Zuckerberg’s New Privacy Essay Shows Why Facebook Needs to Be Broken Up

Mark Zuckerberg doesn’t understand what privacy means — he can’t be trusted to define it for the rest of us

MIT Technology Review
MIT Technology Review

--

Illustration: Ms. Tech; photo sources: Facebook/Whatsapp/Oculus/Instagram

In a letter published when his company went public in 2012, Mark Zuckerberg championed Facebook’s mission of making the world “more open and connected.” Businesses would become more authentic, human relationships stronger, and government more accountable. “A more open world is a better world,” he wrote.

Facebook’s CEO now claims to have had a major change of heart.

In “A Privacy-Focused Vision for Social Networking,” a 3,200-word essay that Zuckerberg posted to Facebook on March 6, he says he wants to “build a simpler platform that’s focused on privacy first.” In apparent surprise, he writes: “People increasingly also want to connect privately in the digital equivalent of the living room.”

Zuckerberg’s essay is a power grab disguised as an act of contrition. Read it carefully, and it’s impossible to escape the conclusion that if privacy is to be protected in any meaningful way, Facebook must be broken up.

Facebook grew so big, so quickly that it defies categorization. It is a newspaper. It is a post office and a telephone exchange. It is a forum…

--

--

MIT Technology Review
MIT Technology Review

Reporting on important technologies and innovators since 1899