Image for post
Image for post
Photo by chuttersnap on Unsplash

Twinkle, Twinkle, Inefficient Star

Or, the Sublime Quest for Fusion

The Sun.

A huge ball of nuclear fusion.

All that MASS and POWER.

Just to twinkle.

Image via European Association for Astronomy Education

Awesome Twinkling Power

How much energy does the sun twinkle away every day?

“In one second, our sun produces enough energy for almost 500,000 years of the current needs of our so-called civilization.” (Boston.com)

Multiply that by seconds per day and you get 43 BILLION years of our energy wants. Daily.

And this is just one average star in a universe full of them. Routinely twinkling billions of years worth of energy into oblivion.

The meager planets that lurk in the fringes catch some energy scraps while struggling to keep their atmospheric coats on.

Image for post
Image for post

Of course, the stars aren’t just twinkling benign energy, there’s quite a bit of radiation in the mix (cosmic rays!) If it weren’t for Earth’s magnetosphere, we’d be toast.

Awesomely Elegant Local Fusion Scene

I’m not here to question Almighty architecture or the divine purpose of a vast expanse of space dotted with flaming twinkle balls, light years away from one another.

I’m here to point out how heroic, efficient and elegant the fusion endeavor on Earth is.

It seems like only yesterday (1868) when someone proposed the existence of helium in the sun. And a little while later when they proposed the electron (1898) followed by the proton, and finally (1932) the neutron.

Yes, it wasn’t until the 30s that people figured out what fusion was, and realized the sun operated on it…and then quickly realized how hard it was.

A fusion reaction will only take place at extremely high temperature and pressure: about 100 million degrees and 1000 times normal solid densities. In stars (like the sun), gravity confines the hydrogen at the density necessary for fusion. On our cold little planet, that doesn’t happen.

Faced with this enormous hurdle, did we give up on fusion? Did we give up on scaling it down to earth? No.

Image for post
Image for post
Indoor skiing facility in Germany

The Ski Slope Analogy

As you can see from indoor ski slopes, you don’t need the mass of a mountain to ski, you just need the slope.

In Fusion, you don’t need the mass of a star, you need heat and confinement. You need to keep the nuclei of atoms crushed together so close, and moving with such energy, that they are unable to avoid each other, collide and fuse together.

And so the fusion community wrestles with elegant magnetic cages or an array of lasers firing on a tiny point to implode it, and many other under-explored ideas.

And it’s working. Fusion has been taking place in labs around the world, with increasing efficiency. Net energy (aka ignition) has not yet been achieved, but we’re on the way. Yes, we are orders of magnitude away from that point, but think of how many orders of magnitude we’ve come. We’ve made fusion happen without the mass of that giant twinklebox. Where does that stand on a fusion Moore’s Law scale? Think of the sun as Fusion Reactor 1.0. Then check out the chart below.

Image for post
Image for post

Man v. Sun

Many people deride the “quest” aspect of fusion. Some don’t have much confidence in mankind’s ability to solve the fusion challenge. Others deride its inefficiency. As Romm says in the NYT article, “Fusion is done by our sun really, really well and for free. Here on Earth in reactors…not so much.”

The point of this article is to offer perspective. In fact, the sun isn’t doing fusion that well. It’s actually glaringly inefficient.

True, human-made fusion reactors don’t, at present, provide us with commercially viable energy. However, once we crack fusion, even our most inefficient, bulky designs will be more efficient than the sun. Technically, they will be billions of times more efficient.

This is because the sun, that huge fusion reactor in the sky, uses all that mass and power just to TWINKLE.

We are engineering stars — without all the waste. This is something extraordinary. And most people are whining about running their refrigerators today and missing the bigger picture of what the fusion endeavor is trying to accomplish. It’s not just about your energy. It’s about a LEAP of capability.

Originally published at www.fusionenergyleague.org by Rezwan Razani

Fusion Energy League

We bring people and nuclei together.

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store