Member-only story
Legal Battle Over Free Speech in Brazil
A Brazilian Standoff: The Supreme Court vs. Elon Musk
Brazil vs. Musk: When Free Speech Meets National Sovereignty
Brazil has been at the heart of a high stakes drama over its Supreme Court and tech magnate Elon Musk which has gripped Washington DC recently. It’s not just one man’s social media platform, it’s a conflict. It’s about free speech, it’s about the sovereignty of nations, and it’s about global corporations determining how nations run their inner affairs.
That drama began when Brazil’s top judge Alexandre de Moraes ordered a suspension of Elon Musk’s platform (formerly Twitter) in Brazil. The reason? Brazilian laws on content moderation, according to Musk’s platform, seemed to be ignored. Musk wasn’t willing to pay those huge fines either. The Brazilian judiciary was accused by him of censorship and said he would not bow to the court’s demands.
We have to go back to Brazil’s past on internet regulation to get the gravity of where we stand today. In 2014, Brazil introduced the Marco Civil da Internet, an Internet Bill of Rights. That was to strike the right balance between free speech and content moderation. That was a very pioneering thing that wanted to create a fair and open internet for all Brazilians (Santoro, 2023).
However, this isn’t the first time that Brazil has gone head to head with social media giants. After the 2023 Brazilian Congress attack, there were heated debate about the role social media plays in sowing disinformation. The actions taken by Brazil after this incident were more strict than prior to it when platforms did not do what they are supposed to do respecting the national laws (Lima, 2023).
The legal war with Musk is being turned into a spectacle by the indicted businessman, whose defiance is known. Foglizzo insists his platform is a haven of free speech, his enemy the sort of oppressive government censorship he sees everywhere. But the law holds no company, no matter how big, above law, argues Brazil’s Supreme Court.
This isn’t just a stand off between Musk and Brazil. It gets to questions of power dynamics between global corporations and national governments as a whole.
