Do You Need an Attorney for a Valid Prenup in California?

Attorney Aimée Hart
Law is in the air
Published in
4 min readFeb 9, 2024
Photo by Alvin Mahmudov on Unsplash

Picture this: You’re all set for the big day, the wedding of your dreams in sunny California. But before you sail off into the sunset, there’s one crucial question to ponder — do you need an attorney for a valid prenup in California?

A prenuptial agreement, colloquially known as a prenup, isn’t just a formal document. It’s a financial pact that could stand as a cornerstone of your marriage, defining the economic landscape of your union. In the Golden State, the legality of these agreements is governed by specific rules that can make or break their validity. So, let’s dive into whether you should call up a lawyer or go at it solo.

Prenuptial Agreements in California: The Basics

In the eyes of California law, a prenup is more than a mere contract; it’s a safeguard for your future. It’s how you and your partner lay all your cards on the table, detailing who owns what and how assets (and debts) will be handled in case of a divorce or death.

For a prenup to hold water in California, it must meet specific benchmarks, a few examples being:

- Written and signed by both parties (sorry, verbal agreements won’t cut it).

- Entered into voluntarily, without any duress or undue influence.

- Accompanied by both parties’ fair and reasonable disclosure of assets and debts.

Legal Requirements for Prenups in California

Within the legal landscape of California, while it’s true that an attorney is not a statutory requirement for drafting a prenup, there’s a significant caveat to this rule. Specific provisions included in your prenup, particularly those that waive substantial rights such as spousal support, may not stand up in court unless there was valid independent legal representation at the time of signing. The courts in California scrutinize these agreements under a microscope, especially when it comes to waivers of substantial rights. The rationale is that without the expertise of legal counsel, one may not fully grasp the extent and future impact of what they’re giving up. This lack of understanding could lead a court to conclude that the waiver was not genuinely voluntary — a concept central to any contract’s enforceability.

California’s adherence to the Uniform Premarital Agreement Act (UPAA) sets the stage for what’s kosher in prenups. One pivotal aspect of the UPAA is the spotlight on independent legal counsel. You’re not mandated to hire a lawyer to draft a prenup, but if you waive that right, you better believe it needs to be in writing.

Moreover, there’s a mandatory seven-day waiting period in California from the time the final version of the prenup is first presented until it’s signed. This isn’t a “wait-and-see” sort of deal; it’s a built-in reflection period to ensure both parties have ample time to consider the agreement and the opportunity to seek legal advice.

Therefore, while you might skip the lawyer to save some dollars now, it could cost you much more later if crucial terms are declared unenforceable or you don’t comply with its strict requirements before signing.

The Role of an Attorney in Drafting a Prenup

Having an attorney by your side is like having a GPS during a road trip. Sure, you could use a map and your gut instinct, but wouldn’t you rather have real-time updates and guidance? Lawyers ensure your prenup isn’t just valid but also tailored to your unique circumstances, protecting you from potential pitfalls like vague language or unenforceable clauses.

Attorneys can be particularly vital if there are significant waivers or complex assets, such as spousal support waiver, family business, or considerable inheritance issues. They’re your advocates, making sure the prenup stands up not only in the court of love but also in the court of law.

Can You DIY a Prenup in California?

The age of DIY has us believing we’re all jack-of-all-trades, but it’s a whole different ball game when it comes to legal documents. Online services and prenup templates might seem convenient and budget-friendly. Still, they’re often one-size-fits-all solutions to situations that are anything but.

DIY prenups can be particularly risky because they may not account for all the nuances of state laws or the intricacies of your finances. If a prenup isn’t up to snuff, you might find it torn to shreds by a judge when it matters most. One exception to this general rule that I have seen to be thorough and extremely helpful for straightforward cases is a website known as Hello Prenup. But even then, it’s essential to consider hiring an attorney to review the final version and instruct you on the correct procedure for execution.

There’s no shortage of horror stories where a lack of legal counsel in drafting a prenup led to a Pandora’s box of problems down the line. From undisclosed assets coming back to haunt to “quick and easy” online agreements crumbling under legal scrutiny, these tales serve as cautionary tales for why skimping on a lawyer can be costlier in the end.

Conclusion

A prenup is more than a legal formality; it’s a document that potentially maps out your marriage’s financial future and well-being. While California law doesn’t force you to hire an attorney, the complexity and importance of a fair and valid prenup often merit professional legal guidance.

Hiring an attorney isn’t pocket change, but neither is divorce. The initial investment in a lawyer might feel steep. Still, it pales compared to the potential costs of litigating a botched prenup.

So, before you sign on the dotted line, consider this: an attorney isn’t just an expense; they’re your safeguard, your advocate, and your surest bet in turning your prenup from a piece of paper into a shield for your future.

Still have questions? Your unique situation deserves a tailored approach. Reach out for a consultation to ensure your prenup stands on solid ground.

--

--

Attorney Aimée Hart
Law is in the air

Attorney and mediator in California with a modern practice in family law and pet law.