Pick a Pile: SNES Vs. PlayStation JRPGs

When was the true Japanese RPG Golden Age?

Aidan Moher
Insert Cartridge

--

I’ve recently been listening to USGamer’s Console RPG Quest, a podcast series from Kat Bailey and Nadia Oxford that chronicles the history of Roleplaying Games across many of gaming’s most popular (and not so popular) consoles. Kat and Nadia are both huge Japanese RPG fans (like your intrepid writer here), and, as all things do when JRPGs are involved, their overarching narrative comes down to the ever-asked, never-answered question: Was the JRPG Golden Age during the SNES or PlayStation era?

Wanting to play along, I raided my gaming collection and pulled out two JRPG piles: SNES and PlayStation. I’m going to go through these piles game by game, discussing what I think they say about the JRPG Golden Age along the way, and why I think it’s tricky, if not impossible, to ascribe the Golden Age to a particular console.

Super Nintendo JRPGs: Chrono Trigger, Final Fantasy VI, Illusion of Gaia, Trials of Mana, Super Mario RPG
Super Nintendo JRPGs: Chrono Trigger, Final Fantasy VI, Illusion of Gaia, Trials of Mana, Super Mario RPG

Pile 1: Super Nintendo Entertainment System

The Super Nintendo was an absolute JRPG juggernaut. While the genre hadn’t yet reached mainstream appeal, it was laying the groundwork for a revolution and evolution that would arrive only a few years later. Playing through Final Fantasy VI nowadays, it’s easy to see the first strides toward the more cinematic storytelling the series would embrace…

--

--

Aidan Moher
Insert Cartridge

Hugo Award-winning writer ft. in WIRED, Washington Post, and Kotaku, and author of "Fight, Magic, Items." He lives on Vancouver Island with his wife and kids.