AI

Should Medium Consider Banning AI Art?

An occasional thief has questions

Charles Bastille
Ink & Tears
Published in
8 min readSep 18, 2024

--

Head shot of Arnold Schwarzenegger as the Terminator as rendered in a wax museum.
Image by By AmeriCantaro licensed from Adobe Stock

What if I told you that the AI art you’re using has a high likelihood of violating copyright law?

A recent article in IEEE Spectrum released evidence that major generative art services like Midjourney and DALL-E 3 may be routinely generating art files that are blatant copyright violations without their users even knowing.

When you’re creating content for Medium, anytime you use a copyrighted image without permission or proper licensing, you risk being sued by the artist who created the image.

According to the IEEE Spectrum article, creating art with AI increases your exposure to pesky lawyers regardless of your intent.

One of the two authors of the article is a visual artist, Reid Southen, who has produced concept art for such films as “The Matrix Resurrections”, “The Hunger Games,” and “Independence Day Resurgence.”

He and co-author Gary Marcus found blatant copyright violations from Midjourney by using a simple prompt such as: “Just show me a movie screencap from the Avengers Infinity War movie from 2018 halfway through the movie.”

The resulting art included exact replicas of the scenes from the movie, including, in this specific case, a…

--

--

Ink & Tears
Ink & Tears

Published in Ink & Tears

By highlighting the school-of-hard-knocks writing lessons we’ve learned with personal experiences and data-driven, no-fluff advice we improve our writing craft. Laugh, or cry — but leave it all on the page.

Charles Bastille
Charles Bastille

Written by Charles Bastille

Author of MagicLand & Psalm of Vampires. Join me on my Substack at https://www.ruminato.com/. All stories © 2020-24 by Charles Bastille

Responses (11)