Democrats Can Secure Victories, Yet Struggle with Political Maneuvering

Winning a battle doesn’t equate to winning the war

Charlene Ann Mildred
ILLUMINATION
4 min readMay 28, 2024

--

People in Voting Booths — Photo by Scukrov on CANVA PRO

After another election, one truth stands out: Democrats can win but fail in politics. Winning in the voting booth only sometimes leads to lasting political control.

However, my counterpoint is that Democrats have repeatedly demonstrated their ability to galvanize support and secure electoral victories. They win close races through charismatic candidates, progressive platforms, or practical grassroots work. Yet, these triumphs can feel like pyrrhic victories.

The 2020 presidential election. Many celebrated Joe Biden’s win. They saw it as a triumph of decency and democracy over division. But losing Senate and House seats tempered the joy of winning the White House. It made it harder for the new administration to implement its agenda. Passing major laws was a struggle for Democrats despite holding the presidency. It showed their ongoing challenge.

Democrats are strong at mobilizing a diverse group of voters.

The party’s base includes various demographic groups with unique concerns and priorities. It’s also a potential weakness. It needs careful and continuous engagement.

Grassroots movements, including those led by Black Lives Matter and climate activists, have shown the power of democracy. Mobilization with effective organization can lead to cohesive efforts. The Republicans have excelled at maintaining disciplined, hierarchical structures, which ensure strategic alignment and consistency.

Yeah, I have actively participated in local Democratic campaigns, and I’ve seen firsthand the frustration of unrealized potential.

I was working on a city council race where our candidate had widespread support. The community was energizing, and the events drew big crowds. The excitement was clear.

Despite all this, our opponent — a Republican with a fraction of our resources — managed to win.

Why?

Because their campaign was ruthlessly organized. They knew exactly which doors to knock on, which voters to call, and how to turn out their base with military precision.

However, we got caught up in our momentum’s excitement. We still need to turn our enthusiasm into votes.

Democrats pride themselves on their nuanced and comprehensive policy proposals. While this intellectual rigor is commendable, it can also be a double-edged sword. No matter how well-intentioned, messages can become muddled in the public discourse.

Of course, the contrasting approaches to healthcare reform. Democrats have proposed detailed, multifaceted plans to expand coverage and reduce costs. Republicans have boiled their stance down to simple but misleading slogans. They use phrases like “Repeal and Replace.”

The media favors soundbites over substance, making it hard for the Democrats’ nuanced positions to gain traction.

A closer look at recent electoral data reveals some telling trends. In the 2020 election, Biden won key battleground states, including Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin, by narrow margins. These wins were led by high turnout in cities, not broad support.

This pattern shows a broader challenge.

Democrats can dominate in cities but struggle in rural and suburban areas. This geographic polarization poses a significant barrier to building a durable governing majority. They risk becoming a party confined to blue pockets in a sea of red. They must expand beyond the cities.

The ongoing filibuster is a prime example of the Democrats’ strategic quandaries. Abolishing the filibuster could allow for the passage of critical laws.

They would cover voting rights, climate change, and healthcare. Others see keeping the filibuster as a needed check. It stops future Republican majorities from enacting extreme measures.

They control the White House and Congress, but they’ve struggled to pass much of their agenda. Their procedural hesitations have held them back, as has the obstruction of a united Republican opposition. The Democrats’ divisions and their impact on effective governance.

Winning a battle does not equate to winning the war. For Democrats, the challenge lies in translating electoral victories into lasting political success.

Please subscribe here to receive the latest insightful stories by email.

Did you find this enjoyable? If so, remember to hit the clap button, which you can press up to 50 times and comment.
Take advantage of more from me — ensure you’re following if you still need to. Thank you for being an integral part of my journey.

--

--

Charlene Ann Mildred
ILLUMINATION

I'm a writer and content creator who loves to share tips on how to maximize your productivity. Email: charleneannmildredfbarroga@gmail.com