2020: When a Janus-Faced America Reared Its Ugly Head

John Tuttle
Dec 29, 2020 · 4 min read
Image for post
Image for post
Image via Gallup.

Putting it lightly, the past year has been a milieu of outbreaks — those of infectious illness and those which decried social and political agendas. It’s a blunt statement, but it does not require much elaboration. We have all lived through it.

We have experienced the hypocrisy of inconsistent mask-wearing mandates — across stores, offices, and institutions with varying procedures and, seemingly, varying levels of concern. As the year progressed, we moved through a gradation of confronting COVID-19 and then producing what counterattacks we could.

Awareness led to response and response to prevention. Even so, the tallies of confirmed coronavirus cases and associated deaths have continued to fluctuate, as has the mood of the country.

The protests, the establishment and fall of CHAZ in Seattle, the vehemently opposing political views regarding the election: all showcase what America has morphed into. We have become a population of maximalists who have gone so far as to refuse to listen to ideas and opinions from viewpoints that differ from our own.

The thesis of Jonathan Freedland’s Guardian column, that 2020 merely accentuated the tendencies (polarization not least among them) that were lurking beneath the surface of society, is one which hardly leaves room for opposition.

Unlike the political situation a quarter of a century ago, polarization in America can no longer be denied.

As early as January 2020, the journalism branch of the Pew Research Center noted that the year promised a “heated” election period, while the two major political parties adhered to “two nearly inverse news media environments.”

Additionally, while Democrats are open to gaining news from a number of sources and not so much from others, the report’s data asserts Republicans have a lot of trust in their chief source of Fox News with little trust placed in alternative outlets.

The general public, including politicians, get to experience the news buffet style, picking and choosing what suits their own ideological preferences. We have the power to tune out anything else that doesn’t particularly agree with us. Perhaps the demise of objective, authentic journalism witnessed its crescendo this past year.

Trickling down from this media influence, itself already polarized, society — the media consumer — has likewise become polarized, splitting more stringently into opposing factions. As Freedland and others have observed, this has been happening for some time now. But it has really been seen at the forefront of this year’s societal crises. Misinformation in an hour that calls for clarity is a scary thing.

2020 was hence a year of extremism. A slew of mantras and calls for action made it into the media spotlight in recent months.

We need to close non-essential businesses. We need to ease up on restrictions and revitalize the economy. Defund the police. Defund National Public Radio. STOP THE COUNT. Then later, Recount the votes.

Calling for change and a healthy sense of political rivalry are essential parts of American society, without which tyranny is given a broad reign. But what we are experiencing deviates from this mentality. No longer are there many bases where representatives of differing political perspectives can come together, listen to one another, and debate in a civilized manner.

In the “civilized” forums for such debate, politicians might often be described as hearers only, not listeners. Even within their respective parties, the Democrats and Republicans experience a polarized atmosphere. Early 2020 brought unrest among Democrats as many vied for the presidential nomination. And as the year has progressed, outspoken Republicans, such as Senator Mitt Romney, have frowned upon President Trump’s decisions and rhetoric on any number of issues.

There is a barrier people are putting between themselves that’s in just as much need of discussion as Trump’s border wall or social distancing. This is the psychological barrier we are digging around ourselves. We put limits on who and what we will listen to and with whom we will strike up a conversation. This divide has resulted in a severe rift between liberal and conservative groups — an ever-widening pit left between two sides of the same nation drifting farther apart.

Mark Sappenfield, editor at the Christian Science Monitor, writes that “American voters are increasingly defining themselves by their partisan identity,” and this produces “two clear camps, one liberal and one conservative, with almost nothing in between.” In politics, this mindset causes a lack of legislation; in society, a condescending, often hate-filled rivalry between fellow citizens.

In 2020, we saw our country for what it is: a Janus-faced America. Yet, despite the extremes we have confronted this year, there might be a way of turning away from this “great divide.”

Change will have to start within society, for it’s our society from which rise the policymakers, journalists, and influencers of the future. As with precautions against COVID-19, change for the better begins with you and me. Acknowledgment and proper concern start with us. Like wearing a mask or keeping your distance, it may begin with simple steps such as open dialogue and listening to those around us.

Of Intellect and Interest

This is the Medium extension for the original website Of…

John Tuttle

Written by

Journalist and creative. Words @ The Hill, Submittable, The Millions, Tablet Magazine, GMP, University Bookman, Prehistoric Times: jptuttleb9@gmail.com.

Of Intellect and Interest

This is the Medium extension for the original website Of Intellect and Interest (https://johntuttleswriting.wordpress.com/) founded by John Tuttle in 2017. Here we talk about pop culture, entertainment, science, Catholicism, history, photography, writing, and much more.

John Tuttle

Written by

Journalist and creative. Words @ The Hill, Submittable, The Millions, Tablet Magazine, GMP, University Bookman, Prehistoric Times: jptuttleb9@gmail.com.

Of Intellect and Interest

This is the Medium extension for the original website Of Intellect and Interest (https://johntuttleswriting.wordpress.com/) founded by John Tuttle in 2017. Here we talk about pop culture, entertainment, science, Catholicism, history, photography, writing, and much more.

Medium is an open platform where 170 million readers come to find insightful and dynamic thinking. Here, expert and undiscovered voices alike dive into the heart of any topic and bring new ideas to the surface. Learn more

Follow the writers, publications, and topics that matter to you, and you’ll see them on your homepage and in your inbox. Explore

If you have a story to tell, knowledge to share, or a perspective to offer — welcome home. It’s easy and free to post your thinking on any topic. Write on Medium

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store