Want To Change The Way People Think? Start With A Great Story.
When I was a kid, my mom had stories for everything: why you should brush your teeth, eat vegetables, not talk to strangers or do drugs. The one I remember vividly, though, is about lying.
When I was six was on a baseball team. I loved playing in games but didn’t care much for practice. To get out of it, I’d pretend I was sick. When she caught on to what I was up to, Mom threatened, “You were too sick for practice yesterday, so you must be too sick to play in your game today.”
The details are fuzzy, but I probably cried a lot and ran around throwing a fit. When I was done, she told me the story of the little boy who cried wolf. The lesson? No one believes a liar, even when they’re telling the truth.
After that, I only needed to hear the story to know it was time to shape up each time I stretched the truth. The story changed me. Against my instincts and desires, it forced me to be a better person. I still remember it today when the temptation to lie strikes.
But it’s not just me. Story is a powerful motivator for change in anyone. If you have a message for the world — if you’re trying to get people to change the way they think and behave — a story could be the most powerful weapon in your toolbox.
Why Story Is A Powerful Motivator
Think of a recent argument. Specifically, a time someone tried to get you to change something about yourself. They might have explained how they don’t like how you act and that you should change it for various reasons.
You, however, happen to like yourself just how you are thankyouverymuch! The more they confronted, the more you tuned out, thought of something else, resolved to be more the same than ever before!
Changing the way someone thinks or acts requires confrontation. You have to point out their inadequacy and try to say or do something that will make them change. Turns out, people don’t like that. Especially when what you’re trying to change is a long-held habit.
Rather than listen, you tune out and look for proof you’re perfect just the way you are. It’s called confirmation bias.
But when you tell a story, the reaction changes. If someone tells you you’re overweight and need to lose 50 pounds, you’re probably not going to like that. But if they casually tell you a story about their friend who lost weight, you’ll listen with great interest. You might even tell yourself, “I can do that! I should do that!” And if you hear that story a few times in a few different ways, you actually might.
Why? Because a story does two powerful things to persuade:
- It removes direct confrontation. When you tell a story, you’re no longer telling someone what they should or shouldn’t do. Instead, you’re laying out a scenario they can follow that will lead them to the result you want. But will they listen? Yes, because…
- It forces the listener to take part in the story. If I tell you about my friend who built a successful business in a year by waking up an hour early every day, you can’t help but place yourself in the story. You see yourself waking up early. You see yourself typing and scribbling notes. You see yourself checking your growing bank account.
This is the weird thing your brain does to process a story. It forces you to take a first-person perspective, and that vision of yourself — once it’s in your head — is an incredibly powerful motivator to make a change.
How To Tell A Convincing Story
It’s not enough to just understand how stories win hearts and minds. You have to be able to craft your own.
If you have a message for the world — if you’re on a mission to change the way people think or behave in some aspect of their life — your success will depend on your ability to tell great stories.
The formula is pretty simple, though. You can create your own persuasive story in just a few minutes.
- Think of the core message you want to get across to people. What is it and why is it important? Why should anyone listen to you?
- Think of a behavior someone should change or action they should take to live that message. What’s one specific thing they can do to put them on the right path?
- Find a story of someone who’s done it and succeeded. Tell it far and wide. Create your hero and use them as your example.
Maybe you want to…
- Change how people eat. Rather than wagging your finger, tell stories about people who’ve gotten fit and healthy by creating better eating habits. Or, tell stories about people who didn’t and suffered.
- Sell your world-changing product. Don’t talk about its features. Tell stories about people who’ve used it and improved their lives.
- Get schools to fund music education? Don’t just cite stats to the school board, tell the stories of five kids who learned music and became successful students.
This will take crafting over time to get right — and it will need to vary from person to person as you tell it — but if you really want to make a difference in someone’s life, don’t just tell them what to do and why they should do it. Show them with a powerful story.
Tyler Tervooren explores psychology, sharing research and insights about winning at life, work, and adventure by taking smarter risks. For more, join his Smart Riskologist Newsletter.
Thanks to David McRaney and Melanie C. Green for their fantastic discussion about this topic in Episode 14 of the You Are Not So Smart Podcast that informed this article.