Richard Banfield
Feb 1, 2016 · 9 min read

(Except from my book published by O’Reilly.)

Why I wrote this book and for whom

Somehow we’ve convinced our design leaders that they need to have all the answers. We’re all to blame. We’ve elevated company leadership to an almost mythological state of knowing everything and never making mistakes. The reality is that all leaders, including design leaders, are just as confused as everyone else. They make mistakes. They screw up. They make things up along the way. They forget lessons and lose their way. In my surveys for this book, almost 50% of design leaders said they were just reasonable leaders and still had tons to learn and only 13% of respondents consider themselves to be very good leaders. Considering that these are the people in charge of the top design companies in North America, it’s confirmation that even the smartest and most experienced are still struggling with the challenges of leadership.

This book was written partly out of personal frustration and partly because there’s a lot of misunderstanding about what design leadership means. Leading a successful design organization is confusing and challenging. There’s no definitive manual or guidebook. The unhealthy perception that leaders have the answers makes leader’s less likely to ask for help. That’s a perception that can only lead to disappointment for both leaders and the people that look to them for direction. Design leaders need better guidance and insights. This book aims to provide some of that knowledge.

I’m one of those confused design leaders. I’ve been an entrepreneur in the tech and digital design space most of my adult life. That’s about 20 years if you are wondering. In that time I’ve learned the hard way that nobody has all the answers. I’ve also learned that as a leader, you can either find the answers through trial and error or you can go directly to the source. I prefer going to the source. If you want to know how to be a great design leader you go directly to the best design leaders. When I started my own design firm 10 years ago, Fresh Tilled Soil, there were lots of questions. Question with no obvious answers. For a while I believed I was supposed to learn the answers the hard way, through trial and error. Over time I learned that this was inefficient and expensive. I believe that learning by trial and error is a little stupid when there are some many other ways to learn. I endeavoured to read about how other leaders had solved these problems but I always felt the published answers were a little too generic. The real breakthroughs came when I had the opportunity to talk directly to other design leaders that were more experienced and smarter than me. These conversations became the inspiration to create a successful strategy for myself. The strategies allowed me to grow a multi million dollar design company from the ground up with no debt and no loans. These conversations were so helpful that I made it a habit to call design leaders that were way ahead of me on their personal and business journeys and ask them their advice.

I also noticed that I wasn’t the only one that was asking these questions. At conferences, industry meetings and casual conversations these topics came up frequently. It started to made sense to capture these conversations and write a book. The book would gather all these design leader’s perspectives and answers together. I imagined that was useful to me could also be useful to other design leaders. So to that end, this book was born.

This book is for design leaders and those that are on a path to leadership. The book will also be useful to those people that work for design leaders and want to understand them better. Ultimately the book is for anyone that leads a design team, owns an emerging design company or works closely with design leaders. Whether you’re starting out or are decades deep into your adventure, this book will guide you through topics like hiring the best talent, building a strong culture, finding personal balance, growing your leadership skills, designing the optimal workspace and creating healthy sales pipelines.

Our interviews focused on leaders from both emerging and established companies. In the cases where the design firm was independently owned and run by the design leader we focused on companies in the 5 to 100 employee range. There were some exceptions but our goal was to talk to leaders dealing with typical growing pains. Although we did speak to leaders from larger corporations like ESPN and Fidelity Investments we gave most of our attention to small and mid sized design teams. About 60% of the companies interviewed had between 5–15 employees, while almost 40% of the companies had 20 or more employees. Several had upwards of 75 team members. The cultural differences between these companies is enormous and it would be hard to quantify those differences. Instead we’ve captured the individual stories, universal insights and strategic approaches to making design groups more productive, creative and focused.

This book is not a textbook or a paint-by-numbers workbook. This book is a conversation. It is a collection of conversations teased out of hundreds of interviews that I did with the help of my colleague and friend Dan Allard. Dan was one of my first employees at Fresh Tilled Soil and was just as curious about design leadership as I was. While I conducted the interviews, Dan lugged around the heavy video and audio equipment to dozens of cities across North America. We recorded almost a hundred design leader interviews, ranging from small companies, like Haught Codeworks in Boulder, CO, to massive corporations like ESPN, with a 120-acre campus in Bristol, CT. From late-2013 till mid-2015 we captured the perspectives, insights, anecdotes and personal stories of some of the top digital design leaders in North America. Many of these original interviews are available on YouTube in their raw and unedited form. Just search for ‘digital design leader’ and you’ll find dozens of one-on-one interviews to inspire you. Over the last 2 years some of this footage has found it’s way to podcasts and articles but this book will be the first time all the interviews are collected into a single publication.

I hope you enjoy reading this book as much as I enjoyed creating it. I’ve learned so much from my interactions with these design leaders and I hope you will too. Getting to know them so intimately has also lead to some great friendships and even a few partnerships. I hope this book brings you closer to these amazing leaders too. With the help of my editors, reviewers and publishers we’ve tried to make the writing clear and engaging. We’ve deliberately avoided making this a prescriptive manual for running a design organization. Instead we’ve curated the best of breed approaches and presented them in a way that you can decide what works best for your team. It was our goal to cover the subject matter comprehensively but not in such detail it’ll put you to sleep. No matter what your design leadership position or aspirations are you’ll find something valuable in this book. There’s enough breadth of opinion and actionable insights that anyone in a design organization will find it immediately useful.

