Indeterminate checkboxes are weird

A checkbox usually has two states: checked and unchecked. But indeterminate checkboxes are in a third state: neither checked nor unchecked. The “checkedness” is not determined.

You have seen these before. The most common reason to have an indeterminate checkbox is when it is controlling a set of checkboxes. When none of the checkboxes are checked, neither is the master checkbox. When all of them are checked, so is the master checkbox. But if some are checked and some are not checked? The master checkbox state cannot be determined—it is indeterminate!

For example, each email in your GMail inbox has its own checkbox to select it. Up top, there is another checkbox. If you check that one, all of the emails are selected. Uncheck to deselect all emails.

If you only select a few emails, then the state of that checkbox cannot be determined. You have neither selected all of the emails, nor have you deselected all of them.

The checkbox to select all or none of your emails appears in an indeterminate state when only a few of the emails are selected.

How do we make this happen?

Although indeterminate checkboxes are conceptually simple, implementing them correctly on a web page is not. We will be referencing the HTML specification about checkboxes and using that information to implement indeterminate checkboxes.

Let’s go!

Content and IDL attributes

The first part of the specification we need to understand is this:

If the element’s indeterminate IDL attribute is set to true, then the control’s selection should be obscured as if the control was in a third, indeterminate, state.

This begs the question: What is an “IDL attribute”?

Glad you asked.

In HTML, elements have “content attributes”. These are the attributes that you can set on HTML elements, such as id and class.

<p id="neat-paragraph" class="neato">Content attributes are neat</p>

HTML code is interpreted by the browser on the web page’s first load in order to initialize the DOM. You can use content attributes to set up the initial state on the DOM nodes created by your HTML code.

Later on, if I wanted to get the class name for this element in JavaScript, I could do this:

const p = document.querySelector("#neat-paragraph");
console.log(p.className); // "neato"

That property className on the p element is an “IDL attribute” for that element. “IDL” stands for “Interface Definition Language” (The Web IDL is the specification for IDL attributes to be implemented in web browsers). In JavaScript, we can use IDL attributes to interact with the state of DOM nodes.

So to sum up:

• Content attributes: The attributes you set on DOM nodes by writing them in your HTML code.
• IDL attributes: The attributes on DOM nodes that you interact with in JavaScript code.

Content attributes and IDL attributes often correspond, but not always. In the example above, we see that the content attribute is called class but the IDL attribute is called className. The kinds of things you can do with those attributes are also totally different between HTML and JavaScript.

The indeterminate attribute is one case of an IDL attribute that does not have any corresponding content attribute. This means that the only way to set this state is with JavaScript.

const cb = document.querySelector("#select-all-checkbox");
cb.indeterminate = true;

Checkboxes only have two states

The next important thing we need to understand is this:

The control is never a true tri-state control, even if the element’s indeterminate IDL attribute is set to true. The indeterminate IDL attribute only gives the appearance of a third state.

This is good to keep in mind. Whether or not a checkbox is checked is always determined; it is always true or false. This matters when you are handling the submitted values from a `form`. It will never submit an indeterminate value.

A note about ARIA

I am always trying to keep my websites accessible, and you should, too. To keep things accessible, it is important that we follow the ARIA guidelines from the W3C. They have excellent documentation!

For checkboxes, there is an aria-checked attribute that you could set on the checkbox. It is strongly recommend that you don’t do this. The reason for this is that it would be really bad for aria-checked to disagree with the actual state of the element.

The good news is that the value of aria-checked is automatically calculated for you!

The Chrome developer tools has an Accessibility tab where we can see the computed ARIA attributes for the elements in the DOM. As you can see, the computed Checked value for an indeterminate checkbox is “mixed”.

I don’t see any reason why you would need to manually set the aria-checked attribute for a checkbox, unless you are building one from scratch out of div elements.

Perhaps you think you need this so that you can write a CSS selector for indeterminate checkboxes.

However…

There’s a CSS selector for that

More good news! CSS allows us to select checkboxes in any of the three states using pseudo-classes.

• The :checked pseudo-class selects checkboxes that are checked.
• We can use :not(:checked) to select for checkboxes that are not checked.
• The :indeterminate pseudo-class selects checkboxes in an indeterminate state.

A React + TypeScript implementation

Now that we have pulled back the curtain on tri-state checkboxes, I will end this post with an implementation of a Checkbox component in React + TypeScript. The benefits of wrapping the native element in a component is that we can support an indeterminate prop right on the component itself.

The goal is to use the Checkbox like so, where checked and indeterminate are two boolean props on the component.

<Checkbox checked={true} indeterminate />

Here is the full implementation:

You can play around with it in this Codesandbox.

Happy hacking!

I would like to extend my gratitude to the following people:

• Matthew Newman for reviewing an early draft.
• Devin Dreszer for reviewing an early draft.
• Nathanael Beisiegel for clarifications.
• Miriam Speert Crowley for great questions that improved the content of this post.