The Enduring Significance of Thomas Hobbes in Modern Politics

The Political Philosophy of Thomas Hobbes

Naushad Sajnani
ILLUMINATION’S MIRROR
6 min readFeb 6, 2024

--

By John Michael Wright — ., Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=6370879

Renowned English philosopher Thomas Hobbes, who lived in the 17th century, made a substantial contribution to political philosophy by developing the social contract theory.

Sovereign Authority and the Social Contract Theory

Hobbes’s idea of the social compact is one of his most important contributions to political theory. Conflict and chaos are the hallmarks of existence in a state of nature without governance, according to Hobbes.

Hobbes contends that people make a social contract with a sovereign power, giving up their rights in return for security and order in order to escape this chaotic situation.

Hobbes held that society order requires the formation of an absolute sovereign authority. He was a supporter of unrestricted, total government power because he thought that any restriction on such power would cause internal strife and maybe even the country’s downfall.

The sovereign is in charge of establishing and upholding laws, resolving conflicts, and preserving social order.

Nature’s Condition and Tension

Hobbes’s natural state, which is an absence of government, is characterised by strife and disorder as a result of people’s unbridled freedom. Hobbes describes existence in this condition as “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.”

His depressing depiction of the condition of nature emphasises his conviction that a strong central authority is required to preserve social harmony and stability.

Hobbes contends that individuals are compelled to pursue peace and submit to political power by the laws of nature, which are imperatives arising from rational self-interest.

According to him, people’s basic instinct is to protect themselves from harm and will do actions that will prevent confrontation and ensure their own safety.

Influence on Contemporary Political Theories

Our knowledge of international relations and government has been greatly influenced by Hobbes’ political philosophy, which has had a significant effect on contemporary political ideas.

His conception of the social compact signalled a change in the basis of political legitimacy from the divine prerogative of monarchs to a societal consensus.

Notwithstanding criticism, Hobbes’s theory continues to have a significant impact on our understanding of the nature of political power and the state’s role in upholding law and order and safeguarding individual rights.

Scholars continue to analyse and discuss his ideas in great detail, providing varying interpretations and critical evaluations.

Thomas Hobbes’s Perspectives on Justice and Morality

Hobbes tackled the topics of morality and justice in addition to politics. Even if his political theory has more sway than his moral philosophy, it is nevertheless important to consider his opinions on these issues.

Debate Concerning Human Self-Interest

A contentious issue that has dominated discussions of Hobbes’ moral philosophy is his conception of human nature. Some contend that Hobbes only considers the self-interested or egoistic aspects of human nature, and they propose that a more realistic understanding of human drive would prevent Hobbes’ political conclusions.

Still, the majority of academics agree that Hobbes had a more nuanced understanding of human drive.

Hobbes accepted that people had a need for their own survival and well-being, but he also recognised that people are capable of reason and cooperation. Although everyone has self-interest, Hobbes thought that rational self-interest might persuade people to desire peace and submit to governmental power.

Impact on Political and Social Order

Hobbes’ political theory is closely linked to his beliefs about justice and morality. He maintained that subjects are not responsible for acts taken in compliance with the sovereign’s laws, so long as their compliance does not endanger their hopes for eternity.

grasp Hobbes’s general theory of social and political order requires a grasp of this idea of moral responsibility within a political context.

Hobbes thought that moral order in society could only be established and sustained by a powerful central authority. People may escape the turmoil and strife that define the natural state by yielding to this power.

By doing this, Hobbes aimed to provide logical guidelines for building a civic society that would not collapse from within.

Hobbes’ Moral Philosophy Interpreted

Hobbes’ moral theory is interpreted differently by different people, especially when it comes to how he feels about religion, gender, and race. While some interpretations contend that Hobbes attempted to disprove religious ideas, others contend that he only wanted to show how compatible he was with Christian principles.

Hobbes was well ahead of his time in how he treated women and the family. He openly recognised women’s equality as well as their inherent right to autonomy and freedom in the natural world.

Hobbes’s use of patriarchal terminology, however, causes friction and begs the issue of how essential Hobbes’s arguments are to his larger theory.

Similar ambiguity may be found in Hobbes’ remarks on race. He rejects the intrinsic distinctions between various cultures that result from scientific progress while also using imagined “savage” communities to show the circumstances of existence in the natural state.

These conflicts draw attention to how complicated Hobbes’ moral theory is and how important it is to read it carefully.

Hobbes, Thomas: Life and Times

It’s important to take into account Hobbes’s intellectual milieu and the historical setting in which he lived in order to completely comprehend and value his philosophy.

Political Events’ Influence

Hobbes was born in a turbulent political climate in England in 1588. Hobbes’ political ideas were greatly impacted by and shaped by the English Civil War. Hobbes was inspired to create ideas of social and political order by the turmoil and collapse of the political system during this period.

Hobbes came to the conclusion that a strong central authority is necessary to preserve peace and stability in society as a result of the events of the Civil War. The political events of his day had an impact on his political philosophy books, such as Leviathan and De Cive.

Philosophical Advancement and Development of the Mind

Hobbes’s schooling and contacts with well-known intellectuals of the day influenced his intellectual growth.

After completing a rigorous education in Latin and Greek classics, he worked as a teacher for the son of the Cavendishes, a powerful aristocratic family. He was able to participate in significant political conversations and learn about thought-provoking concepts thanks to his job.

Hobbes’s philosophical contributions were also greatly influenced by the scientific concepts he encountered while touring Europe. Incorporating scientific techniques and reasoning, he emphasised the value of rationality and factual evidence in his philosophy.

Comparative Analysis of Other Political Theorists

It is useful to evaluate Hobbes’ political philosophy by contrasting it with those of other well-known political theorists from both before and after him.

A century before Hobbes, Nicolo Machiavelli highlighted the harsh realities of power and saw politics as a separate, secular field from religion.

A few years after Hobbes, John Locke wrote, accepting the parameters of Hobbes’ discussion and debating the scope of power and authority in politics.

By contrasting these intellectuals, we might learn more about Hobbes’s unique views and the enduring influence of his political theory.

The Legacy and Ongoing Influence of Thomas Hobbes

Hobbes’s philosophy, which has persisted throughout history and influenced many philosophers in a variety of areas, had a profound effect on political and social philosophy.

Notable thinkers like Adam Smith and Jeremy Bentham were influenced by Hobbes’ views, which have greatly influenced British political and social theories.

His writings contributed to a more complex understanding of human nature and government by serving as a counterbalance to the more idealistic viewpoints of thinkers like Jean-Jacques Rousseau and John Locke.

Hobbes’s theory is still relevant and useful in today’s world of international relations and administration. His focus on the need of a powerful central government to maintain law and order and defend individual rights has shaped our conception of political systems and the function of the state ever since.

To sum up, Thomas Hobbes’s moral and political philosophy has had a long-lasting influence on political thought.

Our conception of political power and the upkeep of social order has been influenced by his views on the social contract theory, the natural state, and the need of an absolute sovereign.

His ideas on self-interest and moral obligation within a political framework provide insights into the intricacies of human nature, even if his moral philosophy has not gotten as much attention.

The legacy of Hobbes continues to elicit discussion and provide light on significant issues pertaining to politics, morality, and social order.

--

--

Naushad Sajnani
ILLUMINATION’S MIRROR

Crafting words, I breathe life into stories, articles, and essays that stir hearts, incite thought and ignite imagination