Air Travel in Academia: Designing a carbon offsets program for the MIT Media Lab
Our planet’s warming climate presents an imminent and catastrophic challenge that will have far-reaching economic, social, and political ramifications. As residents of a wealthy, developed nation, we contribute more to climate change than the average global citizen. At MIT, as globally connected citizens with many opportunities for work- and research-related air travel, many of us contribute more to climate change than the average American.
For many individuals at the Media Lab, who travel around the world to collaborate on research projects, present at conferences, and lead workshops, research-related air travel represents a huge proportion of their annual greenhouse-gas emissions. For example, a single economy class seat on a flight from Boston to Los Angeles is responsible for the same carbon emissions as 110 days of driving a car. We wanted to do more to educate the Media Lab community about the impact of our collective air travel and improve the Lab’s sustainability. While the best way to reduce our carbon footprint would be to take fewer airplane flights, this solution isn’t always possible or desirable given the research opportunities that require air travel.
Instead, we decided to start a pilot program through which we’ll buy high-quality carbon offsets to reduce the climate impact of the Lab’s collective air travel. Though carbon offset programs have been criticized in the past for giving people an excuse for irresponsible climate behavior, carbon offset verification has improved drastically in the past decade. When it is infeasible to reduce overall air travel mileage, the purchase of high-quality, verified carbon offsets will fund projects that produce renewable energy and avoid future carbon emissions. In our pilot program, we plan to buy carbon offsets through Gold Standard, a certified offset provider who verifies that their offset projects, like distributing clean cooking stoves, investing in wind power plants, and regenerating forests, both reduce carbon emissions and also meet the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals.
During the six-month pilot program, we are asking members of the Media Lab community to log their lab-related air miles through a simple web interface. At the end of each month we’ll tally the air miles travelled by the community, calculate the carbon emissions associated with those flights, and purchase offsets through Gold Standard to offset the impact of those flights. We hope that the program will spark a discussion about our climate behavior while contributing to a global model of sustainability!
While putting together the pilot program, we ran into a few surprising data and design issues. First, we learned that gathering data — and knowing which data to collect — was trickier than expected. What exactly counts as “Lab-related” travel, and is there some centralized system that tracks the Lab’s air mileage? It turns out that no such system exists. While MIT maintains careful financial accounting, there hasn’t been a reason to specifically track mileage before, and the ability to do so is not built into the university’s accounting systems.
We also wrestled with interesting questions around user participation. While we wanted to encourage as many people as possible to participate in order to collect the most accurate travel data, we also didn’t want to incentivize people to travel more than they do already. And, we didn’t want people to vacate a sense of responsibility by knowing their travel was being offset. In the process of putting together this pilot, we learned of other groups at MIT and at other universities who are developing carbon offset programs. In other cases, offset programs are top-down: offsets are automatically purchased through finance or logistics channels. These programs don’t have to deal with user participation challenges and likely have more accurate data totals, but they also miss the opportunity to engage the community in a substantive conversation around air travel emissions.
After thinking carefully about our goals for the project, we decided that soliciting travel data from the community would do the most to raise awareness about the issue — and it was also a cheap and easy way to kick off a pilot! So far, we seem to have succeeded in generating discussion: after launching the pilot several weeks ago, we’ve received a few dozen messages communicating enthusiasm, asking questions, and raising concerns. We are planning to send monthly update emails to the Media Lab community, and host several discussion groups at the end of the pilot to evaluate the program and figure out what to do next. Through this pilot we hope to learn about what makes an effective carbon offsets program, and pass this knowledge on to groups at MIT and other schools who are trying to implement university-wide offset programs. So, if you’re interested, please read more at offset.media.mit.edu (and log your air miles if you’re at the Media Lab)! When the pilot is complete we’ll publish a follow-up post to share our findings.