Police Chiefs & DAs Have No Idea What They Are Doing

This is a reprint of an older article…

Baltimore Police Department — Western District

It is in the first sentence of, An open letter to Baltimore’s interim police commissioner from Fred Bealefeld and Gregg Bernstein reveals a huge problem with law enforcement.

“Beginning in 2008, the number of homicides and shootings in Baltimore began to steadily decline, culminating with a homicide rate below 200 in 2011, which had not occurred since 1977 (nor been repeated since).”

The reform in policing that I have been advocating starts with empathy, but the second principle is science. Law enforcement is dominated by ideology, not scientific rigor. Somehow, this has spilled into the culture of every facet of criminal justice, even academia. As the letter states of the strategies (which are ideologies), “They are not complicated or novel; indeed, it is public safety 101.” They are right, it is.

Frederick H. Bealefeld — Former Commissioner of Baltimore Police Department

This issue is why current and past leaders in command are, for the most part, wholly blind to what am I am saying and trying to advance. It is a struggle to criticize these ideas without criticizing the individuals. I am stating that policing has become blinded, not that they are blind. In the case of the former commissioner, Fred Bealefeld, I like the guy, liked talking to him, he recognized my way of thinking, but, “Bad Guys with Guns” is not a crime strategy, it is simply a tagline. The plan had nothing remotely resembling a crime plan. A crime plan ties together every facet of the agency into a mutual goal, each having their roles and milestones to achieve. This level of planning is at the minimum. In practice, the strategy focused on only one thing, bad guys. Who were the bad guys that police in Baltimore look for? I have already explained it, approximately 16–24-year-old black males.

It is not just Baltimore that goes after this group of citizens, as they state with pride in the letter, they did not do it alone. This strategy, this thinking, this ideology was also agreed upon by all of their federal, state, and local partners. All of them seeing no problem with this and no problem with reducing victimization of humans to the cold numbers of stat chasing with Comstat, Gunstat, Policestat, and more. Something is very wrong with what we are doing. The cognitive dissonance is staggering. The further writings in the open letter, discuss engaging the community, and that it is more than just “much deeper than just locking up bad guys” (even though that was the only plan). You will see these types of statements being made all around law enforcement, we have been taught what to say, and we have been taught what to do, but those things have nothing in common.

Gregg Bernstein — Former Baltimore State’s Attorney

It’s easy to say, look crime went down when we did this. That is nothing more than a correlation about an anecdotal event. The problem with portraying anecdotes of success as actual plans that work is that it is not viewed in its totality. Science and professionalism are severely missing from police strategy and criminal justice as a whole. For something to be considered a fact, it must be reproducible. For example, either this is not a sound strategy or every other police leader is a fool for not adopting it because it would reproduce the same results. Think of fighting crime like mowing the lawn, and the grass represents crime. The proponents of an aggressive response, develop big and vigorous lawn mowers to chop down the grass. They may be good at it, they may be great at it, but they only see with blinders on. They hate grass, mow down grass, and store the clippings in a bin away from the land. What they are not seeing is that their big and strong lawn mower is towing a spreader full of fertilizer and seeds. The fertilizer contains environmental poisoning, lack of opportunity, poor socioeconomic conditions, institutionalized racism, breaking down of families, hopelessness, over charging, power imbalances, corruption of justice, militarization, housing segregation, feeding of the prison complex, a war on drugs, and more. They rarely, if ever, stand back to notice that they are making the situation worse in the long term.

It is of no coincidence that crime is rarely addressed with these types of methods in rural, country, suburban, or even Baltimore’s white neighborhoods. An actual strategy to address crime would work in any community because crime is a human thing. These are not sound policies. We need a far reaching rethinking of what policing is. Proactive policing is a term that is used as a justification for heavy handed police actions which have the intention of preventing crime. If police are to prevent crime, we have to have to work on killing the roots, not reinventing and improving upon ways to keep our grass cutting business going.

Michael Wood Jr. is a police management scholar who after spending a career in the USMC and Baltimore Police Department, took to dismantling the blue wall of silence and creating the pathway to reform; a model called Civilian-Led Policing. His fight for justice has included leading the historic Veterans for Standing Rock action in December of 2016, listening to the front lines of Black Lives Matter, opposing money in politics, and elevating the voices of others. You can find Michael in hundreds of media appearances, from HBO’s Fixing the System documentary with President Obama, to The Joe Rogan Experience, to published opinion pieces in The Guardian and Baltimore Sun, and everything in-between, where he furthers the discussion on criminal justice systems and institutions, and the needs of society.

LinkedIn; YouTube; Instagram

iMemberTimes is the digital newsprint of iMemberMedia. We are open to submissions and new writers.

--

--

--

Edited by Dr. Michael Wood Jr., an internationally recognized public safety expert, and scholar of police management.

Recommended from Medium

This is a totally normal story by the way

45 Practical Ways to Live an Anti-Racist Lifestyle (without posting on Facebook!)

Barriers Are Not A Myth

I See Homeless People

These comments appeared on a SLJ article comment thread regarding sexual harassment in the kid lit…

The Subjectivity of Men in Patriarchy (XI): Justice

How social media has started a movement

The Case For A Compassion-First Approach To Homelessness

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Dr. Michael Wood Jr.

Dr. Michael Wood Jr.

USMC, BPD(ret), author “The Business of Policing”

More from Medium

The Youngest

Final Reflection Essay

I think I’m a pretty good talker.

The Thing No One Told You About Challenges!