Analysis of the Lightning network routing problems reported by DIAR

Mattia Franzoni
Jul 9, 2018 · 4 min read
Image for post
Image for post

A study conducted by Diar on June 29 has revealed that Lightning Network technology wouldn’t be so effective, the reliability that successful routing payment is still rather low, especially when high amounts are used. The probability of a LN payment success using a few dollars is 70%, while the success rate for a payment of about $ 200 is 1%.

This happens because not all nodes have channels with a capacity equal to the above-mentioned amount or with larger amounts, making it difficult to find a routing between the various nodes available.

Image for post
Image for post
Diar (source: website)

As explained in the previous article published by DIAR (https://diar.co/volume-2-issue-25/), which, moreover, would seem to be contradictory to the analysis they themselves carried out.

This problem can be solved in a fairly simple way; if all nodes participating in the same LN had a capacity with larger amounts, there wouldn’t be any more relevant problems regarding routing, because precisely, routes would be found more easily, assuming, for example, that the capacity of each node is increased to a minimum of $ 200.

LIGHTNING NETWORK TECHNOLOGY

Image for post
Image for post

Lightning Network technology is a way to solve the blockchain scalability. With a high number of transactions, commission costs increase dramatically due to the problem of poor network scalability. LN is creating a solution to ensure that not all user transactions are not immediately recorded within a blockchain block. To make this solution possible, payment channels are opened between two parties who make an off-chain transfer possible by reducing commission costs and increasing the transactions’ number.

Only when the channel will be closed, the transactions made inside will be included in the blockchian.

Being an optional extension, however, it is necessary that users and services move their transactions on special wallets and also for this reason, this transition which is happening appear so slow.

Image for post
Image for post
Peter Todd (see the Twitter profile)

It would seem that from this study the data, conducted by Diar, the dream of being able to solve bitcoin scalability problem vanishes, but Peter Todd (dev Bitcoin Core) and Elizabeth Stark — the co-founder of Lightning Labs — don’t agree with this study.

It seems that the Diar study is actually highlighting the obvious, which had already been underlined by developers and everyone knows what is happening with the Lightning Network building. It is true that there is a high probability of failure for larger amounts on LN as it is, but that it has never been hidden and has never needed to be discovered.

Even Christian Decker, an LN technology guru, stood against this study stating that the information of their discoveries had always been available and never hidden from fans.

Peter Todd told to Cointelegraph:

Users seem not to have given too much weight to the Peter Todd’s words, incorrectly listening to the developers’ advices which claim to invest little money in the LN channels, probably for fear of repercussions from the community that could lose money invested. Surely, if you are afraid of experiencing evolution, progress is slower.

Image for post
Image for post
Jonas Schnelli (see the Twitter profile)

Jonas Schnelli, one of the main developers of Bitcoin reiterates the limits deliberately imposed by developers about the LN beta test and he tells to Cointelegraph:

It would seem that Diar created this study only to talk about himself, saying obvious things for the sector experts, deceiving the less experienced, denigrating technology in development which is still not ready for the general public.

CREDITS

This article was originally written in Italian by Mattia Franzoni and translated in English by Stefania Stimolo for NovaMining.


NovaMining Media

News, updates, insights from our emerging startup into…

Mattia Franzoni

Written by

Blockchain Enthusiast, Transhumanist, Biohacker, Miner . I spend my life to discovering new things.

NovaMining Media

News, updates, insights from our emerging startup into blockchain industry

Mattia Franzoni

Written by

Blockchain Enthusiast, Transhumanist, Biohacker, Miner . I spend my life to discovering new things.

NovaMining Media

News, updates, insights from our emerging startup into blockchain industry

Welcome to a place where words matter. On Medium, smart voices and original ideas take center stage - with no ads in sight. Watch
Follow all the topics you care about, and we’ll deliver the best stories for you to your homepage and inbox. Explore
Get unlimited access to the best stories on Medium — and support writers while you’re at it. Just $5/month. Upgrade

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store