The Habit Loop: How Your Environment Encourages Bad Habits

Why behavioral science says context is more important than willpower

Jennifer Clinehens
Jan 25 · 6 min read

“When we look at living creatures from an outward point of view, one of the first things that strike us is that they are bundles of habits.”

— William James, psychologist

Why? He goes out to a bar with a friend who smokes.

Image for post
Image for post
Photo by Ander Burdain on Unsplash

Why does being in a bar overpower Joe’s best intentions? Well, Joe’s surrounded by cues to light up — a glass of whiskey, a warm spring night, and good company who’s also smoking. Joe walks into the bar with good intentions and a few smoke-free months behind him, but before he knows it, there’s a lit cigarette in his hand.

It makes sense that being in a bar persuades my friend to smoke. Everywhere he looks, there are triggers for old habits — and habits are compelling. Studies show that up to 43% of our daily actions are habits — actions performed without conscious thought.

43% of our actions are habits — actions performed without conscious thought.

How Habits Work

In the 1990s, researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) decoded the structure of habits. They coined the so-called “Habit Loop” that describes the neurological patterns that govern routines. The loop consists of three parts:

  1. The trigger (or cue): These are signals to our unconscious minds that it’s time to perform our habit. In Joe’s case, being in a bar with a drink in his hand is an unconscious trigger to smoke. For me, waking up every morning triggers a craving for a cup of coffee — not because I want one but because it’s something I do every morning.
  2. The routine: This is the habit itself. In Joe’s case, this means asking the bartender for his favorite brand, packing the box, then lighting and smoking the cigarette.
  3. The reward: This is the payoff you get from performing your habit. For example, Joe’s nicotine craving goes away, and he feels more relaxed. He’s also had a chance to bond with his friend who smokes while standing outside in good weather.
Image for post
Image for post
Image created by the author

There’s a lot of research into habit change, and many evidence-based strategies that can help you quit a bad routine. But most studies agree that you can isolate and avoid the triggers of your bad habit, you can significantly increase your odds of breaking that habit.

How managing your environment can help you break bad habits

Because most habit cues are environmental, changing your context is more important than relying on willpower.

Studies have shown there are five basic categories of habit cues. Use this list to systematically isolate and identify your trigger next time you have the urge to perform a bad habit:

1. Time

Time is a sneaky category because it can be closely related to our third trigger, “preceding action”. Eating breakfast every day at 7:30 am, only because “it’s time for breakfast” and not because you’re hungry, is an example of a time-based trigger.

Next time the urge for a bad habit appears, check the clock. What time is it?

2. Mood

Bad habits can form as ways to self-soothe. We smoke because we’re stressed out, we overeat because our boss is pushing us too hard, or we skip the gym for Netflix because we’re tired after a long day at work.

When your craving strikes, ask yourself, “How do I feel?” And it doesn’t have to be a negative emotion. The positive feeling of finishing a workout might be a cue to grab an unhealthy snack, for example.

3. Location and Context

Situations and surroundings can be triggering for many people, as in Joe’s case. When he walks into a bar, the smell of smoke, the availability of cigarettes, alcohol, and friends that smoke is a deadly combination. That’s also why a move or vacation can be a catalyst for breaking bad habits.

The next time the urge for your bad habit appears, look around. Where are you? Do you usually perform your bad habit in this context?

4. Preceding Action

According to research, it’s easier to make a habit stick if it’s built off an existing chain of action rather than pure motivation. For example, it’s easier to say, “I will exercise at 5 pm right after I close my laptop for the day” than to say, “I will exercise today.” This approach can work in reverse as well if you’re trying to identify the cue for a bad habit.

For example, you might eat a cookie every afternoon at 2:30 pm. When you take a look at your calendar, you realize that your one-to-one with a particularly stressful client happens every day at 2 pm, and it’s triggering you to self-soothe with a cookie.

Next time you have a craving, ask yourself, “What did I just do?”

5. Other People

The people you surround yourself with — particularly your friends — can change your habits. As social psychologist Amber Gaffney put it:

“The more of your identity you draw from a group, even when you’re not around that group, the more likely you are to uphold those values.”

Image for post
Image for post
Photo by Prophsee Journals on Unsplash

The bottom line

There are no silver bullets in behavior change. Studies have shown that willpower is a critical factor in personal management success. But before willpower kicks in, we need to use our powers of observation to isolate our cues.

Next time you have an urge to perform your bad habit, ask yourself:

  1. What time is it?
  2. How am I feeling?
  3. Where am I?
  4. Who’s around me?
  5. What action did I just perform?
  6. How am I feeling?

As you examine your environment to identify habit cues, remember the words of B.J. Fogg, professor at Stanford University and behavior change expert:

“There’s just one way to radically change your behavior: radically change your environment.”

🧠Want to learn more about evidence-based mind management for smart, ambitious folks?

Click here 👉 to subscribe to the Growth Habits Lab newsletter and I’ll send you a free PDF “25 Cognitive Biases and How to Use Them to Make Better Decisions”.

Growth Habits Lab

Science-based self improvement

Jennifer Clinehens

Written by

Behavior change strategist. Use science and psychology to improve design, CX, UX, marketing, habits — subscribe at https://choicehacking.com/newsletter/

Growth Habits Lab

How to apply behavioral science and psychology to habits, change, productivity, and decision-making

Jennifer Clinehens

Written by

Behavior change strategist. Use science and psychology to improve design, CX, UX, marketing, habits — subscribe at https://choicehacking.com/newsletter/

Growth Habits Lab

How to apply behavioral science and psychology to habits, change, productivity, and decision-making

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store