How Did Cyanide Get Into Bootleg Cannabis Vape Cartridges?

The definitive cause of vaping illness remains uncertain, but a cyanide-producing contaminant in illegal cannabis vapes became a “plausible explanation.” How did it get there?

Foster Winans
Sep 30, 2019 · 5 min read

[As reported on The Marijuana Times]

Updated Oct. 3, 2019

Last Friday (Sept. 28, 2019), two months after the national hunt for the cause of the vaping illness epidemic began in earnest, there were two dramatic developments that move us giant steps closer to identifying a culprit.

  • NBC News reported that it bought bootleg marijuana vapes that were tainted with a chemical that can produce cyanide at high temperatures.
  • Friday afternoon the Centers for Disease Control for the first time said that among deaths and illnesses from vaping, THC products “were the most prominent link.”

The NBC News segment aired Friday morning, reporting the results of tests the network had commissioned on black market (or “knock-off”) cannabis vape cartridges. The lab found the contents were contaminated with a fungicide which, when heated to more than 400 degrees fahrenheit, decomposes into hydrogen cyanide—the same poison the Nazi regime used in its gas chambers to murder millions. (Read the report by CannaSafe, the testing lab NBC used.)

Inhalation of cyanide could explain a Mayo Clinic report yesterday, that tests on a group of vape lung biopsies showed evidence of a “chemical burn” injury. Victims’ lungs had been scorched by “noxious chemical fumes.” In a brief email exchange yesterday, Dr. Brandon T. Larsen, a noted lung illness expert and lead investigator on the Mayo report, said chemical analyses of the biopsies are incomplete but a myclobutanil connection could be “a plausible explanation.”

The NBC story confirmed what The Marijuana Times has been reporting since Spring, before any vaping related cases had surfaced in the media—that there was a budding health crisis developing due to toxic pesticides and fungicides in illegal vape cartridges. As we reported then, Mendocino, California County Sheriff Thomas D. Allman had done what NBC did, only he did it six months earlier. He sent samples of seized knock-off vape cartridges to a lab. The finding—an astronomical level of contamination—so disturbed Sheriff Allman that he made a public health warning video and posted it on Facebook. He said he notified state officials but that as of last month none had followed up.

The CDC has reported common symptoms in vaping victims include coughing, shortness of breath, chest pain, difficulty breathing, nausea, and vomiting. The CDC website separately states:

“Breathing small amounts of hydrogen cyanide may cause headache, dizziness, weakness, nausea, and vomiting. Larger amounts may cause gasping, irregular heartbeats, seizures, fainting. Hydrogen cyanide … can produce death within minutes.”

The good news from the NBC tests was that the lab found none of the cyanide-producing chemical in cartridges bought from licensed dispensaries.

The bad news: NBC reported that “ten out of ten” cartridges bought from unlicensed black market dealers tested positive for myclobutanil which, according to The Dow Chemical Company (now Dow, Inc.), is the common name for an active ingredient in several fungicide products registered to one of its wholly owned subsidiaries. Eagle 20 and Nova 40 are two widely available brands that contain myclobutanil.

Myclobutanil is used around the world, especially in the US and China, on a wide range of perennial and annual crops, fruit trees, vines, and turf. One of the most common uses is on wine grapes, a major industry in California that depends on growing conditions similar to those that favor marijuana, another major California commodity. For each, mold and fungus is a major headache. An outbreak can destroy a year’s worth of work.

On grapes it’s not considered a threat to human health as the chemical is washed off before the fruit is processed for human consumption. Not so with marijuana. Myclobutanil is so dangerous when heated that it is banned on tobacco, is banned for use on marijuana in Canada, and in the states of Washington, Oregon, and Colorado. In 2017, scientists warned California pesticide regulators that myclobutanil “is incredibly dangerous in smokable cannabis.

The fungicide is especially dangerous in distilled cannabis. Vape oil is produced by leaching the THC elements out of marijuana leaves and stems with volatile chemicals until the psycho-active molecules are highly concentrated. The problem is that residual pesticides and fungicides in the plant also become super concentrated. The oil seized by Sheriff Allman tested at 7,300 times the state limit for myclobutanil in marijuana for public consumption.

According to David Kurzfeld, a partner and head of sales for Modular Processing Systems in Willits, California, which cleans dirty vape oil, careless outlaw pot growers are using myclobutanil in spite of Dow’s product safety specs: “Avoid exposure to elevated temperatures.” Crops that have been sprayed with it end up in the illegal vape oil supply chain, bought by processors who have no idea what might be in the weed they buy besides weed.

Image for post
Image for post
Website MerryJane.com says this is an example of a counterfeit version of a very popular brand of vape pen. To view dozens of other examples of black market brand knock-offs, click here.

Finally, illegal vape oil cartridges, often packaged to imitate a popular brand, are sold in unlicensed pop-up dispensaries and by underground dealers at a big discount to legal cannabis products. Prime markets are high school and college-aged men, which could explain why the majority of victims have been young men.

By the time the mystery is solved, it’s possible that the lung damage sustained by more than 1,000 vapers and the deaths of nearly two dozen and counting may be exacerbated by other contaminants, misuse of vaping devices, or some other element yet to be discovered. For now, the word on the street is loud and clear—stay away from black market vape cartridges.

The bootleg vaping epidemic appears to be energizing legalization and regulation movements. Congress could find itself under pressure to finally remove the restrictions that have made the cannabis black market so profitable, and thus enabled the scale of this tragedy.

Marijuana Wire by Foster Winans

Enterprise reporting and hard news from inside the…

Foster Winans

Written by

Former Wall Street Journal columnist; Career journalist; Senior Editor, The Marijuana Times (marijuanatimes.org). Full bio at linkedin.com/in/fosterwinans/.

Marijuana Wire by Foster Winans

Enterprise reporting and hard news from inside the marijuana business by Marijuana Times Senior Editor Foster Winans. Visit MarijuanaTimes.org.

Foster Winans

Written by

Former Wall Street Journal columnist; Career journalist; Senior Editor, The Marijuana Times (marijuanatimes.org). Full bio at linkedin.com/in/fosterwinans/.

Marijuana Wire by Foster Winans

Enterprise reporting and hard news from inside the marijuana business by Marijuana Times Senior Editor Foster Winans. Visit MarijuanaTimes.org.

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch

Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore

Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store