Zombie Shuffle: Dancing Through a World Without Mirror Neurons

What if You didn’t have Mirror Neurons?

The Role of Mirror Neurons in Understanding Others

Max Herrmann
ILLUMINATION

--

Photo by Vince Fleming on Unsplash

Imagine a world where no one had mirror neurons.
Humans would basically run around like zombies, not caring what others are doing. Dancing in a club, you would be completely oblivious to the rhythm and moves of those around you.
Dancing with friends? Oh, forget about synchronising in a flash mob or choreography for TikTok.

You would not be able to read the emotions or intentions of others. You would not correctly assess the aggression of the dude you bumped into in the club. That can get you into serious trouble!

Just imagine navigating through life without empathy or smiling when others smile at you.
You would need to learn empathy by reading books and studying emotions like you would learn engineering at university.

The way you would learn something is not by watching others. Fixing your tyre is much harder since you cannot simply imitate others how doing it. It would be only by being explained to you and you doing it with trial and error.

Diving into The Human Brain

Let’s look at two studies on mirror neurons.
Picture a basic movement of lips, and you try to guess what has been said.

In the right-top picture (first figure), the premotor cortex is highly activated, as is Broca’s area for producing speech.

What happens when you watch a monkey who indulges in some lip-smacking? Or a dog decides to join the conversation with a bark?
We get different outcomes in the human brain.

What will be more active?

The monkey’s lip-smacking, for sure! It is more human-like. We can do the same.
But the dog? Have you seen a human properly barking on the lawn of your neighbours? I doubt that!
That’s why we only see the visual cortex (back of your head) activated when the dog is barking, as the brain cannot relate to this behaviour.

The closer a behaviour is to human behaviour, the higher the activation. We need to be able to relate to and copy the behaviour.

Source: Buccino, Giovanni, Ana Solodkin, and Steven L. Small. “Functions of the mirror neuron system: implications for neurorehabilitation.” Cognitive and behavioral neurology 19.1 (2006): 55–63.

What does this tell us?

Mirror neurons are like hidden treasures scattered throughout the brain. They light up like Christmas trees when we watch others performing activities we can perform as well.
Even when we look at single neurons in areas where we would not typically expect mirror neurons, we still find them.

For example, these are neurons recorded in the supplementary motor area (SMA) and entorhinal cortex.

The left graphic (first figure) shows neurons in the SMA activating when observing behaviour, and the middle graphic shows the execution of the same behaviour.

‘Precision’ means in the study, participants observed a precision hand movement and then carried out the same.

In the second figure, we see neurons in the entorhinal cortex (in the middle of the brain) activating when looking at smiles and then performing smiling as well.

SMA mirror neurons recordings for precision hand movements, Source: Mukamel, R., Ekstrom, A. D., Kaplan, J., Iacoboni, M., & Fried, I. (2010). Single-neuron responses in humans during execution and observation of actions. _Current biology_, _20_(8), 750–756.
Entorhinal Cortex mirror neurons recordings for looking at smiling faces and smiling themselves, Source: Mukamel, et al. (2010), Current Biology

Like Sponges

This suggests that multiple systems exist even in non-motor areas, specially designed to respond to the actions of other humans, animals, and yourself.
From the earliest days of childhood, we’re like sponges, absorbing the world around us and learning through the simple act of observation.

This silent, implicit learning plays a crucial role in our development and the evolution of social behaviours across many species, from the loyal dog at your feet to the curious monkey swinging through the trees.

These are the wonderful mechanisms nature gave us to make us empathetic and social animals!

Give this article a clap, and see you next time :)

--

--

Max Herrmann
ILLUMINATION

Cognitive Science Student, interested in Neuroscience, Machine Learning, Psychology, Society, Second Brain and Philosophy