Member-only story

Assumptions

Smuggling on a Drug Cartel Scale

James Hollomon
ILLUMINATION
3 min readJul 31, 2024

--

Drugs found in a container in the port of Cotonou, Benin, 2016
Drugs found in a container in the port of Cotonou, Benin, 2016. Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

This article is one of a series of articles introduced by Flawed Reasons to Believe in God. If you’re new to the series, you should read the Introduction before (or after) reading the material below.

What would a photograph of assumptions look like? That thought had me flummoxed as I sat down to write this chapter. Then, it dawned on me that religious apologists routinely use assumptions to smuggle thoughts or conclusions into a debate, thus sidestepping David Hume’s warning that you cannot get an ought from an is. Hence the image of drug smuggling. And the drug analogy holds when we consider intent. The haul shown above obviously indicates deliberate smuggling. Professional apologists (AKA excusagists) are usually carrying out their smuggling in quite an intentional fashion. For instance, if they are setting out to discuss why there is something and not nothing in our Universe, they will couch it as a debate about the Creation. Then they spring the trap, pointing out that a creation needs a creator, and that creator is, of course, their favorite God. But big-time smugglers sometimes hide contraband on some innocent “mule” without the carrier’s knowledge. I think theists are often so accustomed to thinking their God is behind everything there is that they accidentally smuggle in contraband thoughts and concepts.

--

--

ILLUMINATION
ILLUMINATION

Published in ILLUMINATION

We curate and disseminate outstanding articles from diverse domains and disciplines to create fusion and synergy.

James Hollomon
James Hollomon

Written by James Hollomon

Majored in Chemistry, designed electronics automation until the industry moved offshore, transitioned to writing & web development. Currently writing Cult.

Responses (1)