Betrayal in the Suburbs: Eye Drop Murder Case, The Dark Tale of Jessy Kurczewski and the Poisoned Friendship

True Crime Lounge
Memento Mori Desk
Published in
3 min readApr 7, 2024

--

In the quiet suburbs of Pewaukee, Wisconsin, a case unfolded that seemed more akin to the plot of a crime thriller than the events of everyday life. Jessy Kurczewski, a 39-year-old woman, found herself at the center of a chilling investigation following the mysterious death of her friend, 62-year-old Lynn Hernan. This narrative delves into the background, key events, and significant outcomes of a case that captivated and horrified the local community and beyond.

Betrayal in the Suburbs: Eye Drop Murder Case, The Dark Tale of Jessy Kurczewski and the Poisoned Friendship

A Friendship Turned Fatal

Jessy Kurczewski and Lynn Hernan shared a bond that, on the surface, appeared to be rooted in care and companionship. Kurczewski, who had taken on the role of Hernan’s caregiver, seemed to be a supportive presence in Hernan’s life, especially considering Hernan’s declining health. However, beneath this facade of friendship and care lay a dark and twisted tale of deceit and malice.

In October 2018, tragedy struck when Hernan was found dead in her home, seated in her living room recliner next to a table filled with prescription pills. Initially ruled as a drug overdose, the case took a dramatic turn when toxicological reports revealed a fatal dose of tetrahydrozoline, the main ingredient in over-the-counter eye…

--

--