We’d also like to continue this conversation with our readers and contributors. We’re hoping to continue this conversation on social media and in person. As I’ve said before, design leaders don’t have all the answers, and we know there’s bucket loads more to explore and learn. Let’s work together to get smarter and spread the knowledge so we can all benefit. A rising tide raises all boats. The more informed we are as design leaders, the sooner our organizations will see results. The more we share the more we’ll see highly engaged teams, happy clients and positive financial returns.

Thank you for buying and reading this book. It’s been a real pleasure writing it and sharing it with so many other design leaders.

Richard Banfield

How This Book Is Organized

Chapter 1: Culture

As the investor Jonathan Beare once said to me, “Every company has it’s own brand of culture and politics. You have to figure out which culture and politics are most interesting to you.” This chapter explores the way design leaders create and nurture the culture in their successful organizations. We’ll hear from design studio owners and executives about the links between culture, attracting talent, productivity and purpose. (Full chapter here)

Chapter 2: Talent

People are the cornerstone of all organizations. Great people make great organizations. Finding these people and keeping them engaged and happy is one of the primary responsibilities of design leaders. We’ll explore the innovative ways these leaders attract and nurture talent in their organizations.

Chapter 3: Office Space and Remote Working

Today’s workspace looks nothing like your dad’s office. Walls are coming down and creative workers are more remote than ever. In this chapter we ask the top design leaders what makes their design studios deliver on the promise of being productive spaces for both team members and clients. We also ask them how they manage the increasing numbers of remote workers while maintaining strong cultural bonds between team members.

Chapter 4: Personal Growth and Finding Balance

Design leaders are always learning, growing and struggling with finding balance in their lives. We learned how these top performers find time to stay on top of their daily demands while not losing sight of what’s really important — family, friends and personal growth. There is no one-size-fits-all approach either. We find out how different personalities solve this universal problem with their own brand of intuition and creativity.

Chapter 5: Planning for the Future

The ambiguity of running a design studio or team is becoming increasingly hard. Fast changing tech trends demand agility and flexibility from leaders. Planning for a future that seems to change while you watch it requires leadership skills that are both strategic and tactical. Our design leaders describe how they are laying plans for the future while consistently delivering on today’s demands.

Chapter 6: Leadership Style

Each person we interviewed brings their own flavor and style to the art of leadership. No two styles are the same but there are patterns that are consistent with successful leaders. We discuss how these styles connect leaders to their business visions and company cultures. Over time design leaders adapt their styles to changing environments and new challenges.

Chapter 7: Sales and Marketing

Every design business needs a pipeline of work. This topic is foremost on the design leaders minds as they work through the challenges of attracting new clients and retaining existing clients. Our interviews gave us insight into companies big and small, and provided us with a wide range of techniques and approaches.

Chapter 8: Biggest Mistakes and How to Learn from them

Making mistakes is inevitable. Unfortunately learning from them is not. We delve into the mistakes that these great design leaders have made and what they did to bounce back from them. In these stories you’ll learn that making mistakes isn’t something to be avoided, but rather having mechanisms to grow and improve as a result of mistakes is what makes these design leaders great.

Acknowledgements

This book would not be possible without the tireless efforts of Dan Allard. As we criss-crossed North America interviewing design leaders, Dan was the cameraman, sound man and general Sherpa of all the equipment. I’d also like to thank the entire Fresh Tilled Soil team for holding the fort while I researched and wrote this book. I’d also like to recognize the Bureau of Digital founders, Greg Hoy and Carl Smith, who host the amazing Owner Camp retreats. Meeting them and the fellow campers was a tipping point in getting access to several of the design leaders interviewed here. Finally I’d like to thank Nick Lombardi and Angela Rufino, and the rest of the amazing team at O’Reilly whose attention to detail and dedication make writing a book so much more enjoyable.

Companies Interviewed for this Book

Teehan + Lax

Happy Cog

Virgin Pulse

LogMeIn

Fidelity Investments

The Program

Make

XPLANE

America’s Test Kitchen

eHouse Studio

Envy

ESPN

Super Friendly

The Working Group

Uncorked Studios

Forrester Research

kor group

Yellow Pencil

Plank

Velir

Plucky

Fastspot

Demac Media

BancVue

BigCommerce

Funsize

Zurb

Viget

Barrel

Fresh Tilled Soil

Haught Codeworks

Crowd Favorite

Grey Interactive

Think Brownstone

NGen Works

Bureau of Digital

Mechanica

Palantir

Fresh Tilled Soil

We’re Fresh Tilled Soil. UX Designers and strategists inspired by human biology. Our strong opinions are our own. We take full responsibility for what we say and create.

Richard Banfield

Written by

Dad, husband, cyclist, CEO of @freshtilledsoil. I write books on design & product.

Fresh Tilled Soil

We’re Fresh Tilled Soil. UX Designers and strategists inspired by human biology. Our strong opinions are our own. We take full responsibility for what we say and create.

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade