Meet the SAFG: DeFi’s Emergent Framework for Participatory Investing and Protocol Development

Gavin
Gavin
Apr 30, 2020 · 7 min read

Last week, we saw the successful alpha launch of Futureswap, and this week, the first public voting on Compound’s governance protocol is taking place. While seemingly disconnected, these events in the DeFi space point to a tectonic shift in the nature of crypto investing for both individuals and institutions.

This category of change can be characterized by a framework I’m calling the SAFG: the Simple Agreement for Future Governance. While conceptually similar to Y Combinator’s SAFTE (the Simple Agreement for Future Tokens or Equity; covered below), the SAFG is meaningfully different. It is an evolution — an earned right based on participation — that enables decentralized protocols to more effectively launch, grow, and govern themselves with their communities.

But the SAFG is not a contract that a company will give you to sign. Rather, the SAFG is an agreement, in code, between the protocol and its community. And it states that when you organically invest your time, resources, and energy into the project, you literally earn the right to participate in future governance decisions. It’s that simple, but as you’ll see, this simplicity is deceptively powerful.

It’s About Participation and Governance

Today: Investors buy into SAFTEs.

Tomorrow: Anyone participates to earn SAFGs.

The SAFG uncovers a blueprint for how DeFi projects can launch faster, create economic models more tailored to their communities, and align the long-term interests of their participants to the growth of their protocol.

Fundamentally the SAFG shifts us from a world of “buying to own” to one of “participating to govern,” which can ultimately result in more successful protocols and healthier communities.

The SAFTE’s Shortcomings

When the world needed a simple, standard method to bring capital together with early stage founders, YC introduced the SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity). This became the industry standard for structuring early stage deals. As the crypto market developed, and venture capital needed a uniform way to access these new deals, the SAFE (d)evolved into the SAFTE, which accounted for conversions between tokens and equity.

While the SAFTE iterated on a widely accepted instrument based on historical deal structures, it didn’t fully align with crypto’s ethos of open access. The SAFTE restricted purchase to accredited investors and did little to improve incentive alignment with the protocol’s actual users.

The SAFG Framework

People who participate in the protocol earn governance tokens that can eventually be used to vote on protocol changes.

The SAFG framework is so simple that its most powerful aspects are easily overlooked. But don’t let its simplicity fool you. The SAFG optimizes for the creation of protocols that are minimal from an early feature standpoint, yet maintain maximum flexibility in critical venues (e.g., regulatory, economic).

The structural pattern for launching a protocol with the SAFG is that its governance tokens:

  • Can only be earned through authentic participation in the protocol;
  • Are likely non-transferrable and cannot be acquired on the open market at launch;
  • Guarantee no additional benefits (e.g., economic, at least initially) beyond participating in protocol governance; and
  • Are the primary mechanism used to vote on protocol changes.

That’s right; SAFGs are non-transferrable, non-income generating tokens that only guarantee holders the right to vote on protocol changes.

In an instant, protocol upgrades become even more interesting.

To understand how the SAFG serves as a potential roadmap for progressively decentralizing and evolving a project over time, let’s look at the recent launch of Futureswap’s trading platform and Compound’s governance protocol more closely.

Futureswap’s FST Token

Compound’s COMP Token

Why do we see this pattern occurring in two different places? What’s so interesting about the simple guarantee of being able to participate in future governance?

The Benefits of the SAFG

  • Improve governance participation rates and decision quality through long-term interest alignment;
  • Ship lighter, tighter protocols — faster;
  • Improve regulatory compliance in various jurisdictions; and
  • Enable optionality to introduce tailored, value-capture mechanisms at the right points in time.

Let’s look at what these mean in practice.

Improve Governance Participation Rates and Decision Quality Through Long-Term Interest Alignment

Ship Lighter, Tighter Protocols — Faster

Improve Regulatory Compliance

Enable Tailored Value Capture at The Right Moment

SAFG communities consider protocol upgrades as part of their engagement duty. And in these communities, authentic participation simultaneously builds a corpus of knowledge that can be applied to protocol upgrades when the time comes (if ever) to vote on value-capture mechanisms best suited for the protocol.

This is a complete inversion of the previous paradigm.

Historical product development paths forced products to market with economic models baked in, meaning the financial hypothesis had to be right from the start. You can only tweak things so many times when the end users aren’t fully invested in the process.

But with SAFG protocols, we no longer need to shoehorn economic models into products at the wrong moment. Instead, teams can trust an aligned, patient, and participatory community to design, vote on, and implement value capture mechanisms best suited to the protocol when the time is right.

The magnitude of this shift cannot be overstated.

DeFi Capital is Participatory Capital…

…and Participatory Capital is Writing the New Rules

Because investment in an emerging protocol is no longer an open-market purchase; it’s joining a community and using the protocol. In the process, you publicly prove or disprove the protocol’s viability while simultaneously proving or disproving your original investment rationale. It’s a double win for those who know how to play the game.

Yes, DeFi is quickly changing the world.

And the difference between investors who actually use the protocols they’re investing in and those who don’t grows more apparent with every block mined.

The ideas for the SAFG framework emerged from countless protocol and economic design sessions with my friends and colleagues at IDEO CoLab Ventures and a number of amazing people, projects, and teams in the DeFi space.

Looking to play by new rules? Get in touch; DMs are always open to people pushing boundaries.

Sincere thanks to my teammates Dan, Ian, Joe, and Tara for their feedback.

🕉️

IDEO CoLab

A collaborative network focused on accelerating the…

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store