Are gendered designs a real thing?
Exploring how colors can create clash between culture and genders
Introduction
Have you ever thought about how your experiences on a website or app might be shaped by your gender? Probably not, right? As I delve into the fascinating world of User Interface (UI) design, I’ve begun to realize how gender subtly influences our interactions with digital spaces. In this article, I’ll share my exploration of gender in design, how it impacts users, and the growing need to embrace a more inclusive, gender-spectrum approach.
Understanding Gender in Design
I’ve always known that colors played a role in design, but it’s intriguing to see how deeply gender has influenced color choices in UI design. I’ve begun to notice patterns linked to traditional gender roles. For example, UI designs for apps targeting women tend to feature pastel colors, gentle curves, and graceful fonts. On the flip side, apps targeting men often showcase darker tones, bold lines, and strong typography.
This made me wonder : Do colors inherently signify gender? Have we been conditioned to associate certain colors with specific genders?
I came across a study in the Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, suggesting this color-gender association is not just a Western phenomenon but also exists across various cultures. But, interestingly, scientists argue that the way we perceive colors is mostly subjective. It can drastically vary based on personal experiences, cultural context, and even linguistic differences.
In an intriguing study, researchers sought to understand how color perception varies across cultures. They created questionnaires, translated them into the native languages of participants, and included color swatches for clarity. Participants were undergraduate students from eight different countries, representing diverse cultural environments.
The colors chosen were the ones most often studied in previous color research. Participants were asked to share their associations and preferences for each color. This approach aimed to understand not only what people associate with each color but also their personal liking for each color, shedding light on how cultural background might influence color perception.
Supporting this claim another survey showed, Japanese people preferred cars in color of White and more subtle tones, While people from Hong Kong preferred cars in color red. These color preferences due to culture relates to how user interfaces are design as well. This only drives us away from the notion that colors mean only gender, when there are so many other factors playing at hand.
Moreover, colors in UI design often serve specific functional purposes beyond gender implications. For example, red, often associated with urgency or importance, is frequently used for action buttons like ‘compose’ in email apps. Green, typically indicating success or progression, is often used to signify task completion.
As I delved deeper, I realized that these gender-color associations could unintentionally perpetuate stereotypes. What’s more, they might not resonate with individuals who don’t identify with traditional gender norms, potentially making them feel excluded.
So, in the quest for greater inclusivity in design, it seems crucial to challenge these long-standing norms and associations. It’s becoming clear to me that while colors are a significant element of design, their association with gender is more a societal construct than an inherent quality. Color is a universal language, and its use in design should reflect the diversity and inclusivity of our world.
The Impact of Gendered Design
The more I delved into the concept of gendered design, the more I understood its profound implications. I started to see that a user interface (UI) design reflecting a user’s gender identity could significantly enhance their digital experience, making it smooth and more engaging. However, what was equally apparent was the potentially negative effect of a design that did not resonate with a user’s gender identity. This could turn what should be an enjoyable experience into one that is disconcerting, or even alienating.
It was surprising to find that gendered design extends beyond the more noticeable aspects like color palettes or typography. It’s also deeply ingrained in more functional elements. Take online forms, for example. They often present users with only two options for gender, “male” and “female.” But what about those who identify as non-binary, genderqueer, or another identity outside of the traditional binary? I realized that such designs could inadvertently exclude or marginalize these users, contributing to a sense of being a digital outlier.
The Need for a New Approach
This led me to question the very foundations of UI design. I wondered, “Is there a way to design interfaces that are inclusive, that cater to everyone regardless of their gender identity?” In my quest for answers, I started uncovering articles, research papers, and case studies advocating for a significant shift in UI design — a shift beyond the traditional gender norms.
One of the most striking discoveries I made was in an article on CareerFoundry, where it mentioned a study indicating that gender-neutral design could boost user engagement by as much as 25%. This was a revelation to me. It suggested that inclusive designs not only foster a more welcoming user experience but also have a tangible impact on user engagement.
Further exploration led me to understand the idea of the gender spectrum, which views gender as a fluid and complex construct, rather than a simple binary. It seemed to me that embracing this approach in UI design could better align digital spaces with modern understandings of gender. This could potentially create a more inclusive and representative digital world.
But this idea cannot be implemented in all fields, at least not at present. For instance, a medical or a fitness apps are forced to opt a binary approach to properly diagnose users.
However, understanding this was just the first step. The challenge is in translating this understanding into practical strategies that can be applied in UI design — a challenge that I, and many others in the field, are still exploring and grappling with.
Case Studies
Let’s take a look at some real-world applications of a gender-spectrum approach. A notable example is the design transformation of the Lyft app. Previously, it featured pink accents and a fluffy, cursive logo — elements typically associated with femininity. However, in 2015, Lyft moved towards a more neutral palette with bolder fonts, a decision reflecting a shift towards gender-neutral design.
Another intriguing example is the Android 14 update, which introduces grammatical inflection, allowing apps to adjust their language based on the user’s chosen gender identity. This feature acknowledges and respects gender diversity, representing a significant step towards more inclusive UI design.
As of iOS 13.2, Apple introduced a gender-neutral voice option for Siri, its voice-controlled personal assistant. This was an important step towards accommodating a broader spectrum of gender identities.
In 2019, Google released 53 new gender-inclusive emoji that did not adhere to traditional gender stereotypes. These emoji, available in a variety of skin tones, showed men and women in roles that traditionally were gender-specific, such as haircut or sauna.
Conclusion
Delving into the world of gender in UI design has been an intriguing journey. The relationship between design decisions and user experience has unfolded before me in unexpected ways, prompting a reevaluation of how we perceive gender in digital spaces. I’ve discovered that incorporating a gender-spectrum approach into design can cultivate inclusivity, engage a wider audience, and enhance user engagement.
I’m far from done with this exploration, but one insight stands out: adopting a gender-spectrum approach goes beyond merely crafting a better user interface — it’s about crafting a more inclusive digital world. We all have a role to play in understanding this complexity and taking steps toward creating change. As we unravel the intricacies of gender in UI design, we’re not just enhancing the user experience, we’re redefining it in a more diverse and inclusive way.
ANNOUNCEMENT 🔥
We’re working on our very own AI tool that lets you create fully editable screens just from text prompts!
Check it out here and don’t forget to join the wait-list!
