Member-only story

No One is Indispensable

The story of Bill & Lou, and believing the grass is greener on “the other side”

Jillian Enright
neurodiversified
9 min readJan 7, 2025

--

Created by author on Canva

This is part two of a two-part mini-series. If you haven’t read part one, I recommend doing that first.

When I left off, I was agreeing that, having brought domestic animals into our society and “incorporated them into our schemes of social co-operation”, we owe them a duty of care above our inadequate standards of welfare. That said, the arguments put forth by co-authors Kymlicka and Donaldson to support their claim that citizenship would accomplish this are highly flawed.

No one is indispensable

In their 2014 article Animals and the Frontiers of Citizenship, co-authors Kymlicka and Donaldson assert “because [Bill and Lou] were not recognized as full members, their very existence was precarious, and subject to crude instrumental calculus”. Unfortunately citizenship has nothing to do with it, although I wish it were so easy to compel others to value a life. Citizens are killed or allowed to die avoidable deaths every day in North America.

As one example, more than one thousand people have been killed by police in the United States in 2024. This subject is much too complex to delve into here, and not the focus of this paper, however it must be noted that…

--

--

neurodiversified
neurodiversified

Published in neurodiversified

We write about ADHD, Autism, twice exceptionality, neurodiversity, parenting, advocacy, and education. We’re unique, just like everybody else.

Jillian Enright
Jillian Enright

Written by Jillian Enright

She/they. Neurodivergent, 20+ yrs SW & Psych. experience. I write about mental health, neurodiversity, education, and parenting. Founder of Neurodiversity MB.

No responses yet