The Tale of a Typical Website

Let me tell you the story of (almost) every single website and intranet redesign projects I have been a part of for the past 20 years.

Image for post
Image for post
The sitemap of a typical website. Somewhere, buried deep inside here, is the actual page that the user wants.

1: Start with the front page

Most website or intranet projects start out by discussing the content, buttons, colours and pictures on the front page.

As soon as the fancy digital agency has shown their first design sketch, just about everyone in the organization has an opinion about what should go on the front page:

Oftentimes these discussions end up with the foolish carousel on top, where the organisation’s inability to prioritize really comes to the fore.

And the discussions tend to go on for the entire lifespan of the project.

2: Create a huge structure

In parallel, and under the radar, the information architect creates a huge site map and a grand navigation design.

The graphic designer produce template sketches of the front page, category pages and the generic one-size-fits-all “article template”, filled with lorem ipsum and dummy text.

And the CMS developer has already created the entire information structure with empty categories, filled with either “Content goes here” or his own ramblings about what he had for dinner. (Sometimes these texts even find their way to the finished website, and can stay there for years without anyone noticing it).

3: Fill in the content as an afterthought

As an afterthought, usually around two weeks before launching the new site, someone remembers that we forgot to write most of the content.

Of course we migrated most of the crappy content and press releases from the old site, but we need lots of new pages too.

And then content producers of all kinds are summoned to write product descriptions and filler content for the section pages in the information structure. Everything else goes in the generic article template.

The content producers work late nights and are beginning to hate their jobs. Despite their efforts, the night before the planned launch date only half of the content is in place.

But finally, after two days (and nights) of overtime, the content producers can breathe a huge sigh of relief. Hopefully it will be years until next time.

4: Launch and leave

And so the site is finally launched.

A bit overtime of course (because of the slow content production in the end) and way over budget (because the designer had to make three major revisions to the design, after development had started).

But we’re live! Let there be champagne! And press releases!

And now, for heaven’s sake, let’s close this project and get back to work.

The fancy agency submits their work to design competitions, and after a few months we might even win prizes for “most innovative graphic design” (that mostly confuses the users) or “interactive annual report of the year” (even if no one ever reads it).

Let there be champagne! And press releases! Again!

And now let’s get back to our real work.

5: Let the user sort it out

And so in the end, it is up to the users to find out where on the website they can have their questions answered.

If they make it to the front page, they have to circumnavigate the rotating carousel, the totally irrelevant news articles and the cryptic banners and links to different departments and silos in the organization.

If they try to navigate, they might have to deal with the dreaded mega menu, packed with three levels of information architecture.

And if they in their desperation, God forbid, reach for the internal site search, they are immediately drowned in the same old news articles and outdated content that was migrated from the previous site.

This is why almost all the users on the entire Internet have found out that it’s much easier to just google their own keywords, and get straight to the content they want. Hopefully without drowning in irrelevant menus and links.

That is unless of course the snake oil salesmen of the SEO industry, the gurus of content marketing, and the highest bidding competitors in Adwords have filled the google search results with links to misleading and irrelevant content.

6: Let your content rot over time

As soon as the site is launched, all kinds of arbitrary new content needs emerge:

And the poor web editors, who have no real mandate to decide anything, have to go along with just about everything.

They sometimes tries to make a stand and say no, but if a senior in command has ordered something to be “released immediately” they have to dance to his tune.

7: Rinse and repeat

Fast forward 4–5 years, and the complaints about the website from everyone in the organisation are starting to become unbearable.

Users can’t find their way around the website. Customer service is bogged down with questions from angry customers. Product managers are frustrated with users who don’t understand their products.

Then finally, someone in management decides that something has to be done.

Our old website is “outdated”!

Call in a fancy digital agency, and let them redesign it to make it more usable!

And so the process starts all over again.

But first we need to discuss the front page…

This little rant is an excerpt from my upcoming book about the Core model — an antidote to all this idiocy. The working title of the book is “The Core model: A common sense approach to digital strategy and design”. It will be published in Norwegian first. To receive updates about the book, the Core model and it’s inventor (me), please follow @coremodelbook on Twitter.

You can read an introduction to the Core model here.

And why not check out this related rant about news sickness.

Thanks to Chris Atherton and Gerry McGovern.

Alt du trenger å vite om kjernemodellen

Are Gjertin Urkegjerde Halland

Written by

Kjernekar, syklist og far til 3 + kjernemodellen. Trenger du sparring, foredrag eller workshop? Kontakt meg på // Inventor of the Core Model.

Kjernemodellen er eit enkelt og effektivt verktøy for å forenkle, prioritere og få ting til å skje i digitale kanalar.

Are Gjertin Urkegjerde Halland

Written by

Kjernekar, syklist og far til 3 + kjernemodellen. Trenger du sparring, foredrag eller workshop? Kontakt meg på // Inventor of the Core Model.

Kjernemodellen er eit enkelt og effektivt verktøy for å forenkle, prioritere og få ting til å skje i digitale kanalar.

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store