The Marble Jar: Cultivating a Love of Learning & Leadership

By Dawn Daley, Educator

“Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a fire.” — William Butler Yeats

Creating a positive classroom environment where students are motivated, respectful, and engaged can be a challenge. However, using a structured, consistent, and rewarding approach to behavior management can transform the classroom dynamic. One system that has proven successful in my K-5 classrooms over the years is the Marble Jar system.

Foundation of the System

The system is simple yet powerful. I purchased two large jars, one empty and one filled with marbles. Over the course of about two months, I focused exclusively on emphasizing and reinforcing positive behaviors. Each time I noticed a student exhibiting a positive behavior, either I or a student would place a marble in the empty jar. More importantly, I only rewarded behaviors I wanted to reinforce, such as keeping hands to selves, taking turns, or using polite words like “please” and “thank you.”

As these foundational behaviors became routine, I adjusted my focus to acknowledge and reinforce new, more advanced behaviors. These included completing assignments, working cooperatively with peers, and demonstrating leadership by following expectations even in less structured environments like hallways, recess, and the library. Over time, I increased the spacing of rewards, as positive behaviors became the norm rather than the exception. This shift helped students develop intrinsic motivation (Deci, 1985), rather than relying on external reinforcement.

Concrete-to-Abstract Learning in Action

The Marble Jar Reward system serves as a concrete-to-abstract learning experience, a best practice in education that helps students internalize concepts through tangible experiences (Bruner, 1966). Initially, students engage with the physical act of placing marbles in the jar, allowing them to see their positive actions accumulate toward a shared goal. This hands-on interaction reinforces behavioral expectations in a concrete way. Over time, as the system progresses, students transition to understanding the abstract concept of intrinsic motivation and collective responsibility, making this approach an effective developmental tool in behavior management (Piaget, 1952).

As William Butler Yeats once stated, “Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a fire.” The Marble Jar system embodies this philosophy by inspiring students to take ownership of their learning and behavior, igniting a lasting passion for growth and leadership.

Building Buy-In

From the outset, student input was integral to the success of the system. Prior to launching the program, I facilitated a discussion where students suggested various types of rewards for filling the marble jar. This buy-in created a sense of ownership and excitement. Suggested rewards ranged from movie and popcorn days to extra recess, robotics activities, craft projects, and even cooking experiences.

To keep the process fair, a student would blindly select a reward from the premade class party list each time the jar was full. Over the course of the year, every student had an opportunity to draw the reward, ensuring equity and motivation. The parties were held at the end of the school day, approved by the administration, and often supported by families who volunteered or provided treats.

A key principle of the Marble Jar Reward system was that all students participated in the earned reward, regardless of individual infractions. If a student had a minor behavior issue–even on the day of the celebration–they were still included. This distinction was crucial because the class, as a whole, had earned the reward. Instead of exclusion, any behavioral concerns were addressed through one-on-one restorative justice discussions, focusing on learning and growth rather than punishment.

Meaningful and Thematic Celebrations

Each marble jar party was intentionally designed to be interactive and hands-on. Themes varied based on student interests and seasons. Some examples included:

• Cooking Individual Pies: Students read a social-emotional learning (SEL) book related to teamwork, then wore student-made chef hats while making their own pies.
• Pirate Fort Building: Students dressed up as pirates with mustaches and student-made pirate hats and worked collaboratively to construct forts from classroom materials.
• Movie & Ice Cream Social: Students enjoyed a movie while making their own ice cream sundaes.

No matter the theme, the goal was always the same: engagement, celebration, and reinforcing the positive classroom culture that students had helped build.

Lasting Impact

The greatest success of the Marble Jar system was not just in the celebrations themselves but in the transformation of classroom culture. Students became invested in maintaining a respectful, responsible, and positive learning environment. Instead of focusing on negative consequences, they became motivated to contribute to a culture of leadership and learning. Over time, positive behaviors became habitual, intrinsic motivation increased, and a sense of community flourished.

By implementing a system that highlights and rewards positive behaviors, educators can create a classroom where respect, engagement, and leadership become the norm. The Marble Jar system not only fosters good behavior but also nurtures a supportive and enthusiastic community of learners–one marble at a time.

References

Bruner, J. (1966). Toward a Theory of Instruction. Harvard University Press.

Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (1985). Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior. Springer Science & Business Media.

Piaget, J. (1952). The Origins of Intelligence in Children. W. W. Norton & Company.

Yeats, W. B. (n.d.). Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a fire. [Attributed].

Dawn is a passionate educator at heart. She has over 15 years of experience serving organizations across the globe. Dawn specializes in crafting creative learning solutions. Her expertise spans instructional design, training & development, facilitation, and teaching & coaching, enabling her to deliver impactful, learner-centered programs. Some of her favorite K-12 areas to teach include technology, literacy, and language. She has a master’s degree in education and several professional certificates in areas of specialization. She was nominated for teacher of the year in two organizations and has won several distinctions and honors. Over the course of her career, she has served in suburban, inner-city, and overseas school systems where her love for learning blossomed.

Follow the conversation #WhyITeach

To be reminded why your work is so very important and for more stories and advice, visit our collection of teacher perspectives at The Art of Teaching.

You can view the McGraw Hill Privacy Policy here: http://www.mheducation.com/privacy.html. The views and opinions expressed in this blog are those of the author, and do not reflect the values or positioning of McGraw Hill or its sales.