It’s Not Real Love — You Just Got “Cookie-Jarred”

Get to know what the “cookie-jarring” dating term means and how to avoid it.

Anggun Bawi
Published in
5 min readDec 13, 2023

--

Photo by Angela van Oeffelen

It’s crazy how he could go from making me feel so special to “Am I just a backup plan?”

That’s what happens when someone is cookie-jarring you. According to Forbes, it’s a behavior where your date is actively seeing/dating other people too — so you aren’t the “only one” like how they told you.

We all have different definitions of what commitment means. For some, you’re committed after a few months of seeing each other and for others, no relationship is serious enough unless you get engaged.

This is where these “cookie-jarring” dating terms showed up.

Unfortunately, some people want to have their cake and eat it too. Especially with the dating apps, it’s hard to just commit to one person at a time. They prefer to keep you in a “jar” in case their primary option isn’t working.

I figured I got “cookie-jarred” when I found a swimsuit in my then-boyfriend’s bathroom. We’ve been seeing each other for 6 months and in my dictionary, it was pretty serious.

But, for him, it’ll take at least a couple of years to consider it as a “real” relationship. He wasn’t ready to let go of his options yet.

--

--

Anggun Bawi
Heart Affairs

writing on trauma, dating and relationships - in the hope that you'll feel less alone on your journey | lives in vancouver 🇨🇦