Necessity, invention and The Daily Tar Heel
We’re turning our balance sheets into a learning lab for college and community media.
The Daily Tar Heel is a news organization, and we don’t dodge the facts: This 123-year-old institution has two years to figure out its finances.
This is not the first thing a new general manager wants to say to her community, but there’s only one way forward that I can see, and we have to take the direct route.
The course we’re setting demands candor, collaboration and creativity.
Let me offer you a little of each.
Since 2011, the DTH has operated with a deficit, shortfalls that were filled in by our investment accounts. In recent years, the annual deficit has hovered north of $200,000. When I was hired earlier this month, our investment accounts were just below $400,000.
Our investment fund’s strength obscured the fact that the DTH was slowly approaching the same moment that has shaken every legacy media organization in the world.
Like most newspapers, our historic business model was built on a robust market for print advertising, and a bet that digital advertising could eventually replace it. Print still has power, but we have to forget our old assumptions that we know best what people want. If we want to sustain the DTH’s excellence in journalism, we must provide necessary service (or sets of services) for our neighbors. We have to help solve their problems.
I am not making light of our financial situation when I say that there is something marvelously concentrating about financial reality. The will of this organization has turned toward solutions.
The Daily Tar Heel is rare in student media: We are the independent, nonprofit media lab for the University of North Carolina’s young journalists, advertising pros and creative talent. We don’t receive money from the university — we earn every penny we spend — and we are led by a majority-student board of directors. The editor-in-chief, who is always a student, has complete control of our news content.
That’s a tradition. We have many. In 2018, The Daily Tar Heel will celebrate our 125th year.
We’ll do it in start-up mode.
WHAT’S GREAT: We have a lot of legacy assets, including a national reputation for excellence; a position as the primary news source for the university, Chapel Hill, Hillsborough, and the surrounding counties; a deep roster of creative and talented students; and plenty of infrastructure.
WHAT’S HARD: We also carry legacy costs, particularly a business model that relies on printing and distribution as a way to serve the advertisers who support our journalism.
WHAT’S HAPPENING: Starting next week, The Daily Tar Heel will eliminate our Tuesday print edition. It’s the first of many steps that will help us extend the two-year runway for our launch into the future.
I want to spend a little time on the concerns behind my recommendation and the board’s vote.
Journalists and their communities both feel the literal and metaphorical heft of words and photos created, edited, fact-checked, and ultimately printed on paper. The printed word signals investment and significance, even when, as with newspapers, the entire thing changes every day. For most young journalists, it’s an honor and a responsibility to hold a newspaper with their work in it.
One challenge of the digital cataclysm is how to convey that sense of power and civic pride to every generation when digital publication is available to anyone with access to the internet.
As we move to all-digital Tuesdays, we’re challenging ourselves to find new ways of serving the community. (Read Editor-in-Chief Jane Wester’s thoughts on this point.) We want to deliver powerful, fascinating stories that use the full potential of video, audio, images and words.
While we expect to make other sacrifices in order to extend our runway for experimentation and development, printing four days a week will be the most visible to our community.
Candidly? I hope that the other visible changes to The Daily Tar Heel will demonstrate intense commitment to find a way forward — for ourselves and for others. Which brings us to …
I’ll start with a pitch: The Daily Tar Heel is an independent, nonprofit organization with 501(c)(3) status. One way that we hope to collaborate is by asking our donors and supporters to identify what they most value about the DTH by supporting a section of the paper (what we call a “desk” here — the university desk covers campus, “statnat” covers state and national news) or a particular mission.
You can help us identify what matters to you by clicking here and giving in support of:
- Our sports department’s travel to away games (which will cost just under $8,000 this year)
- Our multimedia units of photographers, podcasters and video journalists
- Our reporting staff
- The software, web development and hardware that allow us to share our work far beyond our delivery routes
We’re taking a page from public media: Our journalism is always free, but we expect to provide DTH supporters with benefits, including pre-season conference calls with our sports staff, and early or discounted access to our workshops and events.
