Lifting the ban on S-300, Russia reminds West of its leverage in Middle East
Following Vladimir Putin’s decision to lift restrictions on the export of S-300 air defense systems to Iran, the Prime Minister of Israel Benjamin Netanyahu initiated a call to the Russian President only to be assured that the technical specifications of the system make it a purely defensive weapon. Although Russia and Iran agreed procurement of arms back in 2007, the 2010 ban by then President Medvedev, forced Iran to engage in a lengthy lawsuit of International Arbitration against Russia. International community and Israel lobbied hard for Russia’s ban of arms export to Iran.
Russia and Iran relations have stronger political-military dimension and economic cooperation remains to be hopeful to reach its potential. The announcement on April 13, 2015 includes the progress on oil-for-goods swap potentially worth $20 billion and would see Russia buy up to 500 ktpa of Iranian crude.
During “Direct line with Vladimir Putin”, a four hour long televised interview with media representatives, on April 17th Russian President cited a need to “encourage Iranian friends” in order to ensure continued cooperation in the nuclear negotiations. Since Russia’s sanctions of export of arms to Iran, were unilateral and done solely in order to support international sanctions regime and it no longer sees a need for the continuation of its abstinence. According to Putin, the S-300 system in possession of Iran, is a balancing factor in the Middle East.
The move itself from political-military and economic point of view is rational, since gaining a foothold in Iranian market prior to relief of sanctions is in the minds of investment funds and global multinationals alike. Increasing military technical cooperation with Iran, either through cooperation deals signed with Russian Minister of Defense Sergei Shoigu’s visit to Tehran last January, arms sale contracts that can support Russia’s military industrial complex cements Russia’s position of a prime supplier of Iranian market. Despite being a barter scheme, a procurement and re-sale of cheap Iranian crude oil is a strong motivation for reaching trade potential between two countries. The announcement however does not mean that Iran will drop the lawsuit and Russia will be able to supply the promised air defense system within short period of time.
The five S-300 divisions produced after 2007 agreement are already in the ranks of Russian armed forces and the system that has not been produced after 2010 export to China, and the plant has moved forward with more advanced models of the system. In the past Russia has offered Antey-2500, a more advanced variant of S-300, to Iran and the parties are likely to engage in time consuming talks over the lawsuit and the exact type of system to be supplied to Iran. Although Iranian Minister of Defense Hossein Dehghan said that the parties will finalize all details of a contract within a month and the contract shall be realized by the end of the year, the announcement proves that Russia and Iran are starting off where they left off in 2010. This time perhaps with more hurdles than motivations and given all the previously unrealized announcements on the sale of S-300 by Russia, there are no signs that this it will be different for Iran.
According to Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, the demonstration of Iran’s willingness and flexibility to reach an agreement with P5+1, through the Framework Agreement concluded in Lausanne, has given Russia a reason to believe that only the technical details of the Final Agreement remain to be sorted out before the June 30, 2015.
In his interview Putin, mentioned Israeli objection to the potential sale of S-300 to another Middle Eastern country and subsequent Russian consultation with the potential buyer to cancel the sales agreement. Russian leadership rarely misses an opportunity to stress the role of Red Army in carrying the brunt of fight against Nazism and thankful words of Chief Rabbi of Russia Berel Lazar for saving the Jewish people together with substantial Russian speaking population of Israel underline the strong people-to-people relationship between Israel and Russia.
Given the recent change of position by President Obama, who has recently yielded to the pressure from the Republicans, allowing the Congress to have a voice in the proposed nuclear deal with Iran, and the Iranian Parliament producing “Factsheet” suggesting revisions for the Framework Agreement reached in Lausanne, lifting of the ban on S-300 exports comes at a not best time for the proponents of the Nuclear Deal. Whether the air defense system is a game-changer or not, the lifting of bans will definitely serve the rhetoric of those opposing the Final Nuclear Agreement between P5+1 and Islamic Republic of Iran, both in Washington and Tehran.
This development is a sober reminder of Russia’s substantial politico-military leverage in the Middle East that goes beyond its historic support of Assad regime in Syria. The S-300 saga continues and perhaps the key asset for Russia is not the actual supply of air defense systems, but rather its continued ability to provide the ones that can significantly improve Iran’s ability to counter outside threat. Despite Russia’s support for international sanctions regime, at a cost of its relationship with Iran, it was not rewarded in any manner and this time around if nuclear negotiations fail, Russia is unlikely to support it. One might argue that Iran is competitor of Russia in energy markets, and that it has little interest in seeing Iranian products in the international markets. However this view is a long-term perspective whereas cementing Russia’s position in Middle East, especially during these volatile times, is a short-term gain with tangible benefits for sanctioned and relatively isolated Russia.
Munkhnaran Bayarlkhagva (Washington DC) — Research Associate of Global Growth Advisors GGA — strategic consulting firm and leading advisor on business and political strategies. www.globalgrowthadvisors.com
Roozbeh Aliabadi (New York/Tehran) — Managing Partner of Global Growth Advisors GGA — strategic consulting firm and leading advisor on business and political strategies. www.globalgrowthadvisors.com
*This piece has been submitted to PressTV Viewpoint for publications.