The Cost to Create: Winky Skull Enamel Pins

Kickstarter creator Carol Benovic-Bradley shares the dollars and cents behind her 2017 project.

Kickstarter Magazine
4 min readJun 18, 2019


The Cost to Create is a new series that invites creators to share how they spent the funds they raised on Kickstarter in detail. Our first entry comes from two-time creator and former Kickstarter staffer Carol Benovic-Bradley, who raised $713 for her project, Winky Skull Enamel Pins, in 2017. If you’re interested in sharing your Cost to Create story, reach out to us at

I had been working at Kickstarter for three years and still hadn’t run a project when we announced our first creative initiative, Make 100, in 2016. I had spent the past few years talking to creators about best practices when it comes to running a campaign, and Make 100 seemed like the perfect opportunity to give it a try myself. So I combined my love of enamel pins and creepy stuff and launched a project for Winky Skull Enamel Pins.

My original budget for the project was $500. This factored in the cost of making 110 enamel pins (about $300), funds for some design help ($100), and some additional budget for shipping and packaging expenses ($100).

I ordered the pins and got the design work done before my campaign launched because I wanted to receive the pins in a timely fashion for backers. So before I even ran the campaign I spent $275.22 on the pin manufacturing and $100 on design work. I really banked on my campaign getting successfully funded, but figured I could always sell the pins one by one or on Etsy if the campaign didn’t go well. Luckily it went well!

My costs

In the end, my campaign raised $713 (142% of my original goal) from 70 backers, 66 of whom pledged to receive the pin. After fees and dropped pledges, I had a total of $642.53. Here, I’ll break down how I spent that money.

Manufacturing: $275.22

Manufacturer: Made By Cooper
Details: 110 enamel pins and backing cards
A fellow Kickstarter creator referred me to Made by Cooper, a good quality, affordable option for manufacturing the pins. However, the trade-off for the affordable price was time. It took over two months from the time of my order to receive the pins.

Design: $100

Designer: Courtney Moy
I asked Courtney, a friend of a friend and a designer I’d worked with before, to come up with some potential designs for the pin. I ended up going with a version that another friend made for the final pin, but I used Courtney’s original sketches for the backing card (see image below).

Packaging: $50

I bought some fancy envelopes for shipping the pins, but once I looked closer, I realized that they didn’t have any adhesive glue on them (WTF!). So instead of sinking more funds into buying new envelopes, I got some heavy-duty tape to make sure that they stayed sealed during transit.

Packing up the pins

Initial shipping: $50

I hand-shipped a few rewards. I only had a few backers in countries other than the U.S. I was surprised that shipping something to Canada was just as expensive as shipping something to Germany!

Additional shipping: $107.55

Shipping company: Shyp
This is probably TMI, but right around the time I was fulfilling my project, I got my wisdom teeth removed (see this update). Turns out that when you get your wisdom teeth removed, you do not want to go to the post office. So I ended up using Shyp. They picked up my remaining rewards and shipped them out for me. It was a little more expensive than doing it myself, but I had funds remaining that could cover the cost.

The final breakdown

Carol’s final budget

What I learned

Overall, Winky Skull taught me that even when a project seems simple and easy, delays can happen. Production of the pins took longer than I thought it would, and life (wisdom teeth removal) got in the way. Also, shipping things isn’t as simple or straightforward as I thought it would be.

All that aside, it was a super fun project to work on and I still get compliments on the pin to this day. I definitely have a few other enamel pin ideas up my sleeve.

Lastly, it was a great first foray using Kickstarter! I was so excited that my friends wanted to help me make this project happen and there were even a few folks I didn’t know who supported Winky Skull.

Want to share your Cost to Create story with Kickstarter? Reach out to us at with the subject line “Cost to Create.”



Kickstarter Magazine

We are a Public Benefit Corporation. Our mission is to help bring creative projects to life.