PHILOSOPHY

What Is Agnosticism? Clear up the Misconceptions About This Philosophical Position

I’ll give you a hint: they are not fence-sitters.

Alejandro Betancourt
ILLUMINATION
Published in
6 min readApr 21, 2022

--

Photo by Tim Marshall on Unsplash

Agnosticism is the idea that it is impossible to know whether God exists. It is a philosophical position stating that it is impossible to prove anything about God.

The word agnosticism comes from the Greek words “a,” meaning “without,” and “gnosis,” meaning knowledge.

Agnostics do not claim to know about the existence of God. They just don’t believe in him.

There are many misconceptions about agnosticism and what it means to be an agnostic person. Still, the most common one seems to be that they are atheist people who are afraid of admitting their beliefs.

Agnosticism is not a belief system but rather a claim about the limits of human knowledge. Agnostics are not saying that they don’t believe in God, but rather that they don’t know if he exists or not.

There are two types of agnosticism: weak and strong.

Weak agnostics say that it is possible to know if God exists, but we don’t have enough evidence to be sure.

Strong agnostics say that it is impossible to know anything about God, including his existence.

Agnosticism is often a middle ground between Atheism and Theism, but this is not always true. Some agnostics are atheistic, and some are theistic. It all depends on what an individual believes.

So, what do Agnostics believe?

This is a difficult question to answer because, as I said before, Agnosticism is not a belief system. Each person has their own. Yet there are some things that many Agnostics tend to believe.

Some common beliefs among Agnostics are:

  • There is no way to know for sure if God exists or not
  • The existence of God is unknowable
  • Agnosticism is a stance on the limits of human knowledge, not a belief system
  • Agnostics can be atheists or theists, depending on their individual beliefs
  • Science is the best way to learn about the natural world, but it cannot say anything about the supernatural
  • Agnosticism is not a cop-out or a way to avoid taking a stance on religion
  • Agnostics can have spiritual beliefs without subscribing to any particular religion

How does one identify as an Agnostic?

Agnostics are not sure about the existence of God and do not want to believe in any particular religion. They may or may not believe in a higher power or deity.

Agnostics are often confused with Atheists, but they’re different. Atheists do not believe in any god, while Agnostics don’t know if there’s one. Agnostic is an umbrella term that covers people who don’t know if they have a belief in God. At the same time, Atheists deny the existence of God.

You can be an Agnostic Atheist (don’t believe in God and don’t know if he exists) or a Gnostic Atheist (believe there is no God).

Agnosticism is not a religion, nor is it associated with any religious group. It’s a position on the existence of God.

Common misconceptions about the Agnostics Perspective

Agnostics are often misunderstood. Some people think that Agnostics are indecisive or ambivalent about their beliefs. This is not true.

Agnostics have a robust belief system, and it is different from theistic religions, like Christianity and Islam, for example.

Some people also think that Agnostics are fence-sitters who avoid taking a stand on anything. This is not the case either. Agnostics have steadfast beliefs; they just don’t involve the existence of a God.

People often associate the Agnostic position with laziness or apathy about finding out if God exists. This is not accurate. Many Agnostics seek evidence and try to answer the question, but they haven’t found a definitive answer yet.

Agnosticism should not be confused with Atheism.

Atheism believes that there is no god, while agnosticism believes that we cannot know for sure if there is a god or not.

Agnostic is a term that Thomas Huxley coined in 1869 to describe one who holds that it is impossible to know whether there is a God or anything beyond material phenomena.

Atheism is the conviction that there is no God. It is a positive belief in the nonexistence of a supreme being.

While both Agnostics and Atheists do not believe in God, they differ in their reasoning and approach to life.

Agnostics tend to be more open-minded and uncertain about their beliefs. Atheists are more sure of what they believe. They are often closed-minded about the possibility of a higher power.

What does this mean for me?

If you identify as an Agnostic, you don’t know if God exists or not. You may believe in a higher power, but you don’t subscribe to a religion.

Agnosticism is a valid perspective, and there is nothing wrong with being one. You can still have spiritual beliefs and be part of a community without subscribing to any religion.

It is possible to have a religious belief and yet be Agnostic. Agnosticism means that you are not sure whether there is a God.

Some people may believe in the existence of a god, but they don’t know if this God has any influence on their lives.

This could be because they don’t feel that they need to rely on this God for anything or are still thinking about the existence of a deity.

Others may believe in the existence of a God, but they don’t identify with any religion.

This could be because they don’t like the rules of a religious group or don’t believe that anyone’s religion is the right one.

If you’re unsure about your beliefs, there is nothing wrong with seeking answers. Many Agnostics are active in their quest to find answers to their questions.

Many resources help you explore your spirituality and find what works for you. You don’t have to subscribe to any particular religion or belief system to live a fulfilled life.

Is there life after death?

There are many things that we do not know about life after death. We cannot know if there is something after death or if there isn’t anything at all.

Agnostics tend to believe that we cannot know for sure if there is an afterlife or not. This is because there is no evidence either way. We have no way of knowing what happens to a person after they die, so we cannot say for sure that there is or isn’t an afterlife.

People often turn to religion for answers about life after death, but this can be difficult for Agnostics. This is because most religions require a belief in God, and Agnostics don’t necessarily believe in God.

However, some Agnostics do find comfort in the idea of reincarnation. This is the belief that a person’s soul continues to live on after their body dies. This could be in the form of another person, an animal, or even a plant. There is no evidence to support the idea of reincarnation, but some people find it a comforting belief.

What do Agnostics believe about the creation of the universe?

There is no one answer to this question because Agnostics can have different beliefs. Some Agnostics may believe that a God or gods created the universe. In contrast, others may think that the universe was created by chance.

Still, other agnostics may not believe in a creator and think the universe has always existed.

Agnosticism is a perspective that allows for many different beliefs, so there is no one answer to this question.

What do Agnostics believe about morality?

Morality is often based on religious principles, but this isn’t always the case.

Agnostics can have different views on morality depending on their personal beliefs.

Some Agnostics may believe in the same moral principles as a particular religion. In contrast, others may have their unique moral code.

Agnostics can also differ on whether or not they think there is such a thing as objective morality.

Objective morality believes that right and wrong are independent of what anyone thinks.

Subjective morality believes that what is right and wrong depends on each individual’s beliefs.

So, an agnostic could believe in objective morality (that there is a right and wrong independent of what anyone thinks) or subjective morality (that what is right and wrong depends on each individual’s beliefs).

What do you think about Agnosticism? Do you identify yourself as one? Can you see the difference between an atheist and an agnostic? Let me know what you think in the comments below!

If you enjoy what you’ve read, consider supporting other thousands of writers and me by becoming a Medium member. Here is my referral link. I will receive a small commission without costing you extra money by subscribing to it.

Or, if you want to show your appreciation for me, purchase me a cup of coffee. It is greatly appreciated!

--

--

Alejandro Betancourt
ILLUMINATION

Entrepreneur, Investor, Executive Coach & Author. Single Dad sharing insights on Mindset, Philosophy, and Self-Improvement.