☁️Load Balancing in the Cloud Ecosystem: Huawei Cloud ELB vs Amazon ELB

Deniz Yalçın
Huawei Developers
Published in
5 min readMay 7, 2024
Huawei Cloud ELB vs Amazon ELB

Introduction🚀

Hi everyone👋, In today’s digital world, web applications are of critical importance for businesses and individuals alike. Ensuring the seamless and uninterrupted operation of these applications requires high availability and scalability. In this context, Elastic Load Balancing (ELB) services have emerged as critical tools for optimizing the performance and reliability of web applications by distributing incoming traffic across multiple servers and balancing the load.

This article will compare the ELB solutions of two leading cloud providers, Huawei Cloud Elastic Load Balancing (ELB) and Amazon Web Services (AWS) Elastic Load Balancing (ELB) services. We will examine the key features, advantages, and disadvantages of each service and provide a comparison table to assist users in making the most informed choice.

Huawei Cloud ELB

Huawei Cloud Elastic Load Balancing (ELB) is a cloud-based load balancing service that automatically distributes incoming traffic across multiple backend servers or containers to enhance application availability and scalability. It offers various load balancing algorithms, including round robin, least connections, and source IP address hashing, to ensure optimal traffic distribution based on specific requirements.

ELB seamlessly integrates with other Huawei Cloud services, such as Auto Scaling, to dynamically adjust the number of backend servers based on real-time traffic demands, optimizing resource utilization and cost-efficiency. It also provides comprehensive health checks to monitor the health status of backend servers and proactively remove unhealthy ones from the traffic flow, ensuring application resilience.

With its robust features and flexible deployment options, Huawei Cloud ELB empowers businesses to build highly available, scalable, and cost-effective web applications that can handle fluctuating traffic patterns and support growing user demands.

Huawei Cloud ELB Example Schema

Load Balancing Algorithms⚖️

1️⃣ Round Robin

Distributes requests sequentially across servers. Simple and easy to use, but can lead to load imbalances.

2️⃣ Least Connections

Directs new requests to the server with the fewest active connections. Better for balancing server load and optimizing performance.

3️⃣ Source IP Address Hashing

Distributes requests based on source IP addresses. Ensures requests from the same source go to the same server, useful for dedicated server assignments.

Health Checks

Provides comprehensive health checks to monitor the health status of backed servers. Utilizes methods like HTTP ping, TCP ping, and custom health checks. Automatically removes unhealthy servers from traffic flow.

Amazon ELB

Amazon Elastic Load Balancing (ELB) is a cloud-based load balancing service that automatically distributes incoming application traffic across multiple Amazon EC2 instances, containers, and IP addresses. It offers a comprehensive suite of features to ensure optimal traffic management, application health, and security. ELB plays a crucial role in modern cloud architectures by enhancing application availability, scalability, and cost-effectiveness. It enables businesses to seamlessly handle fluctuating traffic demands, ensuring seamless application performance and user experiences. With its robust capabilities and flexible deployment options, ELB has become an indispensable tool for organizations of all sizes seeking to optimize their cloud-based web applications.

Amazon ELB Example Image

Load Balancing Algorithms⚖️

1️⃣Application Load Balancer (ALB)

Employs sophisticated algorithms like Weighted Round Robin, Least Response Time, and Sticky Sessions to distribute traffic based on various factors like request latency and application health.

2️⃣Network Load Balancer (NLB)

Utilizes high-performance algorithms like Random, Least Connections, and Source IP Address Hashing to efficiently handle high-volume traffic at low latencies.

Amazon ELB Example Schema for NLB and ALB

3️⃣Gateway Load Balancer (GLB)

Amazon Gateway Load Balancer (GLB) caters specifically to internal traffic management within a Virtual Private Cloud (VPC). Unlike Application Load Balancer (ALB) and Network Load Balancer (NLB) that handle external traffic, GLB operates solely within the VPC, distributing traffic across multiple network endpoints. This is particularly useful for microservices architectures where various internal services communicate with each other. By employing a GLB, you can achieve efficient load balancing within your VPC, improve scalability for internal services, and simplify traffic management within your private cloud environment.

Health Checks

Provides comprehensive health checks to monitor the health status of backend resources. Utilizes methods like HTTP, TCP, and custom health checks to proactively identify and remove unhealthy resources from traffic flow.

Features

Load Balancing Algorithms

Huawei Cloud offers basic algorithms like Round Robin, least connections, and source IP hashing for general load distribution. Amazon provides a wider range of options. Application Load Balancer utilizes advanced algorithms like Weighted Round Robin and least response time for application-aware distribution. Network Load Balancer focuses on high-performance traffic handling with algorithms like source IP hashing for efficiency.

Auto Scaling Integration

Integrate seamlessly with their respective auto scaling services(Huawei Cloud Auto Scaling and Amazon Auto Scaling) to automatically adjust backed resources based on traffic, optimizing resource utilization and cost-efficiency.

Health Checks

Huawei and Amazon offer comprehensive health checks using methods like HTTP, TCP and custom checks to monitor backed health and proactively remove unhealthy resources from traffic flow, ensuring application uptime.

High Availability

Huawei Cloud ELB supports multi-AZ deployment and offers a highly available architecture for fault tolerance. Amazon supports multi-AZ deployments too.

Scalability

Both scale to handle significant traffic volumes and support application growth. Huawei Cloud ELB is designed for thousands of servers, while Amazon ELB boasts millions of requests per second capability.

Pricing

Huawei Cloud ELB offers a single pricing 💸 model based on instance type and bandwidth. Amazon ELB has a more complex pricing structure based on the specific ELB type (ALB, NLB, GLB), request/response traffic, and data transfer.

Listener and Backend Configuration

Both services allow creation of listeners that define the incoming traffic protocol (e.g., HTTP port 80) and backend server groups that contain the actual servers handling requests. Huawei Cloud ELB keeps things simple with a single ELB type, while Amazon ELB offers three distinct options: Application Load Balancer (ALB) for advanced Layer 7 features, Network Load Balancer (NLB) for high-throughput Layer 4 traffic, and Gateway Load Balancer (GLB) for east-west traffic within a VPC.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both Huawei Cloud ELB and Amazon ELB offer robust load balancing solutions. Huawei Cloud ELB provides a simple and cost-effective option for basic Layer 4 and Layer 7 needs. However, for complex deployments requiring advanced features like QUIC protocol support, granular health checks, and intricate auto-scaling configurations, Amazon ELB with its diverse suite of options (ALB, NLB, GLB) might be the better choice. Ultimately, the ideal platform depends on your specific requirements, budget, and desired level of control. Consider your traffic patterns, desired functionalities, and existing cloud ecosystem when making your decision.

References

--

--