How Pants Work
Published in

How Pants Work

Welcome to Aria 51

Carmen or Candide?

And aren’t they really pretty much exactly the same, anyway?

Probably a rock concert, anyway.

Like most people or no one, I can not keep Carmen and Candide straight in my head. I frequently think of one when I mean to think of the other and vice versa. No matter how many times I read up on them, I just end up confusing and conflating them and frustrating myself. So I sat down and made this comprehensive list of the salient characteristics of each for future reference and comparison.

  • Carmen is an opera based on a novella of the same name, whereas Candide is an operetta based on a novella of the same name. Both novel and novella were written by a Frenchman, though not the same Frenchman.
  • Carmen is written in the genre of opéra comique, but Candide is a comic operetta.
  • The events of Carmen take place in Europe. The events of Candide also take place in Europe.
  • The events of both Carmen and Candide take place in the past.
  • The music of Carmen took some time to become widely acclaimed for its brilliance of melody, harmony, atmosphere, and orchestration. The music of Candide, however, was immediately a hit.
  • The principal male role in Carmen is intended for a tenor. The principal male role in Candide, by contrast, is meant for a tenor.
  • Carmen has four acts. Candide has two halves.
  • Carmen features the “Toreador Song,” whereas Candide includes a song called “The Ballad of Eldorado.”
  • The chorus of Carmen includes several “young men.” One of the characters of Candide is “The Old Lady.”
  • I have never seen a performance of Carmen or Candide, but I have never listened to a recording of a performance of either one, too.

--

--

--

Recommended from Medium

Faithfully by Journey

Reexamining Durham’s Past Through Music

“I wish to play the Morin khuur with my heart, like a Mongolian”, the tale about flying horse

Tanille Edwards — “Not This Time” (Single)

1974: A Tragically Boring Year

We Were On a Roll

The Intimate World of a Story: Ali Hoefnagel’s “You Can Call Me Al”

Apple Music Exclusives Return; AfroCharts Offers Budding Musicians a Platform to Make Money; Indie…

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Matthew David Brozik

Matthew David Brozik

Novelist. Copywriter. Lawyer. Lone punman. Visit imdb.name

More from Medium

The one scene that DC needs to use in a Superman film

Death in Love

A patinated copper angel sits on a headstone in a cemetery, next to a black obelisk, tree trunk in left foreground.

Abraham Lincoln’s World Famous ‘Top-Hat’ | Do We Still Have It Today?

Do You Sell Bats Here? Or How I learned about Burglars and their SOP.