Why We Love a Sinister, Gothic Mystery: Lucy Foley’s, The Guest List

Suspects, suspense, & surprise

Melissa Gouty
Literature Lust
Published in
5 min readApr 30, 2021

--

Photo by Robert Thomas on Unsplash

Thanks to you, Nancy Drew

As a kid, I read every Nancy Drew mystery available. I’d get them at the library and haul home five or six at a time. My family was one of book lovers, and every birthday or Christmas, I’d get at least one teenaged-sleuthing-female-mystery-fighting Nancy Drew. Sometimes, for variety’s sake, I’d read The Hardy Boys, an old copy of the Bobbsey Twins, or an ancient book my grandmother had of The Boxcar Children.

Even in grade school, I was an eclectic reader, mixing mysteries with biographies and science with romance. I still am. But no doubt — thanks to Nancy Drew — the mystery genre heavily influenced my future choices.

Classic Gothics

As a young adult, I was mesmerized by Daphne DuMaurier’s “Gothic,” Rebecca, and its powerful combination of romance, distrust, disease, isolation, insecurity, and death. Jane Eyre provided the same titillating thrill of loneliness, creepiness, romance that gave me the heebie-jeebies the first time I read it.

Less classic, but still good reads, I pursued Barbara Michaels (aka Barbara Mertz) who also wrote Egyptian archeologist mysteries under the name of Elizabeth…

--

--

Melissa Gouty
Literature Lust

Writer, teacher, speaker, and observer of human nature. Content for HVAC & Plumbing Businesses. Author of The Magic of Ordinary. LiteratureLust and GardenGlory.