What is the difference between Value Proposition and Product Positioning?

Hint: It has to do with the customer and the competition

Photo by Noah Silliman on Unsplash

Every marketer knows instinctively what a value proposition is. Their definitions of what a value proposition is may differ. They may even disagree on what makes a value proposition compelling.

Take product positioning. It is somewhat understood that you want to position your product in a certain way. This is especially so when you launch a new product. You can compare the product to what you believe are competing products. You certainly want to understand how the customer perceives the product. What would they compare it to?

Both disciplines draw on common marketing concepts. So how are they different, and where do they overlap? Let’s dig in.

Value proposition and product positioning are crucial for marketing success. But, they serve distinct purposes and operate at different levels:

Value Proposition:

• Focus: What value does your product/service offer to the customer?
• Scope: Broader, encompassing the benefit your product/service provides.
• Target Audience: Aimed at potential customers to persuade them of your offer.
• Function: Drives buying decisions. It highlights how your product/service solves a problem. It demonstrates how it fulfils a need better than alternatives.
• Example: A meal-kit delivery service offering healthy meals.

Value proposition: “Convenient and healthy meals delivered to your doorstep. It saves you time and effort while promoting healthy eating habits.”

Product Positioning:

• Focus: Where does your product/service fit within the market landscape?
• Scope: Narrower. Focus on differentiating your offering from competitors within a specific market category.
• Target Audience: Directed at customers, investors, or even internal teams. To create a shared understanding of the product’s place in the market.
• Function: Shapes customer perception and influences their buying choices. Emphasizes your unique strengths and competitive advantages.
• Example: The same meal-kit delivery service might position itself as “the premium meal-kit option for health-conscious professionals. seeking restaurant-quality meals with organic, locally sourced ingredients..”

Here’s an analogy that may shed some light:

• Value Proposition: Imagine a wall around your house. It highlights the benefits of having a wall for protection and privacy. It solves the customer’s problem.
• Product Positioning: Now imagine that wall. It can be a brick wall, wooden fence or steel palisade fencing. It is structurally and materially quite different. Product positioning differentiates that bridge from other bridges (competitors) based on specific characteristics.

Key Differences:

Created by the Author

In essence:

• Your value proposition explains why a customer should choose your product.
• Your product positioning clarifies how your product is different from the competition.

Both elements are essential for a successful marketing strategy. A strong value proposition attracts customers. An effective product positioning convinces them to choose your offering over others.

Examples of Effective Value Propositions and Production Positioning

Here are some examples from well-known brands:

1. Slack

• Value Proposition: “Where work happens.” Slack focuses on making teamwork more efficient and enjoyable. They provide a central hub for communication, file sharing, and collaboration.
• Product Positioning: Slack positions itself as the leading workplace communication platform. It replaces email and other tools with a more streamlined and integrated solution. Their marketing materials often highlight features like channels, integrations, and search functionality. These features enhance team productivity.

2. Apple iPhone

• Value Proposition: “Experience the difference.” Apple emphasizes the iPhone’s premium design, seamless user experience, and innovative features. It enhances everyday life.
• Product Positioning: Apple positions the iPhone as a high-end smartphone. It combines cutting-edge technology with elegant aesthetics. Apple knows how to differentiate itself from competitors. It focuses on its brand image, loyal customer base, and ecosystem of products and services.

3. Dollar Shave Club

• Value Proposition: “A great shave for a few bucks a month.” Dollar Shave Club disrupted the traditional razor market. It is offering affordable, high-quality razors delivered directly to consumers.
• Product Positioning: They position themselves as a convenient and cost-effective alternative. It paints other razor brands as expensive and over-marketed. Their humorous and irreverent marketing campaigns directly challenge established industry norms.

4. Tesla

• Value Proposition: “Accelerating the world’s transition to sustainable energy.” Tesla’s mission goes beyond selling electric cars. It aims to revolutionize the automotive industry and promote sustainable transportation.
• Product Positioning: Tesla positions itself as a luxury electric vehicle manufacturer. It is at the forefront of innovation and sustainability. They emphasize performance, technology, and environmental consciousness. They do this to attract environmentally conscious and tech-savvy consumers.

5. Airbnb

• Value Proposition: “Belong anywhere.” Airbnb offers unique and authentic travel experiences. They connect travellers with local hosts and accommodations worldwide.
• Product Positioning: Airbnb positions itself as a community-driven alternative to traditional hotels. They emphasise local experiences, affordability, and a wider variety of lodging options.

Key Takeaways from these Examples:

• Clarity is Key: Each company clearly articulates its value proposition and product positioning. It is concise and memorable.
• Target Audience Focus: These companies understand their target audience’s needs and aspirations. They tailor their messaging to the needs of the target audience.
• Differentiation Matters: They highlight what makes them unique and better than the competition. It could be innovation, affordability, or a specific brand experience.
• Consistency Across Channels: Their messaging is consistent across all marketing channels. It could be websites and advertisements social media and customer interactions.

Conclusion

We have established the clear difference between Value Proposition and Product Positioning. It differs in focus, scope, target audience and function. Value proposition explains why a customer should choose your product. Product positioning shows how your product is different from the competition.

Our examples show that Value propositions and Product Positioning need to be clear and focus on customer needs. It must differ from the competition.

For more practical tips to grow your business or help you navigate your career as a business developer join my newsletter here.
You’ll get weekly actionable steps to propel your growth as a professional and to apply in your organisation.