We are also open to in-kind donations of time, service and expertise. Let me know what you have to share, and how we can work together. (I’m easy to find at email@example.com.)
We’d like your help right now. But the help is not just for the DTH.
The Daily Tar Heel’s challenges are new to us, but they’re not unique. Community journalism — the act of putting questions to power, watchdogging, and sharing a community’s knowledge and stories — is a fundamental civic activity. It also takes a lot of time, or a lot of money, and sometimes both.
News organizations across the world share the question of how to support this undertaking. In Chapel Hill, we’re lucky: Our peerless asset is a motivated group of students who write the news, sell ads that connect the business community to campus, and create marketing, advertising and brand services for local agencies, nonprofits and businesses. They are an enviable resource.
We want those resources to benefit our neighbors, employing some of our under-used assets (space, expertise, creative capacity) to help those around us solve their problems, either by trading resources or charging modest fees for our services.
We also want to parlay what we have and do into shared knowledge, figuring out solutions and models that can benefit other communities. We can help preserve the community journalism that underpins our democracy. We are interested in finding partners who are doing what we do, and learning together.
We are going to work in public — this post is the first of many, and most of our future posts will share a new idea, or report on our experiments as a way of helping other news organizations.
And we do have new ideas. Lots. Here are a few that we expect to execute in the 2015–2016 school year:
NEW SECTIONS: We have long and often been asked why The Daily Tar Heel doesn’t provide engagement, wedding and anniversary announcements, or obituaries. Starting Sept. 19, we do.
NEW OR EXPANDED SERVICES: We’re in a pilot phase now; in 2017, The Daily Tar Heel will launch a creative services agency — a group of skilled, creative students led by an experienced agency director, offering graphic design, video, photography, social media and sponsored content creation to the business community at a range of rates, and with DTH excellence.
We’ll also help local business create powerful, meaningful ways to connect companies to the campus — whether it’s inviting them to sponsor DTH and a Doughnut or adding tiers of options at our fall and spring Heels Housing fairs.
NEW EVENTS: This fall, The Daily Tar Heel will pilot events for the communities in our coverage area, which will expand into a full calendar in 2017.
Our focus, as always, is on public service, storytelling and education. These events — many of which will be free to the people who attend — reflect that our readership includes students, professors, and longtime residents and neighbors.
DTH workshops and events are available for sponsorship and collaboration, and might include things like:
- A “Swerve” story slam to launch our new arts-and-student-life project and collect stories to fuel it.
- A write-your-own-obituary workshop (think of it as a micro-memoir) with a brief primer on end-of-life planning from a sponsoring local business or organization. (Here is my favorite obit of all time.)
- An iPhone video workshop for athletes and their parents, with a short information session about a relevant, sports-related skill or topic from a sponsoring local business or organization.
We’re going to offer our customized workshops across the community, which will let us deliver self-identified, high-interest consumers to the sponsoring business, and to create advertising around the event and its sponsor.
We’re also developing classes and training camps that capitalize on and sharpen our core skills: workshops for writers, photographers, designers and storytellers across media in the campus community and beyond.
Clayton Christensen and David Skok observed in “Breaking News” that opportunity comes alongside change: “News organizations should challenge their own assumptions by looking beyond their existing business models for new ways of finding value. … The question of how best to survive in the new world will not be answered by hoping for a return to the past.”
The Daily Tar Heel, steeped in history but led by students, has always turned its face toward the future. The years ahead are no exception.
If you want to follow along as we try, fail, succeed and study our own efforts to keep improving, watch this space. And thanks for joining us.
Betsy O’Donovan is the general manager of The Daily Tar Heel. She is an 18-year veteran of community newsrooms, an editorial adviser in the public media system, and was a 2013 Nieman fellow at Harvard University, where she studied media business models and storytelling.