the family owned several private jets, they “generously” leased one of those to the state of Florida for just $1 per year in the late sixties. That benevolence of course helped curry them significant favor in Tallahassee.
The next year Thomas announced a new milestone of one billion dollars in sales. The corporation operated 696 retail stores and 7 wholesale stores (under Economy Wholesale Grocery line) stretching from Key West to Virginia to Indiana to Louisiana.
Uncle Sam is a Party Pooper
But in 1966 the federal government decided to throw some ice water on the party. After a lengthy investigation by the Federal Trade Commission into the increasing conglomeration of power in the grocery market, it was determined Winn-Dixie was heating up too much too fast.
Under the Clayton Anti-Trust Act of 1914, Winn-Dixie was barred from making any acquisitions or mergers for the next ten years. The move wasn’t completely unanticipated, as the most profitable and fastest growing grocer in the country, most already assumed the crosshairs were square on its back.
While it was a downer to visions of world domination, in some ways it was more of a compromise than a punishment. Thomas sought to reassure shareholders that their internal growth would continue. Further, the decision took off the table any retroactive rollback of previous any previous deals (which would have been a nightmare scenario).
“The principal practical effect,” Thomas said in the Wall Street Journal, “is to clear all Winn-Dixie’s past mergers and acquisitions from future challenge.”
Though slowed, they brushed their shoulders off and continued to open new stores. And since the FTC’s jurisdiction stopped at the border, W-D turned internationally for growth in 1967. They purchased City Meat Market and its 11 stores in The Bahamas from owner Sir Stafford Sands.
In 1976 the FCC’s ten year ban finally expired. By that time they had adjusted to slower organic growth; however, the opportunistic acquisitions resumed when the right deal came along.
One such opportunity was expanding into Texas, Oklahoma and New Mexico. Almost immediately upon the moratorium’s expiration Winn-Dixie purchased Kimbell Incorporated, which operated 135 stores in those three states under the trade names Buddies, Foodway, and Hagee.
A Third Generation
Then suddenly shock waves ripped through the company. Just days before the 1982 investor’s meeting, president Bert Thomas died of a stroke and heart attack at age 64.
Thomas’ leadership was lauded on Wall Street. He had successfully navigated the FTC challenges and a changing market. Despite it all, he had lifted the company to well over 1000 stores and year-after-year of uninterrupted top and bottom line revenue growth. Under his leadership dividends (one of the only on the NYSE paid monthly) increased every single year.
Andrew “Dano” Davis (son of then still board chairman J. E. Davis) was elected to replace Thomas as the corporation’s fourth president. Dano was just 37 years old when he was promoted to the post.
A year later Robert D. Davis succeeded his uncle J. E. as chairman of the board. The third generation of the Davis family was now purely at the helm. However, Robert’s tenure was relatively short-lived.
After five years of flat growth, Dano replaced his cousin. While Robert remained on the board as vice chair, Dano served as President/CEO until 1999 and board chairman until he retired in 2003.
Damn You, Sam Walton!
At its peak around 1987 the Winn-Dixie empire included almost 1300 stores and over $9 Billion in gross revenue. Standing as the fourth largest grocery chain in the country, it had more than doubled since the FTC attempted to limit it two decades earlier. Its realm extended westward into Texas and Oklahoma and northward into Ohio and Indiana.
The eighties and nineties proved rough for the grocery industry, however, and Winn-Dixie was severely impacted. At one time a 20,000 square-foot store was considered large, but with the advent of superstores the new normal became 45,000 square feet over the course of just a decade.
Winn-Dixie was pressed from all sides. The Wal-Marts and Costcos of the world with their all-in-one superstores created pressure on the top end. Convenience stores like 7–11 were eating away at the small neighborhood store model. And new traditional grocers were entering the southeast like Albertson’s, Kash ‘n’ Karry and Food Lion.
The increasing competition not only ate away at Winn-Dixie’s customer base, but created a race-to-the-bottom pricing environment. Grocers run a small margin, high volume game. On regular food items it can often run as slim as 2–3%. Leading up to the millennium this razor-thin margin got even tighter.
From 1987 through 1999 the Winn-Dixie store count trended downward. This was partly due to consolidating multiple aging stores into a single larger store (sometimes as large as 55,000 square feet). But also, they began to decisively close down unprofitable stores and even exit certain markets completely.
Winn-Dixie was in a constant cycle of remodeling and enlarging existing stores. Where expansion was not possible, they would close it and open a new store close by. Since they signed multi-decade leases (company policy forbade owning real estate), they were often stuck for years paying rent on the now vacant space — at least until they found someone to sublease it.
In 1994 alone the company spent $650 million on renovations to convert or open new Marketplace stores. Those capital expenditures, in addition to the shrinking margins and marketshare, made profitability a challenge.
Despite move after move to modernize, gain efficiency and improve their image, it was not enough to fend off the company’s eventual bankruptcy. Winn-Dixie filed for Chapter 11 protection in 2005. The Davis era was officially over for the 80-year-old chain.
A year later Winn-Dixie emerged with half the number of stores as its 1987 peak. Their territory was cut down to just Florida, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana.
With the fat trimmed, they re-launched stock ticker symbol as WINN. The leaner company’s profit improved and they worked on fixing their image with fewer but remodeled, cleaner and modernized stores.
In late 2011 they were taken private when they were acquired by the parent company of Carolinas rival Bi-Lo. The merged company was eventually renamed Southeastern Grocers, which retained Winn-Dixie’s Jacksonville headquarters as its home base.
As of November 2017, Winn-Dixie operates around 450 stores, mostly in Florida and the gulf coast. Its parent company Southeastern Grocers operates stores under the BI-LO, Harveys, Winn-Dixie, and Fresco y Más brands.
The Davis Legacy
Grocers stole — ahem, I mean borrowed — so many ideas from each other, it is hard to say exactly who invented what. But it is certain that the Davis family were true innovators in the space.
Revolutionary concepts the three Davis generations pioneered have become so standard, today most people don’t even think about them. This foresight and experimentation played a major role in shaping the modern grocery store. And more generally their imprint is felt on modern business theory.
Corporate policy encouraged any level manager to introduce a new idea. Generally they’d always agree to try it in a subset of stores, without negative consequence if the experiment failed to give the desired result.
However, if it had positive results it would be implemented on a larger scale or chain-wide. This attitude kept the company at the forefront of the industry for decades — plus created empowered and engaged employees.
This is a framework that is considered a new theory among business thought leaders of the 21st century… but the Davis brothers started doing it over eighty years ago!
Outside of business, the Davis family has been exceptional philanthropists, especially around Jacksonville, for many decades.
J. E. Davis gifted land and money to kick start the Mayo Clinic Jacksonville campus in 1986. The family has contributed tens of millions to fund business schools at Stetson and Jacksonville University. Being lovers of social justice, they have also given millions to historically black colleges over the years and served on various boards. That generosity has continued to this day, with a two million dollar donation in 2017 to the Jacksonville Zoo.
Especially if you are an entrepreneur, it is hard not be in awe of the legacy and accomplishments of these three generations of the Davis family!