Review of Tolkien (2019): How the Author’s Real-Life Story Compares to the Film

When watching a non-fiction biographical film, there are two separate and fundamental questions which deserve to be asked — and answered. First off, does the film present genuine characters, a decent plot, and inevitably an entertaining product? High standards, yes. But cinema is an art form, and these points are just as good as any to begin a critique. Secondly, and primarily in regard to non-fiction productions, does the film portray historical events and figures accurately?

This latter question carries its weight in that it ultimately seeks to know whether or not a modern feature film can convey a historical story with authenticity and in reality. Karukoski’s Tolkien (2019) provides answers to both questions, though it does not completely satisfy the latter. This review contains spoilers.

What Were the Highlights of the Movie

The movie itself is beautifully filmed. The cast assembled under this Dome Karukoski production consists of veteran movie stars as well as new…